Wednesday, March 02, 2011

American Idol 10 - Top 12 Boys

So I haven't had much time to blog lately, and that's especially the case this week with me being on afternoon shift (not exactly the best week for the American Idol live shows to start!). But I will do my best to get through last night's episode, where the top 12 boys sang from a pretty wide-open theme. There were a few stand-outs as well as some disappointments. Let's see how it all shook down:

Clint Jun Gamboa - "Superstition" by Stevie Wonder : I don't know if I was totally impressed with Clint's rendition of a song that's been overly-done on American Idol through the years. Yes, he definitely can sing as I did not detect too many botched notes. However, he did tend to overdue it with the runs and over sang at times. It is a very energetic song to perform and he definitely had people clap along. He certainly is no karaoke singer and proves that he has the vocal chops but I wasn't totally won over quite yet.

Jovany Barreto - "I'll Be" by Edwin McCain : The song is kind of a safe one for Jovany to pick as he did not change it up too much from the original. I was actually pretty bored by his performance and it was just okay. There's no question he can sing; heck they all can if they made it to this point in the competition. But he has to bring a lot more fire and intensity if he wants to make it further than the top 24. It probably would've done him better if he selected a song a little more upbeat, or if it had a more upbeat chorus. "I'll Be" is pretty much a simple, syrupy ballad and it did not do Jovany any justice.

Jordan Dorsey - "OMG" by Usher : I'll let you in on a little secret (last night's episode was actually taped this past Friday!)... so, spoilers were released as to which songs each of the boys picked. Usually I can't wait to find these things out, so I checked it out and to me, Jordan's choice of this song probably left me the most bewildered. It isn't a song that allows an individual to really show off their vocal abilities. I mean sure, it's a fun, upbeat song but it does not cater to a singers vocals. And just as I figured last week, it was not a good song for Jordan. Unfortunately I don't think he'll make it beyond this week.

Tim Halperin - "Streetcorner Symphony (Come on Over)" by Rob Thomas : I can honestly say that from out of the top 12 guys, Tim is probably the least I know about. He kind of flew under the radar, even though he did get screen time prior to the live rounds starting. I'm not sure that this particular song did Tim any justice. It started off pretty underwhelming and it kind of ate him up. I don't think he's all that comfortable performing on stage without a piano in front of him. It was just an okay performance for me as he could've done much more to the song to make it his own. To me at this point, he's just an average singer.

Brett Loewenstern - "Light my Fire" by the Doors : So Brett is one contestant we've been following right from the very beginning and could be considered as one of the early favorites. I must say his song choice was a little odd as I figured he would pick something a little more contemporary. However, I think he did a pretty decent job with it. I wouldn't say it was his best vocal, particularly early on in the song. But I think he did make a pretty positive impression on the voting public tonight (if he didn't already). Brett is definitely unique and different, and that should help in his favor.

James Durbin - "You've Got Another Thing Comin'" by Judas Priest : James is a bit of a controversial contestant, especially in regards to his stage-parents comment during Hollywood week. However, he does have a bit of an endearing side to him, too. He really wants to make it big with a singing career. And honestly, out of all of the male contestants tonight, I think James' performance was the best of the night. It was controlled, he didn't overdue it with the rock screech and it was an absolute fun song to hear James perform. It was as if he was already a professional on stage. He certainly hit a home run with this song.

Robbie Rosen - "Arms of an Angel" by Sarah McLachlan : Robbie was one of those stand-out younger contestants featured during the early rounds of the show who could go far, if he can just get through the semi-finals! He did a pretty decent job with the song vocally, although it wasn't totally perfect. However, it was a boring and safe song choice. If I would've watched it live, I probably would have been in danger of dozing off. He needs to carefully choose his songs; there's no question he can sing great ballads, but it needs to be a ballad with a little more energy, too.

Scotty McCreery - "Letters from Home" by John Michael Montgomery : Scotty needs no formal introduction; he could quite possibly be this season's most famous contestant thus far. No real surprises from Scotty this week as he stays true to his roots and selects a country song. And I think that's good because if he chose to take a risk and deviate away from country and fails miserably, he could never recover. And he did a solid job performing "Letters from Home." I wouldn't say it was anything outstanding, but it was much better than a lot of the performances we saw last night. He certainly has great quality and control with his vocals.

Stefano Langone - "Just the Way You Are" by Bruno Mars : Stefano is going very contemporary with this Bruno Mars hit and he does an admiral job with it. Obviously it wasn't perfect particularly in the end with that falsetto, but it was pretty decent. I enjoy it more when a contestant chooses a song that's more relevant to today - not that there's anything wrong with songs in the past. But more people, particularly the younger voters, can relate to a modern song more. I really enjoy the tenor sound to his voice - he's another contestant that can stray higher in his range and still be comfortable doing so.

Paul McDonald - "Maggie Mae" by Rod Stewart : Here's a contestant who has the ability to make anyone smile when he sings. Yes, he's quirky and unique and he's also a pretty good performer. Just look at the way he acted on stage last night; just like a true professional. I think "Maggie Mae" is a song that suited Paul well and he did an exceptional job choosing it. And yes, the way he moves around on stage is a little quirky as well; fits in perfectly with Paul's style. I think he already has a big audience following and he should be able to advance quite far.

Jacob Lusk - "House is Not a Home" by Luther Vandross : Here's the guy that is totally passionate about singing and really gets so emotionally involved within a song. Earlier on, we did not really know too much about Jacob, that is until he blew the box out of "God Bless the Child." Now Jacob has become a household name. He was back in true form last night singing "House is Not a Home," infusing his own style into the song, yet still keeping true to the original. He is such a delightful contestant and honestly, a breath of fresh air to the Idol stage. At this point there's nothing that Jacob cannot do.

Casey Abrams - "I Put a Spell On You" by Jay Hawkins : My goodness, what a potentially great season we have unfolding, and we haven't even seen the girls perform yet! Casey is another one of those unique birds, as we saw him perform with a large bass instrument during Hollywood and do exceptionally well with it! I liked it last night that he took an old classic and brought it to the forefront on American Idol and knocked it out of the park. Was it as unique memorable as some of his Hollywood performances? Probably not, but it was still a great way to end last night's episode.

Top 12 Boys Performance Rankings:
1: James Durbin
2: Jacob Lusk
3: Scotty McCreery
4: Casey Abrams
5: Paul McDonald
6: Stefano Langone
7: Clint Jun Gamboa
8: Brett Loewenstern
9: Robbie Rosen
10: Jovany Barreto
11: Tim Halperin
12: Jordan Dorsey

And there we have it, the first night of live performances is in the books (although it wasn't technically live). All in all, it was a decent night with the latter half of the episode being the best. Tonight, it's all up to the girls to show off their vocal talents. Be sure to check back here tomorrow for a recap of that.

No comments: