Showing posts with label Allison Iraheta. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Allison Iraheta. Show all posts

Saturday, May 30, 2009

American Idol 8 - Season Wrap-Up

It's been a little over a week in a half now since our newest American Idol was crowed, that being 23-year old Arkansas native Kris Allen. Going into the finale, I was happy with either he or Adam Lambert at this season's champion. And I'll admit, even though I picked Kris Allen to win, I was still rather shocked he won. And he was genuinely shocked as well. Well who can blame him, really? All season long, he's flown under the radar and truly fit the mold of being a dark horse. The judges and producers had pimped Danny Gokey and Adam Lambert right from the start of the competition and they both had peaked at different points. In my opinion, I never thought Danny Gokey lived up to the hype. He had a few decent performances during his run to the top three, but nothing that I would define as being memorable. As for Adam, he probably peaked earlier in the top 13 and was consistently good week upon week. As for Kris, he kept bringing it week after week and really created some memorable performances in the end. What vaulted him into becoming the newest Idol was his rendition of Kanye West's "Heartless."

I like to think that this was this season's revenge for David Archuleta losing in season seven. For anyone out there reading and who's into American Idol, wouldn't you say Kris Allen and Archie have similar personalities and singing styles? Archuleta wasn't nearly as outgoing when he was on the show like he is now - and that might have turned some people off. Meanwhile, Kris Allen definitely is more reserved and quiet, and he even says he's a chill guy. However, I think he was more vocal on stage than Archueta. Whatever the case, it still came down to being a singing competition. Archuleta delivered solid performances week after week and even included some pretty memorable moments towards the end of the competition with "Stand by Me" and "Don't Let the Sun Go Down on Me." Kris Allen did the same with "Heartless" and "Ain't no Sunshine." Archie played on the piano - but only a couple of times in the Idol stage compared to Allen's multiple instrument-infused performances throughout the entire season. So Kris is much more instrument-trained than Archie is at this point. However, whatever the case may be, they both had similar singing styles and delivered solid performances week in and week out. However, as Archuleta rose to front-runner status early on, Kris built a small amount of momentum early on and it kept building more and more each week. David peaked early on, much like Adam and Danny did, which may have cost him the competition in the end. Kris' building fanbase, the elimination of Danny Gokey in top three week, and his version of "Heartless" creating one of those all-time moments on Idol really vaulted him into winning the Idol crown. And the more I think of it, you know what would be an awesome duet? David Archuleta and Kris Allen. That is really something I would look forward to.

So where does this leave Adam Lambert and will he suffer from losing the title? In my opinion, this has the potential of helping him more than hurting him. If Adam had won the Idol crown, he may have been more restricted as to what he could make in an album. 19 might've forced him to go the pop music route. And he still might do some of that, however, I don't believe the entirety of his album will be composed of pop-sounding music. I guess the big question is - will his music be radio-friendly and will he achieve success like that of a Chris Daughtry who proved winning Idol isn't necessarily important? I definitely believe Adam has some challenges in becoming a music star. Now as he's proven even before his stint on Idol, he could become a major star on broadway. He's commented that he's never performed in New York - well with the right offer, he just might get that chance. I guess all that will depend on whether his music career takes off right away after the show has commenced.

Overall, I would say season eight ended up being much more enjoyable than I originally thought going into the top 13. A lot of talented singers emerged and much of them have potential to become successful in the entertainment industry. Obviously with his win, Kris Allen could become a big star. The music he created on Idol is radio-friendly and he is likely to incorporate the same sound into his debut album. Having him be the newest American Idol makes sense because the Idol-image fits him the most versus Adam Lambert. I already discussed Adam Lambert so I won't talk too much more about him other than to say he needs to hit the ground running right out of the gate in order for him to have a successful music career. Otherwise broadway might be calling or he'll become a reality show star other than for American Idol. As for Danny Gokey, I don't see him having a very successful musical career, other than singing gospel music. He came into Idol not knowing much mainstream music and even after Idol, he seems lost and hasn't defined himself musically. I'd be surprised to hear one tune from Gokey on the radio. Allison Iraheta definitely has some potential to be a radio success. She needs to be placed with the right people in order for her music to shine, however. Otherwise she'll just be another Idol alumni forgotten. For those individuals beyond the top four, it gets even trickier as to whether they'll experience success. Lil Rounds and Scott MacIntyre absolutely won't. Matt Giraud and Anoop Desai have a small chance. Megan Joy and Michael Sarver have very small chances to experience music success in my opinion. Megan may have a unique sound but she floundered towards the end of her Idol run. And Michael may have written a ton of songs during the course of his life, but that might be all he's good for. Maybe he'll become the next great songwriter. Only time will tell.

So that about does it for my wrap-up of the American Idol season that was. I can't wait to see who releases an album and who doesn't. If I'd have to predict, Kris (duh), Adam, and Allison will be signed to record deals. It's a crapshoot whether the rest will get signed or not. And for those lucky enough to see the Idols live in concert this summer - I am seriously envious. I think it would be worth a ticket just to see Adam Lambert perform. I just can't imagine what it would be like to see him sing Mad World or Black and White in person - two of my personal favorites from him. And then there's Kris, who flies under the radio and is totally laid back in his demeanor. But he performs killer song arrangements and does a wonderful job making a song his own. I'd definitely buy his first album. All in all, season eight ended up being great and and creating some pretty powerful moments on-stage. Despite the producer pimping, the show becoming more about the judges than the contestants, and the tabloid news headlines, this show is as good as ever and it remains the most-watched one for me. January can't come soon enough when it comes to Idol!

Wednesday, May 06, 2009

American Idol 8 - Top 4

Ah, a rock theme on Idol. This is a first for the show and I don't think they've ever had a more reluctant mentor on the show than Slash. I don't really think he was all that thrilled in being a mentor, however, he made the most of it. I actually enjoyed that he had the whole band playing while the contestants sang. It truly was a nice effect. With that being said, we are getting closer and closer to the finale; only three weeks away! Hard to believe how quickly this season has come to a close. And with all things considered, we really haven't had a shocking elimination yet this season. Could that still be in the cards after this week's performances? Only time will tell. Let's get on with the recaps, why don't we?

Adam Lambert - "Whole Lotta Love" : For the first time this season, Adam is performing first. I think Adam is going to do quite well this week with the rock theme. I mean, people had the same thoughts going into disco week and he did well with that particular theme. He definitely picked the right song to fit his rocker-mentality and he absolutely knocked it out of the park. It's a very powerful performance with stellar vocals and he certainly has that rock star swagger. He's working it out tonight and this rock theme fits Adam like a hand fits a glove. I would say he's a bit more toned down than I thought he would be - not as many rock wails like he's known for. All things considered, Adam did very well tonight and it was a great way to start the night out.

Allison Iraheta - "Cry Baby" : No surprise here, but another one that should do quite well with this theme is Allison. I believe she's the first female rocker to make it as far as she has in this competition. Usually we have the R'nB Diva's to advance further, but not this season. Like with most of her performances in season eight, she had a few enunciation issues, especially earlier on in her performance. However, everything else about it was great. She's very confident on that stage and I will agree with Simon insomuch as to her growth from the beginning of her live performances to now. I mean sure, it's not the most familiar Janis Joplin song ever, but she really worked it out and made it her own. I believe she did a very smart thing in not picking "Another Little Piece of my Heart" because it had been done numerous times on the show. Well done Allison, well done.

Kris Allen & Danny Gokey - "Renegade" (DUET #1) : Now we come to the very first duet ever performed during a live performance show, other than the finale results show. And I've got to say, this will be a very interesting pairing, considering that this genre doesn't fit Kris or Danny all that well. They are more known for the Christian Contemporary music. I will agree with Randy in that their harmonizing together was wicked good. But their solo efforts in the song fell particularly flat. I heard a few off-pitch notes from both Kris and Danny at times. I didn't think they complemented each other that well on this duet. Maybe another song would've suited them both better. And Danny just might have taken the lead and picked this song without much input from Kris, seeing as they were having a difficult time choosing a song. And I didn't think Kris was that bad - he was probably about equal to Danny's performance.

Kris Allen - "Come Together" : It's kind of unfair how Kris had to sing back-to-back like this. The song order was especially odd and Kris is at a bit of a disadvantage this week because of it. I remember Carly Smithson's version of the song last year and she did an absolutely phenomenal job with it. Will Kris leave the same impression? I agree that this hard-rock genre doesn't fit Kris all that well. However, I really think he worked it out and it wasn't as bad as the judges made it out to be. I really loved his electric guitar playing skills and he is truly this season's musician. I didn't really notice a lot of pitchiness except for one note about two-thirds of the way through. I really enjoyed it when he slowed the tempo down for a brief moment and sung at a lower octave and encouraged the audience to clap along. Yes, this isn't the type of music suited for Kris, I get that. But quit throwing him under the bus just because he's not a judge's favorite.

Danny Gokey - "Dream On" : We are getting a lot of repeat song choices from season seven this week. Danny picks a classic Aerosmith song chosen by Michael Johns in season seven; the song that got him booted out in a shocking elimination. Could the same fate be set in stone for Danny? If that last note in the taped piece with Slash is any indication, this could be a total train wreck for Danny. I love the song but I think it's simply too big for Danny. He does a classic interpretation of the song from the start; as it's supposed to sound. He doesn't make a whole lot of changes with the melodies. He gradually builds the song up to its classic rock-sound. And then he sings the chorus over and over again. Finally, we get to the last few notes and oh my god ... my ears! It's like a combination of a fire alarm going off and a chorus of cats screeching. It really is that bad. I believe he should be eliminated simply because of that horrendous performance.

Adam Lambert & Allison Iraheta - "Slow Ride" (DUET #2) : Thank god for this last duet; I can't imagine the show ending with Danny's horrible performance. The Adam and Allison pairing is like a match made in rock heaven. These two had the best solo performances of the night and I agree with Kara in that they complemented each other very well and pushed each other to do better. It was an outstanding vocal from them both and honestly, what more is there to say? They are truly in their element with this theme. I think the addition of duets this season is an interesting change and it obviously worked well for some contestants and not for others. It all comes down to being paired with the right people and the producers knew exactly what they were doing with this pairing. It ended up being the perfect way to end the show. Adam basically book-ended tonight's performance show!

Ah yes, now to the all important performance rankings. Who was the best and who did the absolute worst? Here are my picks:

1.) Adam Lambert (officially eliminated - 5/11/09)
2.) Allison Iraheta
3.) Kris Allen (eliminated)

4.) Danny Gokey (bottom two)

I included a space between Kris Allen and Danny Gokey in the rankings because Danny was just that bad. I think if he didn't push that final note, it would've been a little tolerable of a performance than it was. Obviously he had to know it wasn't going to work. I mean, even while Slash was mentoring him, it sounded horrendous. How could he be so misguided? Taking all things into consideration, I don't believe Danny will get voted off even though he was horrendously bad. The judges threw Kris Allen under the bus for a second consecutive week - in fact, I think overall they all were rather harsh with him. And of course, they are still pimping Danny for the finale even though he had a pretty rough night. They could've told him it was his worst performance to date or even said they simply did not like it. But no, they have to tell him they'll give him an A+ for effort and they commend him for taking risks. What is that all about?! Obviously I'm not very happy because I have a strong feeling Kris will get the boot and Danny will be saved. I HOPE I AM WRONG!

Please be sure to enjoy tonight's results show! Unfortunately I cannot watch it live and will have to watch it back later. Here's hoping Danny finally gets the boot!

Wednesday, April 29, 2009

American Idol 8 - Top 5

This week on American Idol, we have songs from the Rat Pack era. For me, this is not a wildly exciting theme as I am unfamiliar with a lot of these standards. However, Idol is proving to be a great way to introduce these songs to new generations of fans; those who have no idea these songs exist. So all in all, it's a good thing Idol chooses to do a theme like this every couple of years. It seems they flip flop years between Broadway tunes. And there's no denying that Frank Sinatra is one of the very best from the Rat Pack era. His songs are legendary and will live on for all time. And taking all things into consideration, this week's song choices by the five remaining contestants were very smart and suited them all. On with the recaps!

Kris Allen - "The Way You Look Tonight" : Kris' evolution on Idol has been pretty amazing. He was barely featured in any of the early rounds, did a decent-enough job to get into the finals with his "Man in the Mirror" rendition, and has surged to the top of the pack in recent weeks. He's up first this week and receives major props from this week's mentor Jamie Foxx. I have become a fan of Kris and am absolutely loving his rendition of this song. He's on pitch and the first half of this song is very sensual, soft, and he's really connecting to it. Then the tempo picks up and it's still pleasantly good. He gives the song a more upbeat, jazzy feel. He closes the song with a very nice falsetto note (I didn't find it off-pitch). However, I was VERY upset how Simon chose to throw Kris under the bus this week. Honestly, what was his problem with Kris and this song?!

Allison Iraheta - "Someone to Watch Over Me" : Allison is this season's contestant that has gotten no respect. No respect from the American voting public and the judges (except for Kara). For her to land in the bottom three on three separate occasions in blasphemy especially in all of those weeks, she was one of the best of the night! Maybe this week, things will go her way. I am loving Allison's look this week; she actually isn't dressed like a rocker, but more like a typical 17-year old high school girl. And right from the start of this performance, I am feeling her deep connection to this song. I don't think I've felt such high emotion from her in a performance like this to date. It's very restrained, yet she adds a certain edginess to the song with her vocals. I can clearly understand her this week and it was so nice to see her step back from the rock genre and into something out of her element. Well done to Allison.

Matt Giraud - "My Funny Valentine" : Next we have the contestant who has defied fate on three separate occasions during the course of season eight. Honestly, I don't see Matt getting much further in this competition with four other superb contestants around him, but he's definitely made the most of his time on the Idol stage. And he certainly makes Michigan proud for bringing some much needed positive news to the state. I remember back in season six when Melinda Doolittle absolutely slayed this song - so Matt has some pretty big expectations to live up to. One thing is for sure, Matt has slowed down this song in his rendition - WAY down. I am thinking the song's range is way too low for Matt because he's failing to hit the right notes, especially in the beginning of this. He's a bit more restrained with the riffs, much like Jamie suggested, however he's not completely laying off them. I will say the ending was better than the beginning, but it just wasn't the best we've seen from Matt.

Danny Gokey - "Come Rain or Come Shine" : Danny has become the contestant people either love or hate. There's no denying he has a pretty large fanbase that keeps him in the competition week in and week out - in fact, he hasn't landed in the bottom three yet. However, he is one of the contestants to receive the most negative commentary from the fans and his popularity has definitely fallen since the early stages of the show. He's often described as being smarmy, show-boaty, and egotistical. Whatever you might think of him, he's still in this competition. And many, including Paula, are penciling him in to reach the finale. This week I found Danny to be much more tolerable than I've found him in previous weeks. In fact, this is probably the most relevant Danny has been to this competition in awhile. First off, Jamie Foxx's mentoring of Danny was hilarious - all up in Danny's face. I really enjoyed how the performance started with a more restrained Danny and keeping the song relatively simple. However, the final-third of the song was typical shouty-Danny. That took away from this being a great performance for me.

Adam Lambert - "Feeling Good" : Next up is Adam Lambert, who again performs in the pimp spot. How many times has he had the fortune to sing in this position? I know it's the most of any contestant this season. After all, it's a foregone conclusion that he'll win this thing. Why don't we crown him now and forget the final three weeks we have of Idol? Ah, but there's always hope of a shock elimination! Why don't I think it'll ever be Adam? I do generally like Adam but I think he tends to go a tad bit overboard with the theatrics of some of his performances, particularly those that are the uptempo, manic ones. And what a set-up we have for Adam to begin his performance; way up top on the stairs at the center of the stage; him gradually walking down, posing, and singing. I do enjoy the way this performance starts; certainly more restrained and he's not over-doing it. I was afraid this was going to be a train-wreck if he was going to glamrock-it-up. But overall, it was another spectacular vocal from Adam. And what the heck was with that second to last glory note? That was sick!!

Wow, the contestant recaps are getting longer and longer as we get down to the finale. I guess with less contestants, I write more! Anyways, here is this week's performance rankings, based on my opinion:

1.) Allison Iraheta
2.) Kris Allen - bottom two (actual bottom three - 4/29/09)
3.) Adam Lambert (actual bottom three - 4/29/09)
4.) Danny Gokey
5.) Matt Giraud - eliminated (actual eliminee - 4/29/09)

Matt Giraud gave the weakest performance out of the five, which is why I am thinking he'll get the boot this week. I genuinely believe Matt's time is up in this competition - even though he's defied fate a number of times. But you have to be at the top of your game at this stage of the competition and Matt most certainly wasn't compared to the other four. And despite my opinions of Kris having the second-best performance of the night, Simon certainly didn't feel that way. He was thrown under the bus this time around, which is why he'll land in this week's bottom two. And going first never helps a contestant, either. Allison could also be a threat to land in the bottom two (or three, if they do a bottom three this week), however, I have seen a lot of negative reaction to Simon's comments about Allison's performance. A lot of people have stepped up their voting in support of Allison so with that being said, she should escape any threat of elimination this week. And with the continued pimping of Danny and Adam, don't expect them to go anywhere this week.

With that being said, I was a little disappointed each of the five contestants only sang one song, unlike previous years when each contestant at this stage sang two songs. I guess adding that fourth judge really took away a lot of performance time and that's especially sad. I think the producers of Idol really need to re-examine the four-judge panel heading into next season. I don't believe it's working all that well, especially when it's taking away from the performance time of the contestants. Out of anyone, they need to get rid of Randy because I've found him to be the most irrelevant this season than ever before. Just get the three-judging panel back, at least keep Simon and Paula, and things will be much rosier heading into season nine.

I have lost my concentration to write anymore as some idiotic woman is screaming obscenities to a person on her cell phone outside my window, so I'm going to get on my merry way. Ugh, some people... Be sure to enjoy tonight's results show starting at 9 PM on the east coast on Fox. Peace!

Wednesday, April 22, 2009

American Idol 8 - Top 7 (Again)

So here we are again for the second week in a row - a top seven! I am sure many people out there were unsure if the judges would ever use their power to save a contestant this season from the brink of being eliminated like Matt Giraud faced last week. And let's be honest, Matt certainly has had his up and down weeks. And last week's performance wasn't exactly stellar either. So to be fair, Matt probably was due to go home last week. But, will we honestly see Adam or Danny get kicked off anytime soon? Probably not. This would've been the last week the judges could've used the save so hopefully it don't end up biting them in the rear end! I would be absolutely sick if someone like Allison or Kris gets sent home prior to Lil or Anoop. But isn't that what makes American Idol so intriguing year after year - those shocking eliminations? It's hard to forget those nights when Chris Daughtry or Michael Johns went home way too early.

This week's theme is disco! It seems like such an irrelevant week to have at this stage of the competition, although basically the entire decade of the '70's was disco music! And from past years, disco week has provided some pretty memorable train wrecks. We'll see if this season is anymore different! Let's start the recaps:

Lil Rounds - "I'm Every Woman" : I think Lil is at a big disadvantage this week with the way the show starts sans the video package and her being the first contestant on stage. Seems like the kiss of death for me and the producers could possibly be setting her up to go home. Again, as in prior weeks, this is not starting out all that good. Her phrasing needs a lot of improvement and she's not hitting the right notes. She's sounding terribly flat, particularly on some of the higher notes. She improves towards the middle and the end but it's still just an average performance for me. I don't care if she's been ill and is on vocal rest; that can't be an excuse for her sounding mediocre ever since the top 13 began.

Kris Allen - "She Works Hard for the Money" : This isn't the type of song you'd expect Kris to sing but after all, it is disco week! I am loving this stylized, cool, jazzy arrangement of this classic Donna Summer song that Kris has put together. He really re-invents this song and turns it into a contemporary tune. Kris has really become a genius of re-creating some classic songs, particularly those from the '70's. This song ended up suiting Kris nicely, even though the original performer was female. But then again, other male contestants this season have also covered songs originally performed by females, so it's not like it's something completely different. But we're definitely seeing from Kris the kind of music he would like to make. Kudos to him.

Danny Gokey - "September" : You know, I was a pretty big Danny Gokey fan at the beginning of the season. I thought his backstory was inspiring even though many other people thought he was using the drama of his dead wife to gain votes. But lately I have been finding Danny to be rather off-putting; basically from his demeanor. I don't know; I've just been getting weird vibes from him lately. He starts off this performance with a "yeah" that sounds similar to that of a fire alarm. Yeow - that hurt the ears. For the most part, Danny is on-pitch through the entire song. I think it's his performance skills that could use some work. I don't know; he just hasn't had a truly memorable performance yet for me. I think he does just enough to get by each and every week. I still don't believe it was as good of a performance as the judge's said.

Allison Iraheta - "Hot Stuff" : This performance starts off very slow and intense. Allison is basically leaning back on the stairs that Ryan comes down from during the opening of the show. Wow, Allison is decked out in a very tight-fitting leather ensemble. She looks like hot stuff herself - and then I remember she's only 16. Tempo then picks up and she's really rocking out to this on stage. Despite some enunciation issues that Allison typically has, this is turning into a very enjoyable performance. Once again, she is displaying those very powerful rock-star vocals. And despite Randy and Kara's problems with the arrangement, I didn't feel it was that big of a deal. I absolutely love how she picks songs that are way too old for her to be singing, too. (laughs)

Adam Lambert - "If I Can't Have You" : I think prior to this week's performance show, many people were expecting Adam to do the best of all the contestants with disco week. He has also fallen into a bit of a predictable pattern of singing a powerful ballad one week, and then following it up with a big up-tempo rock song the next. He is back to following that pattern with a ballad, although the original was a bit more up-tempo than this. Adam is as good as ever with this performance. His vocals are spot-on and as usual, he is showing off that amazing range he's got. I had actually hoped the tempo would pick up a little more than it did. I thought the middle and end portion of the song was a big under-whelming, but overall, it was another brilliant performance from Mr. Lambert. Enjoyed the emotional connection he showed with this one.

Matt Giraud - "Stayin' Alive" : I was quite surprised this was the first Bee Gees song performed this week as I was expecting a total of two Bee Gees songs covered during disco week. But then again, this is the Bee Gees most famous disco tune of all! Matt's rendition isn't totally disco; in fact, I'm sensing a heavy RnB flair. His vocals are a bit gravely at times and he loses it a bit on the falsetto, but all in all, this is a nice vocal performance from Matt. I am really digging how he re-invented this song to fit his style. He's definitely having a good time on stage and this song really suits his style.

Anoop Desai - "Dim All the Lights" : Anoop is probably the underdog of all underdogs during season eight. I mean after all, how many times has he been in the bottom three lately? He finally gives his wardrobe a bit of a makeover from his usual preppy look, although his attire is more fitting of a '70's night. This performance starts out rather boring for me but then the tempo picks up. It's kind of a mid-tempo arrangement and I'm still not blown away by it. Overall, I'm bored by the whole thing. I just don't think this song suited him all that well. And then he doesn't help matters by squealing through that last note. Could nerves have possibily gotten to him at this stage of the game?

With that out of the way, here is this week's performance rankings:

1.) Kris Allen
2.) Adam Lambert
3.) Allison Iraheta (actual bottom three - 4/22/09)
4.) Matt Giraud - bottom three
5.) Danny Gokey
6.) Anoop Desai - eliminated (actual eliminee - 4/22/09)
7.) Lil Rounds - eliminated (actual eliminee - 4/22/09)

As for my predictions, I am giving Lil Rounds and Anoop Desai the boot. Both had mediocre performances and neither are deseving to be in this season's top five. However, do not be surprised to see a shock elimination. Allison Iraheta may be that person, as sad as it is for me to say. Let's hope not, though! Don't forget to watch this week's results show tonight at 9:00 PM (EDT)!

Whoa - my predictions are right again! Both Lil and Anoop went home this week. I've never had a streak quite like this before. Let's see if it continues next week!

Wednesday, April 08, 2009

American Idol 8 - Top 8

So yet another week has come and gone and it's time for the American Idol contestants to sing songs from the year they were born. So essentially, it's '80's week (except for Allison)! That's not completely a bad thing. The 1980's had some incredible songs. And usually I don't go back-to-back with American Idol recaps in my blog, either. But I'm on an unusual stretch at work where I'm working afternoon shift two weeks in a row. And when I'm on afternoons, I have the least amount of motivation to do much writing! Except when it comes to these American Idol recaps which I absolutely have to write. So how will the contestants fair this week? Will Lil actually pick a song the judges will like? Will Kris Allen continue to shine with his ability to rearrange a song? And will Adam and Danny continue to be the front runners? Let's find out!

Danny Gokey - "Stand By Me" : When I first heard Danny was picking this song, I thought to myself, "oh no." Because as we all know last year, David Archuleta absolutely knocked it out of the park. But Danny chooses a completely different arrangement and it totally works. I really like his controlled vocal performance - far less over-shouting than some of his previous performances. And even when the tempo picked up, it still wasn't half-bad. But I still don't believe Danny has had a truly memorable performance yet that will be talked about for a long time. Hopefully he'll continue to step it up each week because I don't see him going anywhere.

Kris Allen - "All She Wants to Do is Dance" : Before Kris performs, Ryan mentions the praise from the judges he's been getting for some of his prior performances. Well, he's certainly in for a rude awakening there! The whole brass ensemble to this arrangement was rather off-putting. It definitely did not work as well as Kris probably hoped it would. I certainly applaud his efforts in attempting to make this Don Henley hit different but I believe he strayed too far away from the original. His vocals are actually pretty decent, but the song just did not do him any justice this week. He could be in trouble - and that would be especially disappointing.

Lil Rounds - "What's Love Got To Do With It" : I am really digging this song choice and if Lil executes it properly, she could actually receive some much needed praise by the judges after several weeks of sub-par performances. But again, I am finding this to be very average. I believe she needs to work on her interpretation and phrasing of the songs she chooses. She infuses too much southern drawl into her vocals. And she needs to be able to hit all of the right notes, which she clearly did not this week. I agreed with Simon in that it sounded too much like Tina Turner's version. She needs to differentiate herself more and become an original artist.

Anoop Desai - "True Colors" : Anoop is going back to singing a ballad this week. It seems that is where he is most comfortable and it allows him to show off his vocals the most. When he attempts an up-tempo song, he comes across as being too much of a party guy and not a true vocalist. "True Colors" is definitely working for Anoop. I am actually liking this so much better than his version of "Ooh Baby Baby" a few weeks back. I am not bored to tears with this and vocally it's very good. He even backed it up with a very nice falsetto note to end the performance on. Very well done for Anoop.

Scott MacIntyre - "The Search is Over" : Wow, it seems very odd to see Scott carrying a guitar. I thought all he could play was the piano! Despite Simon's comments on the song, I think it's a great one in my opinion. However, it wasn't the right choice for Scott. I give him huge props for stepping out of his comfort zone and straying away from the piano for one week. It could've been a good opportunity to showcase his vocals - but they weren't that great. He especially struggled with the build-up into the faster tempo portion of the song and that one stretch where he hit the falsetto was particularly excruciating. The song was just too big for him.

Allison Iraheta - "I Can't Make You Love Me" : I loved the way this performance began. Her vocal is very controlled and she's performing in a very heartfelt way. We're able to really listen to her vocal skills and based on that I find that she's an amazing singer. I think her enunciation of the words in the song is better this week, too. I feel America needs to embrace her more - either that or the judges need to give her the proper credit she deserves. She certainly knows how to sell a song and she does another spectacular job. I would love to see her go deep into this competition - much further than Lil, that's for sure.

Matt Giraud - "Part Time Lover" : Matt starts it off very different from the original; very soulful and sexy. Even when the tempo of the song picks up, it's still slowed-down from the original. I am really enjoying Matt's interpretation of this song. Sometimes it can be the death-knell for anyone tackling a Stevie Wonder song, but Matt made it his own. He tends to over do it with the runs, but that's kind of who Matt is. Such a very soulful and bluesy performance. It was a big improvement over last week and it should save him from a trip into the bottom three this week.

Adam Lambert - "Mad World" : So what is Adam going to do this week? You can always expect the unexpected from Adam because he's never predictable. Let me start off by saying I love this particular arrangement of the song. Adam's performance is based off an arrangement by Gary Jules, heard most famously from a "Gears of War" video game ad a few years back. It was another very controlled performance from Adam, much like "Tracks of my Tears." But I found this performance to be even better because the song is amazing. Just listen to the lyrics and you'll see what I mean. Another superb job from Adam and a great way to end the night.

So with the recaps out of the way, here's this week's performance rankings:

1.) Adam Lambert - best of the night
2.) Allison Iraheta
3.) Matt Giraud
4.) Danny Gokey
5.) Anoop Desai (actual bottom three - 4/8/09)
6.) Kris Allen
7.) Lil Rounds (actual bottom three - 4/8/09)
8.) Scott MacIntyre (actual eliminee - 4/8/09)

So once again, Adam gave a masterclass performance that a lot of people raved about. I just don't see him or Danny ever winding up in the bottom three because they are such popular figures, even though Danny hasn't been quite as good as Adam. Matt and Anoop continue to have their up and down weeks and they'll need to continue to perform at high levels to even consider cracking the top five. And after a strong surge from Kris the previous few weeks, he stumbled somewhat and could end up in trouble this week. I don't have him being in the bottom three this week, but I'm sure you all remember what happened to Michael Johns last year in the top eight. That could actually end up happening this year with Kris, although his performance wasn't nearly as good as Michael's was last year. Allison continues to shine week in and week out and this week was no exception. I believe America will embrace her a little more because the judges actually complemented Allison on her singing abilities instead of what she was wearing. Meanwhile, Lil Rounds is free falling to a place I never imagined she might end up, getting kicked out before the top six. And I don't believe the judges will save her, either. And last but not least is Scott. He's an inspiring individual and has a great personality. However, his vocals just aren't as good as the rest of the group. I pick Scott to leave this week.

Don't forget to watch tonight's results show. I'm sure it'll be as dramatic as always!

Scott leaves American Idol and I have correctly picked the last three eliminees in a row!

Thursday, March 26, 2009

American Idol - Top 10

Here we are again - another week of American Idol (even though it's a day late because of another speech by President Obama). This week on Idol, we are celebrating 50 years of Motown. A few of the major Idol blogs are dissing this week's theme because it's been overdone throughout the eight seasons of the show. But the Motown franchise is celebrating a major milestone this year, so props to Idol for giving us this week. Hey, any little bit of positive coverage for Detroit, the auto industry, and Michigan as a whole is welcomed. And hopefully we'll get a little bit more of positive coverage when the NCAA men's basketball Final Four moves into Detroit next weekend. This week's Idol mentor is Smokey Robinson, one of Motown's biggest starts. I remember the last time I saw Smokey on TV, he freaked me out! I think it was during the Grammy's or something. But he looks and acted a lot better during his time with the Idols. Alright, it's time to get it on!

Matt Giraud - "Let's Get it On" : I really enjoyed how Matt started his performance out by playing on the piano and giving the song a different sound than what we're used to. It gave the song a totally new vibe for me and I thought it was really cool. There's no doubt he has a definite bluesy sound to him. I found it even more surprising when he got up from the piano and actually began performing in front of the audience! Now that was very risky and he showed off more personality that way. Overall, I thought he put his own spin on this classic song and the performance was well done. He showed that he, too, can be a performer on that stage.

Kris Allen - "How Sweet it Is" : Again, another performance where I enjoyed how it started. Kris starts it slow, nearly acapella except when he strums the guitar a bit. Then the uptempo portion of the song begins and he gets accompaniment from the band and overall, it's a very enjoyable performance by Kris. I love that he's been stepping it up week after week. He proved to us that he can sing a more upbeat song without having a ton of trouble and having it labeled as being karaoke. He doesn't seem as nervous as when he started singing live and he's really been showing a ton of personality with his performances the last two weeks.

Scott MacIntyre - "You Can't Hurry Love" : Scott decided to change things up a bit with the arrangement of the song. I really don't think it worked because it made the song sound more like it should've been performed at a mall. The arrangement was a bit too fast and I don't believe the piano-sound worked for this particular performance. Vocally, Scott did okay but not great as the performance certainly had its pitchy moments. It was a nice effort on his part, but it just fell flat. A different song probably would've suited Scott better.

Megan Joy - "For Once in My Life" : Again, Megan infuses her own uniqueness into this classic Stevie Wonder song but it doesn't work with the performance. I definitely think it was too fast of a song for her and that typical jazz sound that Megan uses seemed out of place this time around. Her unique sounds tends to work best when she slows it down, particularly with songs like "Walking After Midnight" which she sung last week. She had trouble hitting the right notes from time to time, especially the higher ones. Overall, it just wasn't a strong week for Megan.

Anoop Desai - "Ooh Baby Baby" : Vocally, Anoop did really well as I hardly noticed any off-pitch notes. However, I did find the performance to be rather boring. I listened to the original version with Smokey Robinson and the Miracles and the tempo in that particular song seemed to be a tad bit faster. Anoop's song was just too slow and I found the chorus of all places lacking in energy. I realize that the song is a ballad and it's supposed to be sung slow, but the way Anoop performed it was rather tedious. I am hoping to see Anoop pick a song with more tempo next week but nothing as disastrous as "Beat It" was a few weeks back.

Michael Sarver - "Ain't Too Proud to Beg" : I almost think Michael would be better suited singing ballads more than uptempo songs because ballads tend to highlight his voice better. When he performs a song like "Ain't Too Proud to Beg," it sounds too clumsy and he really struggles keeping up. It seems like when he picks an uptempo song, it's not the right choice. Last week, his song during Grand Ole Opry week did not suit him as well as it should have. Overall, it was a weak performance that included odd phrasing and weird facial expressions. And he topped it off with a terrible second-to-last note.

Lil Rounds - "Heat Wave" : I was rather touched seeing Lil get so emotional being in Motown and talking about it with Smokey. Then, we quickly transition to the live performance where the band is blaring the very opening of the song and we are treated to this very uptempo song. It was kind of a shock to my system and I think the moment deserved a much slower song, for what it's worth. Vocally, I thought Lil did okay, but nothing spectacular as she seemed to struggle more with the lower notes in the song. She definitely had a fun time on stage but I think she really could've had an epic week if she went with a ballad.

Adam Lambert - "Tracks of My Tears" : Adam definitely had a moment with this song and it's going to be remembered as one of the best of this season, at least. I loved seeing this side of Adam; very heart-felt, with a softer tone. If you can believe it, he showed a more vulnerable side and it was such a smart thing to do. I really liked the whole vibe of the song; more of an acoustic sound with more woodwind instruments added once we got to the chorus. The overall arrangement of the song was well planned out and it proved to be the best performance of the night.

Danny Gokey - "Get Ready" : I think Danny needs to take a page from Adam's book and know when to reign it in from time to time. We haven't seen a truly heart-felt performance from Danny in awhile and I am finding him to be rather stale in this performance. You know, I was really liking Danny from the beginning but he needs to start showing me something different because the same routine week in and week out is getting old fast. I did find his "choreography" with the background singers to be nicely spontaneous, but overall I wasn't all that impressed with the performance and it definitely lacked a spark.

Allison Iraheta - "PaPa Was a Rolling Stone" : Wow, Allison totally blew it out of the box tonight. I am so happy to see this because she's been one of my favorites since the beginning and she definitely needs more support from the fans especially after winding up in the bottom three last week. She had lots of energy and certainly showed off a more funky side. There's no question she can belt it out. I do believe she needs to enunciate some of the words in her performances a little bit more - but even that can be hard to do when singing these kinds of songs. This was definitely one of Allison's more memorable performances to date.

So, with the recaps out of the way, I bet you're wondering how I ranked this week's performances. Well, here ya go!

1.) Adam Lambert
2.) Allison Iraheta
3.) Matt Giraud (actual bottom three - 3/26/09)
4.) Kris Allen
5.) Anoop Desai
6.) Danny Gokey
7.) Lil Rounds
8.) Megan Joy
9.) Scott MacIntyre (actual bottom three - 3/26/09)
10.) Michael Sarver (actual eliminee - 3/26/09)

So no surprise who I think will be sent home. Michael basically just picked the wrong song that was way too big for him. Something much slower that allowed him to hit the big notes would've suited him just fine. Yet, you have to make sure not to sound too old fashioned either. It's tricky trying to please the judges all of the time. If not Michael, then Megan or Scott are deserving to be sent home. Scott really needs to pick his game up, otherwise he won't survive another week. Megan just needs to pick the right songs that will fit her jazzy sound and she'll last at least until the top eight.

With another week of Idol in the books, it's time to prepare for the top nine. Next week's theme is "top downloaded songs," or something along those lines. Yes! A contemporary week during the top ten - something last season definitely lacked. Be sure to stop in next week and read the performance recaps from the top nine singers during American Idol's eighth season. See you then!

Wednesday, March 25, 2009

American Idol - Top 10 Quick Thoughts

A full recap of tonight's performances will be posted on "Luke's Ponderings" tomorrow - but just a few quick thoughts on tonight's show.

Adam Lambert for the win! I thought he did an absolutely incredible job with his song tonight. It was a slowed down, vulnerable, soothing vocal of "Tracks of My Tears." Honestly we haven't seen anything like it from Adam yet this season and it was such a smart thing to do! I was so blown away by it and I have truly become a fan of this guy. For me, he's gradually won me over week after week with his performances even though in my recaps, I haven't really reflected that sentiment. I didn't give him as much credit as he deserved for his "Black and White" performance from a few weeks back. I watched that one back a few different times since and it honestly gives me chills. I still believe "Ring of Fire" was rather like broadway, but it still shows off Adam's incredible skills. I thought he was far and away the best performer of the night.

I have also come to realize why the ratings may be faltering for this show. It's not anything the contestants have done nor has it really been anything to do with shock eliminations in the past. Mostly, I blame the judges! The judges really drove me nuts tonight. How immature and childish are they getting to be? At the end, you had Simon drawing a mustache on Paula with a crayon and totally ruining Allison's moment. Allison gave a phenomenal performance and I felt it was mostly ruined by these stupid antics between Simon and Paula. Get a grip, you two! Either that, or get a room. I also found Kara to be rather off-putting tonight, as well. I noticed a couple of different times where she repeated the same comments with different contestants. One of the comments was about two contestants having artistry, when Simon a week or two back said that American Idol is nothing about being an artist! I also hated it when she got downright rude to the audience after getting booed. Up to this point, I didn't really have a negative thing to say about Kara. But after tonight, she definitely got on my nerves. And now there's Randy. Seeing that he doesn't always get to give his critiques first anymore, he often says, "I agree with Simon, or Paula, or Kara..." and he doesn't appear he's able to say anything original in his commentary. I'm finding him to be real stale this season, and he's typically been my favorite judge on the show. But he, too, is starting to get on my nerves a bit. I am almost beginning to think the entire judges panel needs an overall make-over. It's getting to be too over the top and almost more about them more than the contestants.

Overall, I thought the show was pretty decent. It started off really good, then the performances trailed off and some of them were downright bad. But things picked up again very nicely and things ended with a bang with Allison's performance. Be sure to vote for Allison tonight! She's another one that deserves to stay in this competition for a very, very long time. I am still baffled she ended up in the bottom three last week and near the bottom the previous week. Vote for Allison and keep her in the competition!

Well that's it for now. Be sure to watch for the full top 10 recap here on "Luke's Ponderings." Goodnight!!

Thursday, February 26, 2009

American Idol 8 - Top 36 Group 2

It's a new week so it's time for another recap of last night's American Idol performances. We're one week later than last week because of President Obama's address to Congress on Tuesday. Either way, we still get two shows this week. It's another week of songs from the Billboard Top 100 from any year, apparently. So the contestants have a wide selection of songs to pick from. One thing I am definitely liking this year over last is the choice of contemporary songs in the semi-final round. That was sorely lacking last season and it's nice they've done an about-change in season eight. As for this week, I am liking a few changes they have made since the last performance show. The parents/friends are in the audience instead of up on the balcony - so we aren't getting any overly excessive chatter once the performances have concluded. Also, there weren't nearly as many camera flaws or production errors. It appears they have most, if not all of their ducks in a row. So, on with the review!

Jasmine Murray - "Love Song" : I do enjoy her choice in this contemporary song, especially one that allowed Sara Bareilles to become a break-out star. As for Jasmine, it doesn't start out all that great. In using Randy's term, it was very pitchy in spots. It seemed to get better as the performance moved along but yet I don't believe this was the right song choice for her. It was just an okay performance; certainly did not blow me away. As she's proven during her audition and in Hollywood week, she can sing. She just needs to pick the right song that really shows off her vocal ability. "Love Song" doesn't allow Jasmine to do that. I will say this, her stage presence is very good and she appeared very confident.

Matt Giraud - "Viva La Vida" : Up next we have Michigan's very own Matt Giraud, so you know I am rooting for him to do well. I am a bit worried, however, because he picks such a well-known contemporary song that was one of the top songs for the year in 2008. I don't know if it's exactly the kind of song that shows off Matt's vocal abilities. In fact, I think it may be too big of a song for him. He's trying to do too much with the song; trying to deliver an epic and memorable performance. Honestly, it falls short for me. Like the judges, I find him most appealing when he's behind a piano doing the more soulful stuff. Why haven't we seen any contestants playing instruments in the semi-finals anyways? They were allowed to last season - so why not now? Anyways, I am rather disappointed for Matt.

Jeanine Vailes - "This Love" : Another of those contestants that we know absolutely nothing about! It was Ricky last week and now Jeanine this week. Well, we do know she's a bartender. Big whoop. She's 28 and apparently she's been waiting all her life for an opportunity like this. Let's see if she can deliver. Nope; not gonna happen. I think Maroon 5 is a fabulous group, but this is the wrong song for Jeanine. She just blew her big shot at a music career. Back to being a bartender, I'm afraid. It's a train wreck right from the start. She's all over with the notes and towards the end, she wasn't either above or below the actual notes. I think she was trying to do way too much with the song in the later half. It just doesn't sound good at all. Oh well, at least she has great looking legs!

Nick Mitchell - "And I am Telling You" : This guy is an absolute clown, but I have to admit, he's hilarious. The whole banter between him and Simon during Nick's audition was hysterical. Plus, when he's not being comedic, he can actually sing. He has a good singing voice somewhere behind the hysterics. I am actually hoping the real Nick Mitchell shows up and not Normund Gentle - because this is where things get serious and a person needs to show off how well they can sing. Ah well, he doesn't follow my advice and he's doing the Normund routine. Even though this is a competition to find America's next break-out music star, Nick is kind of refreshing. Although this isn't the right show for him (try "America's Got Talent" instead), he certainly is a memorable figure and makes the show interesting whenever he happens to be on. Again, very funny stuff.

Allison Iraheta - "Alone" : She is very young; not even 17 yet! She doesn't seem all that confident in herself and appears to be quite nervous. And ouch, right off the bat she's picking the classic Heart song that has been covered countless number of time's on the Idol stage. So I am definitely nervous for her. Will her performance even be comparable to Carrie Underwood's or Gina Glocksen's? I don't necessarily believe it was as good as Carrie's version (and honestly, who's ever will?), but it was still very good. She may not seem all that confident during interviews, but on that stage, she's a powerful singer. Now that is how to do a performance during the semi-finals. Allison has the best performance of the night so far and she should earn a spot in this season's top 12.

Kris Allen - "Man in the Mirror" : Uh oh; not another Michael Jackson song! It didn't work out very well for Stephen Fowler last week; we'll see if it's any different for Kris this week. He's another contestant we don't know much about so he'll definitely have to kick it into high gear and sing for his life, otherwise he has no shot. I really didn't care how the song starts - and it's not really Kris's fault for that because that is how the song is. He has a few pitch problems here and there but his performance improves as the song moves along. Despite the interesting song choice, Kris doesn't do that badly with it. I just wish the song would've been a lot stronger in the beginning, otherwise Kris would've had more of a fighting chance. I wasn't blown away by it, but it ends up being the best male vocal so far.

Megan Joy Corkrey - "Put Your Records On" : I really like her and hope she does well. I agree with Paula's assessment that she looks great on camera. She has a very unique sound to her and I am absolutely digging this song choice for Megan. I would agree that her stage presence does need work; she's fidgety and does some odd twists. However, her singing isn't bad. Again, it's not spectacular vocal-wise but she did a decent job with it. The song fits her vocal abilities but some of the notes, especially in the higher range were off at times. But I thought she provided one of the more shining moments during the show than what we've seen so far.

Matt Breitzke - "If You Can Only See" : I think the contestant's have been picking great songs; yet in most cases, they are not the right songs for them, per se. It was another example of that for Matt. I really enjoy this Tonic song but Matt's rendition was pretty bland. I just wasn't jumping up and down with it and although he can sing, as we've seen during Hollywood week, it just didn't live up to its potential. He should've chosen a song that shows off more of his vocal prowess. I would agree with the judges that he hit all of the right notes in the song, however, the song doesn't have a real big range to it. It also would've helped if was a higher energy song, too. Would've helped his chances in advancing to the top 12 some.

Jesse Langseth - "Bette Davis Eyes" : Prior to the episode where the top 36 were chosen, we didn't know much about Jesse. However, at least we know more of her history than we do for Jeanine and Kris. It appears she has been singing for awhile and is waiting for a big break. Maybe Idol will help her out. When I first heard her performance of "Bette Davis Eyes," I wasn't all that impressed. However, after listening back to it a couple of different times, it's grown on me. Like we've seen many times so far in group two, I wasn't blown away by it but vocally it was quite good and it definitely had its moments. Again, could she have picked a song that had more of a range? Yes, but she did quite well with what she chose.

Kai Kalama - "What Becomes of a Broken Hearted" : So after all of the contemporary songs the contestant's have chosen so far during the performance night, Kai's pick is the song with the oldest track record. As Paula said, he seems to like the older songs more, which might be why he performs them the most. However, he says he's a contemporary guy, but we probably won't be able to see that side from him after this performance. He definitely comes across as an old fashioned guy. Again, I am not blown away by it. It's just average and I'm actually bored. He could've picked a Bee Gees song or something with a little more energy - if he wants to sway towards the throw-back songs. Another disappointment from someone with high potential.

Mishavonna Henson - "Drops of Jupiter" : Back on the contemporary train (no pun intended) and Mishavonna picks a good one. However, it's not a good choice for her performance. It's not really a vocally powerful song and the performance becomes rather bland to me. I mean, she can definitely sing and I feel quite bad for her because she has been in the Idol competition for two year's running and it's going to fall short for her again. I liked it more once it picked up tempo half-way through but still not as spectacular as I was hoping. Again, if she could've chosen a song more fitting to her style, she'd definitely be a lock for a spot into the top 12, if not the wildcard. I still believe she's going to fall well short of contention.

Adam Lambert - "Satisfaction" : You know, I haven't been a big fan of Adam thus far in the competition. I thought he's been too dramatic, over-the-top and yes, too theatrical. However, I think the tide is beginning to turn and he became more likable for me tonight. "Satisfaction" is definitely a high-energy song and it'll get everyone up off their feet. During the performance, he's a little shouty at times but he's certainly having a good time on stage. I agree with Kara in that he has a phenominal vocal range - you don't see many guys who can sing with such an amazing falsetto. No surprise here; he's a shoo-in for top male vocal in group two.

So, who sang the best and the worst during the top 36 - group two performance night? Well, here's how I rank them:

Top Six Male Performers:
1.) Adam Lambert
2.) Kris Allen
3.) Matt Giraud
4.) Matt Breitzke
5.) Kai Kalama
6.) Nick Mitchell

Top Six Female Performers:
1.) Allison Iraheta
2.) Megan Joy Corkery
3.) Jesse Langseth
4.) Mishavonna Henson
5.) Jasmine Murray
6.) Jeanine Vailes

Who'll be advancing to the top 12? Here are my picks:

M - Adam Lambert
F - Allison Iraheta
M - Matt Giraud

Be sure to enjoy tonight's results! Despite the corny group performances, it's always a high intensity show. See you again next week!