So yet another week has come and gone and it's time for the American Idol contestants to sing songs from the year they were born. So essentially, it's '80's week (except for Allison)! That's not completely a bad thing. The 1980's had some incredible songs. And usually I don't go back-to-back with American Idol recaps in my blog, either. But I'm on an unusual stretch at work where I'm working afternoon shift two weeks in a row. And when I'm on afternoons, I have the least amount of motivation to do much writing! Except when it comes to these American Idol recaps which I absolutely have to write. So how will the contestants fair this week? Will Lil actually pick a song the judges will like? Will Kris Allen continue to shine with his ability to rearrange a song? And will Adam and Danny continue to be the front runners? Let's find out!
Danny Gokey - "Stand By Me" : When I first heard Danny was picking this song, I thought to myself, "oh no." Because as we all know last year, David Archuleta absolutely knocked it out of the park. But Danny chooses a completely different arrangement and it totally works. I really like his controlled vocal performance - far less over-shouting than some of his previous performances. And even when the tempo picked up, it still wasn't half-bad. But I still don't believe Danny has had a truly memorable performance yet that will be talked about for a long time. Hopefully he'll continue to step it up each week because I don't see him going anywhere.
Kris Allen - "All She Wants to Do is Dance" : Before Kris performs, Ryan mentions the praise from the judges he's been getting for some of his prior performances. Well, he's certainly in for a rude awakening there! The whole brass ensemble to this arrangement was rather off-putting. It definitely did not work as well as Kris probably hoped it would. I certainly applaud his efforts in attempting to make this Don Henley hit different but I believe he strayed too far away from the original. His vocals are actually pretty decent, but the song just did not do him any justice this week. He could be in trouble - and that would be especially disappointing.
Lil Rounds - "What's Love Got To Do With It" : I am really digging this song choice and if Lil executes it properly, she could actually receive some much needed praise by the judges after several weeks of sub-par performances. But again, I am finding this to be very average. I believe she needs to work on her interpretation and phrasing of the songs she chooses. She infuses too much southern drawl into her vocals. And she needs to be able to hit all of the right notes, which she clearly did not this week. I agreed with Simon in that it sounded too much like Tina Turner's version. She needs to differentiate herself more and become an original artist.
Anoop Desai - "True Colors" : Anoop is going back to singing a ballad this week. It seems that is where he is most comfortable and it allows him to show off his vocals the most. When he attempts an up-tempo song, he comes across as being too much of a party guy and not a true vocalist. "True Colors" is definitely working for Anoop. I am actually liking this so much better than his version of "Ooh Baby Baby" a few weeks back. I am not bored to tears with this and vocally it's very good. He even backed it up with a very nice falsetto note to end the performance on. Very well done for Anoop.
Scott MacIntyre - "The Search is Over" : Wow, it seems very odd to see Scott carrying a guitar. I thought all he could play was the piano! Despite Simon's comments on the song, I think it's a great one in my opinion. However, it wasn't the right choice for Scott. I give him huge props for stepping out of his comfort zone and straying away from the piano for one week. It could've been a good opportunity to showcase his vocals - but they weren't that great. He especially struggled with the build-up into the faster tempo portion of the song and that one stretch where he hit the falsetto was particularly excruciating. The song was just too big for him.
Allison Iraheta - "I Can't Make You Love Me" : I loved the way this performance began. Her vocal is very controlled and she's performing in a very heartfelt way. We're able to really listen to her vocal skills and based on that I find that she's an amazing singer. I think her enunciation of the words in the song is better this week, too. I feel America needs to embrace her more - either that or the judges need to give her the proper credit she deserves. She certainly knows how to sell a song and she does another spectacular job. I would love to see her go deep into this competition - much further than Lil, that's for sure.
Matt Giraud - "Part Time Lover" : Matt starts it off very different from the original; very soulful and sexy. Even when the tempo of the song picks up, it's still slowed-down from the original. I am really enjoying Matt's interpretation of this song. Sometimes it can be the death-knell for anyone tackling a Stevie Wonder song, but Matt made it his own. He tends to over do it with the runs, but that's kind of who Matt is. Such a very soulful and bluesy performance. It was a big improvement over last week and it should save him from a trip into the bottom three this week.
Adam Lambert - "Mad World" : So what is Adam going to do this week? You can always expect the unexpected from Adam because he's never predictable. Let me start off by saying I love this particular arrangement of the song. Adam's performance is based off an arrangement by Gary Jules, heard most famously from a "Gears of War" video game ad a few years back. It was another very controlled performance from Adam, much like "Tracks of my Tears." But I found this performance to be even better because the song is amazing. Just listen to the lyrics and you'll see what I mean. Another superb job from Adam and a great way to end the night.
So with the recaps out of the way, here's this week's performance rankings:
1.) Adam Lambert - best of the night
2.) Allison Iraheta
3.) Matt Giraud
4.) Danny Gokey
5.) Anoop Desai (actual bottom three - 4/8/09)
6.) Kris Allen
7.) Lil Rounds (actual bottom three - 4/8/09)
8.) Scott MacIntyre (actual eliminee - 4/8/09)
So once again, Adam gave a masterclass performance that a lot of people raved about. I just don't see him or Danny ever winding up in the bottom three because they are such popular figures, even though Danny hasn't been quite as good as Adam. Matt and Anoop continue to have their up and down weeks and they'll need to continue to perform at high levels to even consider cracking the top five. And after a strong surge from Kris the previous few weeks, he stumbled somewhat and could end up in trouble this week. I don't have him being in the bottom three this week, but I'm sure you all remember what happened to Michael Johns last year in the top eight. That could actually end up happening this year with Kris, although his performance wasn't nearly as good as Michael's was last year. Allison continues to shine week in and week out and this week was no exception. I believe America will embrace her a little more because the judges actually complemented Allison on her singing abilities instead of what she was wearing. Meanwhile, Lil Rounds is free falling to a place I never imagined she might end up, getting kicked out before the top six. And I don't believe the judges will save her, either. And last but not least is Scott. He's an inspiring individual and has a great personality. However, his vocals just aren't as good as the rest of the group. I pick Scott to leave this week.
Don't forget to watch tonight's results show. I'm sure it'll be as dramatic as always!
Scott leaves American Idol and I have correctly picked the last three eliminees in a row!
Showing posts with label Matt Giraud. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Matt Giraud. Show all posts
Wednesday, April 08, 2009
Wednesday, March 18, 2009
American Idol 8 - Top 11
It's time to get out your cowboy hat and boots and celebrate country music on American Idol this week! More specifically, the songs featured on this week's Idol come from artists who belong to the coveted Grand Ole Opry. This week also is the first of the mentor weeks as Randy Travis gives his advice about each of the contestant's songs. There isn't a huge amount of recent country artists included in the Grand Old Opry, from what I understand. So the contestants have a choice of picking songs that go way back to the Country-Western times. Somehow I don't think they want to be classified as being too "old-fashioned" either. Seeing that Carrie Underwood is a member of the Grand Old Opry, how much you wanna bet that we'll be seeing one or two of her songs featured by this week's contestants? I guess we'll find out.Michael Sarver - "Ain't Goin' Down Til the Sun Comes Up" : Country seems to fit Michael well even though he's made comments previously that it's not the kind of music he wants to sing. It's a very fast, upbeat country song. He appears extremely comfortable on stage singing this song, even interacting with the audience. Michael does a nice effort with this performance. It involved plenty of risk especially with a song that moves as fast as this; it could've been very easy for him to stumble and forget a lyric or two. It was a good performance, but not spectacular. Agreed with Randy in that it didn't show off his vocal abilities like it could've.
Allison Iraheta - "Blame it on Your Heart" : A very rock-country type of song for Allison. I am not familiar with this song but I am going to assume the original does not have this much of a rock flair to it. Allison infused her own rock edge to it and it fit her personality to a T. She plays to her strengths and does a nice job. She is having lots of fun; seems very comfortable moving around on stage. I do think that her lack of a large fan base may end up hurting her at this stage of the competition. She's been a solid performer, but typically the American audience doesn't embrace a female rocker like Allison.
Kris Allen - "To Make You Feel My Love" : Kris is going without his guitar tonight which I think is a very good move. I always feel that by mixing it up week after week, it shows off more variety. Kris shows a very vulnerable side to him with this performance. I think he's been getting better and better with each week. I tend to agree that he's probably better at singing ballads than more of the up-tempo songs. I could really feel his connection that he had with this song and he's definitely doing the right things to stay in this competition.
Lil Rounds - "Independence Day" : I thought the low notes in the early part of the song were too low for Lil and she struggled a bit there. She tried singing a straight country song and I don't think it quite fit her. She certainly could've included a more R' n B edge to the song and probably would've had much better success with it. I don't agree that a different song (such as Randy's suggestion of "I Will Always Love You) would've done Lil any better either. The performance definitely got much better in the later half of the song where she was able to hit those power notes like she usually does. This week certainly wasn't as strong as Lil has been.
Adam Lambert - "Ring of Fire" : I can empathize with Randy Travis in how he was speechless over Adam. I mean, what can you really say about this? It started out very intense. It almost seemed as if I was watching a Broadway rendition of this classic Johnny Cash song. He starts to infuse his usual vocal dynamics into the song once the tempo picks up. This whole performance has a very different sound to it; no question it has more of a middle eastern flair to it. I can say I've never seen anything like it on American Idol. Honestly, this is supposed to be country week, right? One thing you can say about Adam is that he is entertaining.
Scott MacIntyre - "Wild Angels" : I can tell Scott enjoys picking songs that tell a message. Again as I've said before, Scott isn't the most dynamic singer during this season of Idol - but he definitely holds his own. He struggled more with the lower notes in this song. I would tend to agree that he shouldn't always be playing the piano during his live performances but then again, he's not going to be moving steadily across the stage without it, either. He's doing what he feels is most comfortable to him. The falsetto note towards the end of the song wasn't great. Overall, I'd say it was a good performance from Scott, but not great.
Alexis Grace - "Jolene" : It will be interesting to see how Alexis pulls this one out. We're used to seeing her sing rock songs with a harder edge. "Jolene" is more of a softer tune and Alexis even said she wanted to show that side of her. I don't entirely believe it was the right song choice for this particular week. Overall, she struggles a bit with the song and is off-tune throughout. The arrangement just wasn't as favorable for her to be successful this week, either. Basically, it was just an okay performance and actually was quite forgettable. A rare off week for Alexis so far in the competition.
Danny Gokey - "Jesus Take The Wheel" : There's always a certain risk to choosing a song that has been created by a former Idol. I think a different song would've suited Danny better, especially one that wasn't so low or bland to start. The front part of the song just sounded awkward to me; even though that's how it's supposed to sound. Of course be rebounded well with the later half of the song once the tempo picked up and he was able to get into his upper register. That is typical of Danny's performances there. He's a very likable guy, but this week he was just good for me, not great.
Anoop Desai - "You Were Always on My Mind" : Anoop goes the Kris Allen route and performs a softer, vulnerable ballad. It's a perfect song choice because it allows Anoop to show off his vocal talents. He is definitely much improved over the last couple of weeks. He doesn't go over board with the song and holds back more. It was definitely a much more controlled performance and he doesn't try to do too much with it. It was very well done and it's nice to see him get such great reviews from the judges. Another very likable guy.
Megan Joy - "Walking After Midnight" : We have absolutely no idea that Megan has been sick this week except after her performance is over when she starts coughing. I don't know what more you can say about Megan that hasn't already been said. The judges say time and time again that she's quirky and unique. That about sums up this performance. It was the perfect song choice for Megan and she delivered on that unique sound of hers. She made the song her own and certainly made it much more memorable. And actually, it was a lot better than I thought it was going to be.
Matt Giraud - "So Small" : Whenever I think of Matt, I just can't get his Coldplay performance out of my head. He has been severely damaged because of that and hopefully as we move further along in the competition, that performance in particular can be all but a memory. He is a super-talented guy and there's no question he belongs in this competition. He does a very impressive job with this Carrie Underwood song. He is a true consummate musician - I think he nailed this song tonight and it proved to be a very memorable performance.
So how did the contestants fair? Here is tonight's performance rankings:
1.) Matt Giraud
2.) Anoop Desai
3.) Kris Allen
4.) Allison Iraheta
5.) Adam Lambert
6.) Danny Gokey
7.) Megan Joy
8.) Michael Sarver
9.) Lil Rounds
10.) Alexis Grace (actual eliminee 3/19/09)
11.) Scott MacIntyre
CODES:
best of the night
in danger of being eliminated
As for who will be eliminated tonight - now that is a very tough call. Even though I've had a very tough time connecting with every one of the contestants this year, they are all extremely talented. I thought these last couple of weeks have been very strong, vocal-wise. In my opinion, the top six in this week's performance rankings are a lock and in no risk of going home anytime soon. Adam, Anoop, and Danny have such huge fan bases. Allison has been consistently strong each and every week even though her fan base isn't quite as big as the three guys mentioned. Kris Allen has been improving with each week and is quickly becoming a fan favorite. And then there's Matt Giraud who we know is an amazing musician. He stumbled pretty seriously after his Coldplay performance but quickly picked himself back up and is making a strong push towards the later stages of this competition.
Now as for the bottom five of the performance rankings, the only one that could be considered a pretty sure lock to stay in this competition for a long time is Lil Rounds. She, too, has a pretty strong fan base. Megan, Michael, and Scott are basically just cannon fodder. It'll only be a matter of time before they get eliminated. As for Alexis, she also has a relatively small fan base and one weak performance like this week's could leave her in serious danger. That is why I am picking Alexis Grace to be this week's eliminated contestant on American Idol. I know, it's a mild-shocker seeing how well she has done in prior weeks. But does anyone see her outlasting Adam, Danny, Anoop, or Matt? The males truly are the stronger of the gender this season and the only female contestant that stands a chance to last awhile is Lil, and maybe Allison, too. It could be a very, very interesting results show tonight. Don't miss it!
(UPDATE: Sad to say, but I ended up being right - Alexis is eliminated. It is never easy, especially someone with her talent. Only one sub-par performance was all it took for her to be booted off. I am disappointed she is gone, to say the least.)
Tuesday, March 10, 2009
American Idol 8 - Top 13
And let the real show begin! We have now advanced to the final round of American Idol and I've got to say, I am excited! Despite the fact that I don't have the same buzz like I did with last season, I still have good feelings that season eight will end up being just as great. There is a lot of good talent in this year's pool; I just think we haven't seen the contestants live up to their potential. Hopefully everyone will be able to step it up as tonight they sing the songs of Michael Jackson. I believe that MJ has a vast collection of songs that are touchable; however, there are a few that shouldn't be attempted. Did any of tonight's contestants dare to cover some of those songs? We shall see. On with the review!
Lil Rounds - "The Way You Make Me Feel" : This is a very high energy song. She really looks good on stage; wearing a slimming outfit with nice, light colors. Lil appears comfortable being on stage and is not showing any nerves. Not sure if the song really shows off Lil's great vocal abilities but she definitely had fun with it. I believe she's absolutely perfect for this competition. Nice way to start the show.
Scott MacIntyre - "Keep the Faith" : Scott, as promised, playing the piano; exactly what I was looking forward to. I don't really believe he will be known for his vocal abilities in this competition because in my opinion, his singing is just average. But you have to admit he's one heck of a musician. The way he plays the piano is phenominal. I wasn't familiar with the song he chose this week so I was surprised the tempo picked up part-way through. I thought the end of the song was better than the beginning but overall, it was a very good effort from Scott.
Danny Gokey - "PYT (Pretty Young Thing)" : Danny is one of the most talked about contestants of season eight; either you love him or hate him. I thought his song choice was very odd and it started off really weird. But the tempo quickly picked up and suddenly it's one big party in the studio. Danny is full of energy and very likable. There's no doubt about his vocal abilities. He was very fun tonight and his singing wasn't half-bad either.
Michael Sarver - "You Are Not Alone" : I think this was a million times better than his semi-final performance singing "I Don't Wanna Be." This is more of a sound suited for Michael and he may be more comfortable singing ballads. The performance was just a bit boring for me when it started, but I really began to feel Michael's passion and soul. It was definitely a well-controlled performance.
Jasmine Murray - "I'll Be There" : A very predictable song choice from Jasmine. I wouldn't call it a pitch-perfect performance by no means. It was an admirable effort, however. She struggles with the lower notes in the song but I have to say the ending was better than the beginning. With the way she's dressed and picked songs the past couple of weeks, I can't get the "Princess Jasime" allusion out of my mind when I think of her. It's time she mixes things up and does something a little more edgy.
Kris Allen - "Remember the Time" : I really enjoyed how this started out. He injected a lot of soul into it and it didn't hurt with him playing the guitar. He showed a ton of confidence on stage and had lots of fun. Miles better than his semi-final song where he sang "Man in the Mirror." However, he did get a bit clumsy towards the end of the song when he may have gotten caught up in the moment and started over-singing and becoming off-tune. Still, much better than I was expecting.
Allison Iraheta - "Give it to Me" : She is certainly the bona-fide rocker chick in season eight and she's playing it off extremely well. I think it falls just a tad bit short of her semi-final performance where she sang "Alone," but it was still very good. She has no trouble hitting the right notes; even the higher ones in this song. She is definitely one of my favorites of this season so far.
Anoop Desai - "Beat it" : What a tremendously risky song for Anoop to sing. I have a feeling Simon will rip his performance to shreds; which he does. Actually the whole panel does! I didn't think it was terrible, but it wasn't great either. You could tell he was having a lot of fun with it, as he moved across the stage with ease; even interacting some with the audience. Still, a bit indulgent and over-the-top. I feel bad because Anoop is so likable. He really looks disappointed.
Jorge Nunez - "Never Can Say Goodbye" : I am really liking Jorge's sound with this song; has a very Latin-American feel and is very soulful. He even sounds like Marc Anthony at times. He was off on a few notes but overall I found the performance to be very enjoyable. I think he's a breath of fresh air for this show, especially if they are looking for a singer in the Latin American market. I'm still rather puzzled why the judges panned it so terribly.
Megan Joy Corkrey - "Rockin' Robin" : A very fun, quirky song for Megan - seems to fit her nicely. She looks absolutely stunning tonight in that red dress. I love her personality; she seems very bubbly. I'll admit, I wasn't blown away by her vocals but she is a very pleasant and likable person. It is an older song; maybe that's why it seems so old-fashioned. I was a bit taken aback by Simon calling her song choice "stupid." This is practically his girl!
Adam Lambert - "Black or White" : The start of the song seemed a bit sub-dued, more restrained. Things really start picking up towards the middle and end. I thought we were going to see a different side of Adam with the way the song started, but I should've known better. In my opinion, it's a bit over-the-top at times and shouty, but there's no question he's an amazing performer. He's so confident on that stage it's not even funny.
Matt Giraud - "Human Nature" : I am so totally digging the arrangement of this song. It almost has a naturistic-sound to it and it's enhanced even more with Matt playing on the piano. Loved the overall feel of the song. Probably not quite as good of a performance like his Wild Card song and I'd even characterize it as being a bit safe. But I believe we'll be seeing lots of Matt in the weeks to come.
Alexis Grace - "Dirty Diana" : I am really enjoying the start of this song. She really turned herself into this edgy, rocker-style performer. She has to be careful not to over-do it, however. Don't think it was pitch-perfect, but still, very nicely done. She appears to be very confident being on that big Idol stage. There's no question she's in her element while singing on this show and I look forward to her performing with her guitar in the weeks to come.
With the recap out of the way, how do I think the contestants performed tonight? Ask and you shall receive! Here are tonight's rankings:
1.) Danny Gokey
2.) Adam Lambert
3.) Lil Rounds
4.) Matt Giraud
5.) Allison Iraheta
6.) Michael Sarver
7.) Kris Allen
8.) Alexis Grace
9.) Jorge Nunez (actual eliminee 3/11/09)
10.) Scott MacIntyre
11.) Megan Joy Corkrey
12.) Jasmine Murray (actual eliminee 3/11/09)
13.) Anoop Desai
My prediction: Jasmine Murray and Jorge Nunez will go home. Jorge is a very memorable contestant but I don't think he did enough with his song tonight. And it doesn't help when he gets absolutely sand-bagged by the judges! I still don't get why they thought it was so horrible. Jorge is a very happy and likable guy. Obviously it will be very disappointing to see him go home at this stage of the competition. Meanwhile, Jasmine has "cannon fodder" written across her profile in big, bold lettering. Honestly, I don't understand why she was even chosen as a wild card because in my opinion (and many others), Jesse Langseth was a much stronger contestant at this stage of the competition. I just don't see a whole lot of star potential in Jasmine, so it would not surprise me at all to see her get the boot this week.
Still, don't be surprised if there's a huge, shocking elimination during the next couple of weeks. That is, if the fan votes still count after the anticipated rule change that will take effect on tonight's results show. The speculation on the internet is that the judges will get a one-time veto of the fans' votes where they can bring back a deserving contestant who's on the brink of being eliminated far too early. If this is the new rule that will take effect, will they be hesitant to save a contestant like Allison, Matt, or Michael? Honestly, the three I believe are untouchable are Danny, Adam, and Lil. I think those three have a clear path right down to the top three so long as either one don't seriously mess up. As for the others, it's probably only a matter of time before they get voted off.
Be sure to enjoy the results on Wednesday. Kelly Clarkson will be peforming her hit song, "My Life Would Suck Without You." Really looking forward to that!
(After the results show, I picked both contestants sent home. Whoot! First time this season.)
Lil Rounds - "The Way You Make Me Feel" : This is a very high energy song. She really looks good on stage; wearing a slimming outfit with nice, light colors. Lil appears comfortable being on stage and is not showing any nerves. Not sure if the song really shows off Lil's great vocal abilities but she definitely had fun with it. I believe she's absolutely perfect for this competition. Nice way to start the show.
Scott MacIntyre - "Keep the Faith" : Scott, as promised, playing the piano; exactly what I was looking forward to. I don't really believe he will be known for his vocal abilities in this competition because in my opinion, his singing is just average. But you have to admit he's one heck of a musician. The way he plays the piano is phenominal. I wasn't familiar with the song he chose this week so I was surprised the tempo picked up part-way through. I thought the end of the song was better than the beginning but overall, it was a very good effort from Scott.
Danny Gokey - "PYT (Pretty Young Thing)" : Danny is one of the most talked about contestants of season eight; either you love him or hate him. I thought his song choice was very odd and it started off really weird. But the tempo quickly picked up and suddenly it's one big party in the studio. Danny is full of energy and very likable. There's no doubt about his vocal abilities. He was very fun tonight and his singing wasn't half-bad either.
Michael Sarver - "You Are Not Alone" : I think this was a million times better than his semi-final performance singing "I Don't Wanna Be." This is more of a sound suited for Michael and he may be more comfortable singing ballads. The performance was just a bit boring for me when it started, but I really began to feel Michael's passion and soul. It was definitely a well-controlled performance.
Jasmine Murray - "I'll Be There" : A very predictable song choice from Jasmine. I wouldn't call it a pitch-perfect performance by no means. It was an admirable effort, however. She struggles with the lower notes in the song but I have to say the ending was better than the beginning. With the way she's dressed and picked songs the past couple of weeks, I can't get the "Princess Jasime" allusion out of my mind when I think of her. It's time she mixes things up and does something a little more edgy.
Kris Allen - "Remember the Time" : I really enjoyed how this started out. He injected a lot of soul into it and it didn't hurt with him playing the guitar. He showed a ton of confidence on stage and had lots of fun. Miles better than his semi-final song where he sang "Man in the Mirror." However, he did get a bit clumsy towards the end of the song when he may have gotten caught up in the moment and started over-singing and becoming off-tune. Still, much better than I was expecting.
Allison Iraheta - "Give it to Me" : She is certainly the bona-fide rocker chick in season eight and she's playing it off extremely well. I think it falls just a tad bit short of her semi-final performance where she sang "Alone," but it was still very good. She has no trouble hitting the right notes; even the higher ones in this song. She is definitely one of my favorites of this season so far.
Anoop Desai - "Beat it" : What a tremendously risky song for Anoop to sing. I have a feeling Simon will rip his performance to shreds; which he does. Actually the whole panel does! I didn't think it was terrible, but it wasn't great either. You could tell he was having a lot of fun with it, as he moved across the stage with ease; even interacting some with the audience. Still, a bit indulgent and over-the-top. I feel bad because Anoop is so likable. He really looks disappointed.
Jorge Nunez - "Never Can Say Goodbye" : I am really liking Jorge's sound with this song; has a very Latin-American feel and is very soulful. He even sounds like Marc Anthony at times. He was off on a few notes but overall I found the performance to be very enjoyable. I think he's a breath of fresh air for this show, especially if they are looking for a singer in the Latin American market. I'm still rather puzzled why the judges panned it so terribly.
Megan Joy Corkrey - "Rockin' Robin" : A very fun, quirky song for Megan - seems to fit her nicely. She looks absolutely stunning tonight in that red dress. I love her personality; she seems very bubbly. I'll admit, I wasn't blown away by her vocals but she is a very pleasant and likable person. It is an older song; maybe that's why it seems so old-fashioned. I was a bit taken aback by Simon calling her song choice "stupid." This is practically his girl!
Adam Lambert - "Black or White" : The start of the song seemed a bit sub-dued, more restrained. Things really start picking up towards the middle and end. I thought we were going to see a different side of Adam with the way the song started, but I should've known better. In my opinion, it's a bit over-the-top at times and shouty, but there's no question he's an amazing performer. He's so confident on that stage it's not even funny.
Matt Giraud - "Human Nature" : I am so totally digging the arrangement of this song. It almost has a naturistic-sound to it and it's enhanced even more with Matt playing on the piano. Loved the overall feel of the song. Probably not quite as good of a performance like his Wild Card song and I'd even characterize it as being a bit safe. But I believe we'll be seeing lots of Matt in the weeks to come.
Alexis Grace - "Dirty Diana" : I am really enjoying the start of this song. She really turned herself into this edgy, rocker-style performer. She has to be careful not to over-do it, however. Don't think it was pitch-perfect, but still, very nicely done. She appears to be very confident being on that big Idol stage. There's no question she's in her element while singing on this show and I look forward to her performing with her guitar in the weeks to come.
With the recap out of the way, how do I think the contestants performed tonight? Ask and you shall receive! Here are tonight's rankings:
1.) Danny Gokey
2.) Adam Lambert
3.) Lil Rounds
4.) Matt Giraud
5.) Allison Iraheta
6.) Michael Sarver
7.) Kris Allen
8.) Alexis Grace
9.) Jorge Nunez (actual eliminee 3/11/09)
10.) Scott MacIntyre
11.) Megan Joy Corkrey
12.) Jasmine Murray (actual eliminee 3/11/09)
13.) Anoop Desai
My prediction: Jasmine Murray and Jorge Nunez will go home. Jorge is a very memorable contestant but I don't think he did enough with his song tonight. And it doesn't help when he gets absolutely sand-bagged by the judges! I still don't get why they thought it was so horrible. Jorge is a very happy and likable guy. Obviously it will be very disappointing to see him go home at this stage of the competition. Meanwhile, Jasmine has "cannon fodder" written across her profile in big, bold lettering. Honestly, I don't understand why she was even chosen as a wild card because in my opinion (and many others), Jesse Langseth was a much stronger contestant at this stage of the competition. I just don't see a whole lot of star potential in Jasmine, so it would not surprise me at all to see her get the boot this week.
Still, don't be surprised if there's a huge, shocking elimination during the next couple of weeks. That is, if the fan votes still count after the anticipated rule change that will take effect on tonight's results show. The speculation on the internet is that the judges will get a one-time veto of the fans' votes where they can bring back a deserving contestant who's on the brink of being eliminated far too early. If this is the new rule that will take effect, will they be hesitant to save a contestant like Allison, Matt, or Michael? Honestly, the three I believe are untouchable are Danny, Adam, and Lil. I think those three have a clear path right down to the top three so long as either one don't seriously mess up. As for the others, it's probably only a matter of time before they get voted off.
Be sure to enjoy the results on Wednesday. Kelly Clarkson will be peforming her hit song, "My Life Would Suck Without You." Really looking forward to that!
(After the results show, I picked both contestants sent home. Whoot! First time this season.)
Thursday, February 26, 2009
American Idol 8 - Top 36 Group 2
It's a new week so it's time for another recap of last night's American Idol performances. We're one week later than last week because of President Obama's address to Congress on Tuesday. Either way, we still get two shows this week. It's another week of songs from the Billboard Top 100 from any year, apparently. So the contestants have a wide selection of songs to pick from. One thing I am definitely liking this year over last is the choice of contemporary songs in the semi-final round. That was sorely lacking last season and it's nice they've done an about-change in season eight. As for this week, I am liking a few changes they have made since the last performance show. The parents/friends are in the audience instead of up on the balcony - so we aren't getting any overly excessive chatter once the performances have concluded. Also, there weren't nearly as many camera flaws or production errors. It appears they have most, if not all of their ducks in a row. So, on with the review!
Jasmine Murray - "Love Song" : I do enjoy her choice in this contemporary song, especially one that allowed Sara Bareilles to become a break-out star. As for Jasmine, it doesn't start out all that great. In using Randy's term, it was very pitchy in spots. It seemed to get better as the performance moved along but yet I don't believe this was the right song choice for her. It was just an okay performance; certainly did not blow me away. As she's proven during her audition and in Hollywood week, she can sing. She just needs to pick the right song that really shows off her vocal ability. "Love Song" doesn't allow Jasmine to do that. I will say this, her stage presence is very good and she appeared very confident.
Matt Giraud - "Viva La Vida" : Up next we have Michigan's very own Matt Giraud, so you know I am rooting for him to do well. I am a bit worried, however, because he picks such a well-known contemporary song that was one of the top songs for the year in 2008. I don't know if it's exactly the kind of song that shows off Matt's vocal abilities. In fact, I think it may be too big of a song for him. He's trying to do too much with the song; trying to deliver an epic and memorable performance. Honestly, it falls short for me. Like the judges, I find him most appealing when he's behind a piano doing the more soulful stuff. Why haven't we seen any contestants playing instruments in the semi-finals anyways? They were allowed to last season - so why not now? Anyways, I am rather disappointed for Matt.
Jeanine Vailes - "This Love" : Another of those contestants that we know absolutely nothing about! It was Ricky last week and now Jeanine this week. Well, we do know she's a bartender. Big whoop. She's 28 and apparently she's been waiting all her life for an opportunity like this. Let's see if she can deliver. Nope; not gonna happen. I think Maroon 5 is a fabulous group, but this is the wrong song for Jeanine. She just blew her big shot at a music career. Back to being a bartender, I'm afraid. It's a train wreck right from the start. She's all over with the notes and towards the end, she wasn't either above or below the actual notes. I think she was trying to do way too much with the song in the later half. It just doesn't sound good at all. Oh well, at least she has great looking legs!
Nick Mitchell - "And I am Telling You" : This guy is an absolute clown, but I have to admit, he's hilarious. The whole banter between him and Simon during Nick's audition was hysterical. Plus, when he's not being comedic, he can actually sing. He has a good singing voice somewhere behind the hysterics. I am actually hoping the real Nick Mitchell shows up and not Normund Gentle - because this is where things get serious and a person needs to show off how well they can sing. Ah well, he doesn't follow my advice and he's doing the Normund routine. Even though this is a competition to find America's next break-out music star, Nick is kind of refreshing. Although this isn't the right show for him (try "America's Got Talent" instead), he certainly is a memorable figure and makes the show interesting whenever he happens to be on. Again, very funny stuff.
Allison Iraheta - "Alone" : She is very young; not even 17 yet! She doesn't seem all that confident in herself and appears to be quite nervous. And ouch, right off the bat she's picking the classic Heart song that has been covered countless number of time's on the Idol stage. So I am definitely nervous for her. Will her performance even be comparable to Carrie Underwood's or Gina Glocksen's? I don't necessarily believe it was as good as Carrie's version (and honestly, who's ever will?), but it was still very good. She may not seem all that confident during interviews, but on that stage, she's a powerful singer. Now that is how to do a performance during the semi-finals. Allison has the best performance of the night so far and she should earn a spot in this season's top 12.
Kris Allen - "Man in the Mirror" : Uh oh; not another Michael Jackson song! It didn't work out very well for Stephen Fowler last week; we'll see if it's any different for Kris this week. He's another contestant we don't know much about so he'll definitely have to kick it into high gear and sing for his life, otherwise he has no shot. I really didn't care how the song starts - and it's not really Kris's fault for that because that is how the song is. He has a few pitch problems here and there but his performance improves as the song moves along. Despite the interesting song choice, Kris doesn't do that badly with it. I just wish the song would've been a lot stronger in the beginning, otherwise Kris would've had more of a fighting chance. I wasn't blown away by it, but it ends up being the best male vocal so far.
Megan Joy Corkrey - "Put Your Records On" : I really like her and hope she does well. I agree with Paula's assessment that she looks great on camera. She has a very unique sound to her and I am absolutely digging this song choice for Megan. I would agree that her stage presence does need work; she's fidgety and does some odd twists. However, her singing isn't bad. Again, it's not spectacular vocal-wise but she did a decent job with it. The song fits her vocal abilities but some of the notes, especially in the higher range were off at times. But I thought she provided one of the more shining moments during the show than what we've seen so far.
Matt Breitzke - "If You Can Only See" : I think the contestant's have been picking great songs; yet in most cases, they are not the right songs for them, per se. It was another example of that for Matt. I really enjoy this Tonic song but Matt's rendition was pretty bland. I just wasn't jumping up and down with it and although he can sing, as we've seen during Hollywood week, it just didn't live up to its potential. He should've chosen a song that shows off more of his vocal prowess. I would agree with the judges that he hit all of the right notes in the song, however, the song doesn't have a real big range to it. It also would've helped if was a higher energy song, too. Would've helped his chances in advancing to the top 12 some.
Jesse Langseth - "Bette Davis Eyes" : Prior to the episode where the top 36 were chosen, we didn't know much about Jesse. However, at least we know more of her history than we do for Jeanine and Kris. It appears she has been singing for awhile and is waiting for a big break. Maybe Idol will help her out. When I first heard her performance of "Bette Davis Eyes," I wasn't all that impressed. However, after listening back to it a couple of different times, it's grown on me. Like we've seen many times so far in group two, I wasn't blown away by it but vocally it was quite good and it definitely had its moments. Again, could she have picked a song that had more of a range? Yes, but she did quite well with what she chose.
Kai Kalama - "What Becomes of a Broken Hearted" : So after all of the contemporary songs the contestant's have chosen so far during the performance night, Kai's pick is the song with the oldest track record. As Paula said, he seems to like the older songs more, which might be why he performs them the most. However, he says he's a contemporary guy, but we probably won't be able to see that side from him after this performance. He definitely comes across as an old fashioned guy. Again, I am not blown away by it. It's just average and I'm actually bored. He could've picked a Bee Gees song or something with a little more energy - if he wants to sway towards the throw-back songs. Another disappointment from someone with high potential.
Mishavonna Henson - "Drops of Jupiter" : Back on the contemporary train (no pun intended) and Mishavonna picks a good one. However, it's not a good choice for her performance. It's not really a vocally powerful song and the performance becomes rather bland to me. I mean, she can definitely sing and I feel quite bad for her because she has been in the Idol competition for two year's running and it's going to fall short for her again. I liked it more once it picked up tempo half-way through but still not as spectacular as I was hoping. Again, if she could've chosen a song more fitting to her style, she'd definitely be a lock for a spot into the top 12, if not the wildcard. I still believe she's going to fall well short of contention.
Adam Lambert - "Satisfaction" : You know, I haven't been a big fan of Adam thus far in the competition. I thought he's been too dramatic, over-the-top and yes, too theatrical. However, I think the tide is beginning to turn and he became more likable for me tonight. "Satisfaction" is definitely a high-energy song and it'll get everyone up off their feet. During the performance, he's a little shouty at times but he's certainly having a good time on stage. I agree with Kara in that he has a phenominal vocal range - you don't see many guys who can sing with such an amazing falsetto. No surprise here; he's a shoo-in for top male vocal in group two.
So, who sang the best and the worst during the top 36 - group two performance night? Well, here's how I rank them:
Top Six Male Performers:
1.) Adam Lambert
2.) Kris Allen
3.) Matt Giraud
4.) Matt Breitzke
5.) Kai Kalama
6.) Nick Mitchell
Top Six Female Performers:
1.) Allison Iraheta
2.) Megan Joy Corkery
3.) Jesse Langseth
4.) Mishavonna Henson
5.) Jasmine Murray
6.) Jeanine Vailes
Who'll be advancing to the top 12? Here are my picks:
M - Adam Lambert
F - Allison Iraheta
M - Matt Giraud
Be sure to enjoy tonight's results! Despite the corny group performances, it's always a high intensity show. See you again next week!
Jasmine Murray - "Love Song" : I do enjoy her choice in this contemporary song, especially one that allowed Sara Bareilles to become a break-out star. As for Jasmine, it doesn't start out all that great. In using Randy's term, it was very pitchy in spots. It seemed to get better as the performance moved along but yet I don't believe this was the right song choice for her. It was just an okay performance; certainly did not blow me away. As she's proven during her audition and in Hollywood week, she can sing. She just needs to pick the right song that really shows off her vocal ability. "Love Song" doesn't allow Jasmine to do that. I will say this, her stage presence is very good and she appeared very confident.
Matt Giraud - "Viva La Vida" : Up next we have Michigan's very own Matt Giraud, so you know I am rooting for him to do well. I am a bit worried, however, because he picks such a well-known contemporary song that was one of the top songs for the year in 2008. I don't know if it's exactly the kind of song that shows off Matt's vocal abilities. In fact, I think it may be too big of a song for him. He's trying to do too much with the song; trying to deliver an epic and memorable performance. Honestly, it falls short for me. Like the judges, I find him most appealing when he's behind a piano doing the more soulful stuff. Why haven't we seen any contestants playing instruments in the semi-finals anyways? They were allowed to last season - so why not now? Anyways, I am rather disappointed for Matt.
Jeanine Vailes - "This Love" : Another of those contestants that we know absolutely nothing about! It was Ricky last week and now Jeanine this week. Well, we do know she's a bartender. Big whoop. She's 28 and apparently she's been waiting all her life for an opportunity like this. Let's see if she can deliver. Nope; not gonna happen. I think Maroon 5 is a fabulous group, but this is the wrong song for Jeanine. She just blew her big shot at a music career. Back to being a bartender, I'm afraid. It's a train wreck right from the start. She's all over with the notes and towards the end, she wasn't either above or below the actual notes. I think she was trying to do way too much with the song in the later half. It just doesn't sound good at all. Oh well, at least she has great looking legs!
Nick Mitchell - "And I am Telling You" : This guy is an absolute clown, but I have to admit, he's hilarious. The whole banter between him and Simon during Nick's audition was hysterical. Plus, when he's not being comedic, he can actually sing. He has a good singing voice somewhere behind the hysterics. I am actually hoping the real Nick Mitchell shows up and not Normund Gentle - because this is where things get serious and a person needs to show off how well they can sing. Ah well, he doesn't follow my advice and he's doing the Normund routine. Even though this is a competition to find America's next break-out music star, Nick is kind of refreshing. Although this isn't the right show for him (try "America's Got Talent" instead), he certainly is a memorable figure and makes the show interesting whenever he happens to be on. Again, very funny stuff.
Allison Iraheta - "Alone" : She is very young; not even 17 yet! She doesn't seem all that confident in herself and appears to be quite nervous. And ouch, right off the bat she's picking the classic Heart song that has been covered countless number of time's on the Idol stage. So I am definitely nervous for her. Will her performance even be comparable to Carrie Underwood's or Gina Glocksen's? I don't necessarily believe it was as good as Carrie's version (and honestly, who's ever will?), but it was still very good. She may not seem all that confident during interviews, but on that stage, she's a powerful singer. Now that is how to do a performance during the semi-finals. Allison has the best performance of the night so far and she should earn a spot in this season's top 12.
Kris Allen - "Man in the Mirror" : Uh oh; not another Michael Jackson song! It didn't work out very well for Stephen Fowler last week; we'll see if it's any different for Kris this week. He's another contestant we don't know much about so he'll definitely have to kick it into high gear and sing for his life, otherwise he has no shot. I really didn't care how the song starts - and it's not really Kris's fault for that because that is how the song is. He has a few pitch problems here and there but his performance improves as the song moves along. Despite the interesting song choice, Kris doesn't do that badly with it. I just wish the song would've been a lot stronger in the beginning, otherwise Kris would've had more of a fighting chance. I wasn't blown away by it, but it ends up being the best male vocal so far.
Megan Joy Corkrey - "Put Your Records On" : I really like her and hope she does well. I agree with Paula's assessment that she looks great on camera. She has a very unique sound to her and I am absolutely digging this song choice for Megan. I would agree that her stage presence does need work; she's fidgety and does some odd twists. However, her singing isn't bad. Again, it's not spectacular vocal-wise but she did a decent job with it. The song fits her vocal abilities but some of the notes, especially in the higher range were off at times. But I thought she provided one of the more shining moments during the show than what we've seen so far.
Matt Breitzke - "If You Can Only See" : I think the contestant's have been picking great songs; yet in most cases, they are not the right songs for them, per se. It was another example of that for Matt. I really enjoy this Tonic song but Matt's rendition was pretty bland. I just wasn't jumping up and down with it and although he can sing, as we've seen during Hollywood week, it just didn't live up to its potential. He should've chosen a song that shows off more of his vocal prowess. I would agree with the judges that he hit all of the right notes in the song, however, the song doesn't have a real big range to it. It also would've helped if was a higher energy song, too. Would've helped his chances in advancing to the top 12 some.
Jesse Langseth - "Bette Davis Eyes" : Prior to the episode where the top 36 were chosen, we didn't know much about Jesse. However, at least we know more of her history than we do for Jeanine and Kris. It appears she has been singing for awhile and is waiting for a big break. Maybe Idol will help her out. When I first heard her performance of "Bette Davis Eyes," I wasn't all that impressed. However, after listening back to it a couple of different times, it's grown on me. Like we've seen many times so far in group two, I wasn't blown away by it but vocally it was quite good and it definitely had its moments. Again, could she have picked a song that had more of a range? Yes, but she did quite well with what she chose.
Kai Kalama - "What Becomes of a Broken Hearted" : So after all of the contemporary songs the contestant's have chosen so far during the performance night, Kai's pick is the song with the oldest track record. As Paula said, he seems to like the older songs more, which might be why he performs them the most. However, he says he's a contemporary guy, but we probably won't be able to see that side from him after this performance. He definitely comes across as an old fashioned guy. Again, I am not blown away by it. It's just average and I'm actually bored. He could've picked a Bee Gees song or something with a little more energy - if he wants to sway towards the throw-back songs. Another disappointment from someone with high potential.
Mishavonna Henson - "Drops of Jupiter" : Back on the contemporary train (no pun intended) and Mishavonna picks a good one. However, it's not a good choice for her performance. It's not really a vocally powerful song and the performance becomes rather bland to me. I mean, she can definitely sing and I feel quite bad for her because she has been in the Idol competition for two year's running and it's going to fall short for her again. I liked it more once it picked up tempo half-way through but still not as spectacular as I was hoping. Again, if she could've chosen a song more fitting to her style, she'd definitely be a lock for a spot into the top 12, if not the wildcard. I still believe she's going to fall well short of contention.
Adam Lambert - "Satisfaction" : You know, I haven't been a big fan of Adam thus far in the competition. I thought he's been too dramatic, over-the-top and yes, too theatrical. However, I think the tide is beginning to turn and he became more likable for me tonight. "Satisfaction" is definitely a high-energy song and it'll get everyone up off their feet. During the performance, he's a little shouty at times but he's certainly having a good time on stage. I agree with Kara in that he has a phenominal vocal range - you don't see many guys who can sing with such an amazing falsetto. No surprise here; he's a shoo-in for top male vocal in group two.
So, who sang the best and the worst during the top 36 - group two performance night? Well, here's how I rank them:
Top Six Male Performers:
1.) Adam Lambert
2.) Kris Allen
3.) Matt Giraud
4.) Matt Breitzke
5.) Kai Kalama
6.) Nick Mitchell
Top Six Female Performers:
1.) Allison Iraheta
2.) Megan Joy Corkery
3.) Jesse Langseth
4.) Mishavonna Henson
5.) Jasmine Murray
6.) Jeanine Vailes
Who'll be advancing to the top 12? Here are my picks:
M - Adam Lambert
F - Allison Iraheta
M - Matt Giraud
Be sure to enjoy tonight's results! Despite the corny group performances, it's always a high intensity show. See you again next week!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)