Here we are again with another American Idol recap. It's really getting down to the wire now, with only three contestants left! I'm always amazed when we get to this point in the season because it always seems to go by so quick. And this year is no exception. Man, what are us Idol fanatics going to do once the show ends next week? Ah well, it's like this every year. At least the weather is nice enough outside now that we'll be able to spend it out there more than watching TV in the summer. At least that's my plans. Anyways, regarding last night's Idol performance episode. I think we all know how big of a disappointment season nine has been overall. Don't really need to emphasize it anymore than it already has been. So heading into Top 3 night, I wasn't all that enthusiastic about the night - not like in prior seasons. I think it's been pretty clear for awhile that we'll end up with a Crystal and Lee finale. The only way Casey has a slim chance is if the other two completely flounder with their songs and Casey absolutely nails his songs. Let's find out exactly what happened last night ...
CONTESTANTS' SONG CHOICES:
Casey James - "Okay It's Alright With Me" by Eric Hutchinson : Interesting song choice from Casey because it's pretty obscure and relatively unknown. This could either work in his favor or completely bomb. Did you notice he almost had a near disastrous moment when he forgot his guitar pick in his pocket and had to quickly fish it out before the song took off on him? Nice save there. My initial reaction to his performance was that it was just okay. I was definitely not jumping up and down about it as I listened to it. I kind of compare it to Lite FM music - nothing big or fancy, but easy listening. The song certainly didn't have a lot of range to it and Casey did fine with it vocally. But as I said, it's not a big, dynamic song and at this stage of the game, it needed to be a better song choice.
Crystal Bowersox - "Come to My Window" by Melissa Etheridge : When I first heard that Crystal picked this song to perform last night, I thought this could really be huge for her. It's a great song and you'd think it would fit her perfectly. Well, it kind of fell flat for me. I honestly don't think she did enough with the song to make it her own. The song kind of started rather awkwardly (after the harmonica solo) when it almost seemed like she was whispering. I'd agree with the judges comments about the arrangement being off because it was. Not as great of an arrangement as it could've been. And she was really straining on those high notes in the song, especially during the chorus of the song. So for me, it wasn't as great of a performance from Crystal as I was expecting.
Lee Dewyze - "Simple Man" by Lynyrd Skynyrd : Now Lee picked the best song for himself out of all of the contestants on the night. It suited his style and you could tell he had a great time with it. I can't say I'm all that familiar with the original but it sounds as if Lee made it current and it could be a hit on today's radio. He is really beginning to own the stage now, as his confidence is there and he realizes he belongs there. I really think that visit home within the week did him some good. It goes to show what kind of impact he is having to those people watching at home. When you look back on the show in previous years and the kind of performances the contestants have at this stage of the game - this is the kind of performance Lee needed to have and he did exactly right by it.
JUDGES' SONG CHOICES:
Casey James - "Daughters" by John Mayer: Here we have the laugh-out-loud moment when Randy Jackson says "as Casey James leaves the show" when commenting why he and Kara chose the song for Casey. Nice, real nice Randy - as if Casey has no chance (well, he really doesn't). It was a real nice performance from Casey and it suited him quite well. He certainly didn't have a moment with it, as it's not one of those songs that'll wow a person. But he did a competent job with it, changed it up just enough to make it his own, and vocally it was quite good. I read or heard a comment during the week that Casey is probably the best guitarist that Idol has ever seen (contestant-wise) and we may not ever see someone that talented again, and that's true. He certainly knows how to wield out a guitar, that is for sure.
Crystal Bowersox - "Maybe I'm Amazed" by Paul McCartney : Coming into this performance from Crystal, I was wondering how'd she do with it and what she'd do to make it her own. She stepped out of her comfort zone a bit (even though we've seen her do that on occasion this season) by not playing her guitar and even performing from different spots on the Idol stage. I must say, this is the kind of performance that Crystal needed, especially on this night. I loved that she was able to show off the range in her voice. Wow, those high notes - who knew she could sing those? I really liked how she controlled the performance, from singing all out to dialing it back when it was appropriate. She is a true musician and is definitely deserving to be on that Idol stage next week in the finale.
Lee Dewyze - "Hallelujah" by Leonard Cohen : Oh my goodness, where do I begin. First off, the song choice by Simon. As we've seen earlier this season when Tim Urban performed it, it's one of those songs that can allow anyone to have a moment. As further proof, look at Jason Castro in season seven. It's got a great, haunting message to it and you can't go wrong with that. Secondly, the set-up by the Idol Powers-That-Be to bring in a choir and orchestra during the performance. An incredible effect but honestly, was it needed? Thirdly, Lee's vocal. It was awesome. He really excelled with the song and it suited him nicely. So taking that all into consideration, whether you want to call it over-pimping from the producers or what have you, I thought it was a nice moment for Lee. I actually got caught up into it all when I first watched it. But I can see why people would be turned off by all of the choreography going on within the performance. Lee's vocal shined on its own.
Top 3 Performance Rankings:
1.) Lee Dewyze
2.) Crystal Bowersox
3.) Casey James
Going Home: This really is a no-brainer this week, and after picking him to leave for awhile now, I honestly think I have a good shot at getting it right this week (whataya know!). Casey James' Idol journey ends tonight. Nice job on getting this far, Casey.
Showing posts with label top 3. Show all posts
Showing posts with label top 3. Show all posts
Wednesday, May 19, 2010
Tuesday, May 12, 2009
American Idol 8 - Top 3
The grand finale of American Idol season eight is one week away. This season seems to have flown by a lot quicker than last for some reason. Nonetheless, it's almost over and tonight is typically the night that makes it or breaks it for all three finalists. Obviously one gets sent home and at this stage of the game with all three singers highly qualified, it's going to come right down to the wire. One little flaw, flat note, or forgotten lyric could prove to be the death knell. At this stage of the competition, you want proven winners and people that will stand out from the rest of the pack. I think in this season's top three, they are all very talented people. Tonight is a very fun show because the contestants themselves get to make their own song picks and in prior seasons, their picks get scrutinized by the judges. Meanwhile, the judges attempt to make a song pick that suit their genre of music and their voices. Some are brilliant picks while others fall flat. This is the first season where Clive Davis or the producers won't get to make a third pick for the contestants (not really a big loss) due to an extra judge yakking and eating away precious performance time. So what's gonna happen tonight? Let's find out what went down on that Idol stage!
Danny Gokey - "Dance Little Sister" : Interesting song choice from Paula in that it's very obscure - or at least I've never heard it before. It's a fun, upbeat little ditty to open the show. Danny's all shouty right from the get go. And then we get the saxophone solo and he's scatting along with the saxophonist. Not finding that to be all that great. I will say this, his stage presence is quite good - he's moving around on the stage pretty freely, dancing, and showing a ton of confidence. Maybe he's having too much fun on stage because it's throwing off his vocals some. Overall, this was just an okay performance. I actually agreed with Kara in that this performance is pretty forgettable. Heck, I really don't remember much about the performance as I'm typing it and I don't really feel like watching it back again. More major pimping from Randy and Paula - they desperately want him in the finale. Danny talks way too much.
Kris Allen - "Apologize" : What on earth was Randy and Kara thinking when choosing this song for Kris, especially when David Archuleta did a killer version with One Republic themselves on last season's results finale? These judges are so clueless. Really loved the start of Kris' performance - playing on the piano where we hadn't seen him play all that much. I feel the song is a bit too high for Kris to handle - at least he doesn't seem comfortable going that high and he kind of drops an octave while going through a run on the first chorus. Despite that, it doesn't throw him off too badly. I thought the band drowned him out too much, particularly when Kris was attempting to hit those higher notes and this might have been nicer if it had a more acoustic sound to it. I didn't really pick up on the one bad note that Paula mentioned. Overall, I thought it was a decent performance from Kris.
Adam Lambert - "One" : You know, I was actually digging Simon's song choice for Adam when I first heard the news. But after the performance, it kind of landed a bit flat for me. Maybe "Wicked Games" would've been better - I dunno. I really liked the set-up for Adam in the beginning; him at the center of the stage with the blue mood lighting. Kind of reminded me of his "Mad World" performance. Manic Adam is in full effect a lot sooner than I was expecting. I don't know if I am enjoying the wicked-high vocals and shoutiness for this particular song. For me, I like it as more of that ballad sound. Adam is turning it more rock-ish towards the end. I've got nothing bad to say about his vocals because for what he did, they were spot on. But the song arrangement left me a tad bit disappointed. It might have worked better if he was toned-down throughout the entire song.
Danny Gokey - "You Are So Beautiful" : We're back for round two, where Danny makes his own song selection. He actually makes a pretty decent pick in "You Are So Beautiful" by Joe Cocker. The performance starts at first with no instruments, then an acoustic guitar, and gradually more instruments, but from the stage floor. I wouldn't say it was pitch perfect because I detected a few bum notes here and there. I am finding it to be a generally nice performance. Once again, is it something we're going to remember at the end of the day? Now the Danny we've all come to love - the shouty version! I am finding this much less enjoyable than the first part. I just prefer Danny when he's not trying to over-sing. I actually think he could've done more with the song than what he did. He made a few tweaks here and there and even injected some gospel into this classic song. But all in all, another average performance from Danny.
Kris Allen - "Heartless" : Well I'll be - Kris is actually getting some awesome lighting effects as he begins his performance. This is starting off really, really nice. It's just Kris and his guitar - the rest of the band is silent. The audience is just getting to focus on Kris and his guitar playing and it's pretty spectacular. I've got to admit, I wasn't sure if this song was going to work for Kris but he certainly made it his own and he put a completely different spin on the song and it's superb. It kind of reminds me of David Archuleta last year picking "With You" and while he made a great choice picking a contemporary song, I don't think it worked quite as well as he hoped. Now with Kris and this selection - it totally worked. The judges loved it, he was getting a great reaction from the audience, and this performance is one of many that we've come to love from Kris Allen. Best moment of the night right here with Kris' second song.
Adam Lambert - "Cryin' " : Ah, Adam tackling an Aerosmith song ... didn't somebody want Adam to perform an Aerosmith song? I'm thinking Melinda Doolittle - but she's obsessed with Aerosmith as a whole. Right from the get-go, his voice and one of the background singers is not meshing. I think that background singer is REALLY pitchy. But Adam Lambert is a pro - it's not throwing him off in the least. This is another strong rock-style vocal from Adam. I am actually liking this much more than his first performance and I agree with Randy that this is more of what works the best for Adam. What more can you say? This is Adam at his best being a rock star. It's a high energy performance; showing off his killer vocal skills. He truly nailed this song and he displayed great vocal control. American Idol has born it's newest star in Adam Lambert.
Hmm, my spell check isn't working! So if you notice any misspellings, blame blogger, not me. Anyways, here is how I rank tonight's performances:
ROUND #1:
Adam Lambert - best
Kris Allen
Danny Gokey - worst (actual eliminee - 5/13/09)
ROUND #2:
Kris Allen - best
Adam Lambert
Danny Gokey - worst (actual eliminee - 5/13/09)
This is going to be an absolutely tough choice in deciding who gets sent home. I've become a big Kris fan, so I'd like to see him stay. I've enjoyed Adam for most of the top 13. And Danny has fallen out of favor for me. Based on tonight's performances, I've got to say that Danny should be going home. But I've got to take into account his massive fan base. Meanwhile, Kris is a regular, everyday, humble guy and his fan base has been growing. Adam is popular because he's flashy, theatrics, and has amazing vocals. I mean honestly, it's truly a toss-up. With that being said, here is goes. Adam is safe - and in a shocker, Danny goes home and Kris makes it to the finale. That's right, I said it! Let's see if it all comes true tomorrow night. I have a feeling tomorrow's results show is going to be extremely tense. Be sure to enjoy it!
YIPEE!! Danny Gokey gets the boot on tonight's results show! So that means our finale will consist of Adam Lambert and Kris Allen. What a great pairing! I love it ... it will be awesome.
Danny Gokey - "Dance Little Sister" : Interesting song choice from Paula in that it's very obscure - or at least I've never heard it before. It's a fun, upbeat little ditty to open the show. Danny's all shouty right from the get go. And then we get the saxophone solo and he's scatting along with the saxophonist. Not finding that to be all that great. I will say this, his stage presence is quite good - he's moving around on the stage pretty freely, dancing, and showing a ton of confidence. Maybe he's having too much fun on stage because it's throwing off his vocals some. Overall, this was just an okay performance. I actually agreed with Kara in that this performance is pretty forgettable. Heck, I really don't remember much about the performance as I'm typing it and I don't really feel like watching it back again. More major pimping from Randy and Paula - they desperately want him in the finale. Danny talks way too much.
Kris Allen - "Apologize" : What on earth was Randy and Kara thinking when choosing this song for Kris, especially when David Archuleta did a killer version with One Republic themselves on last season's results finale? These judges are so clueless. Really loved the start of Kris' performance - playing on the piano where we hadn't seen him play all that much. I feel the song is a bit too high for Kris to handle - at least he doesn't seem comfortable going that high and he kind of drops an octave while going through a run on the first chorus. Despite that, it doesn't throw him off too badly. I thought the band drowned him out too much, particularly when Kris was attempting to hit those higher notes and this might have been nicer if it had a more acoustic sound to it. I didn't really pick up on the one bad note that Paula mentioned. Overall, I thought it was a decent performance from Kris.
Adam Lambert - "One" : You know, I was actually digging Simon's song choice for Adam when I first heard the news. But after the performance, it kind of landed a bit flat for me. Maybe "Wicked Games" would've been better - I dunno. I really liked the set-up for Adam in the beginning; him at the center of the stage with the blue mood lighting. Kind of reminded me of his "Mad World" performance. Manic Adam is in full effect a lot sooner than I was expecting. I don't know if I am enjoying the wicked-high vocals and shoutiness for this particular song. For me, I like it as more of that ballad sound. Adam is turning it more rock-ish towards the end. I've got nothing bad to say about his vocals because for what he did, they were spot on. But the song arrangement left me a tad bit disappointed. It might have worked better if he was toned-down throughout the entire song.
Danny Gokey - "You Are So Beautiful" : We're back for round two, where Danny makes his own song selection. He actually makes a pretty decent pick in "You Are So Beautiful" by Joe Cocker. The performance starts at first with no instruments, then an acoustic guitar, and gradually more instruments, but from the stage floor. I wouldn't say it was pitch perfect because I detected a few bum notes here and there. I am finding it to be a generally nice performance. Once again, is it something we're going to remember at the end of the day? Now the Danny we've all come to love - the shouty version! I am finding this much less enjoyable than the first part. I just prefer Danny when he's not trying to over-sing. I actually think he could've done more with the song than what he did. He made a few tweaks here and there and even injected some gospel into this classic song. But all in all, another average performance from Danny.
Kris Allen - "Heartless" : Well I'll be - Kris is actually getting some awesome lighting effects as he begins his performance. This is starting off really, really nice. It's just Kris and his guitar - the rest of the band is silent. The audience is just getting to focus on Kris and his guitar playing and it's pretty spectacular. I've got to admit, I wasn't sure if this song was going to work for Kris but he certainly made it his own and he put a completely different spin on the song and it's superb. It kind of reminds me of David Archuleta last year picking "With You" and while he made a great choice picking a contemporary song, I don't think it worked quite as well as he hoped. Now with Kris and this selection - it totally worked. The judges loved it, he was getting a great reaction from the audience, and this performance is one of many that we've come to love from Kris Allen. Best moment of the night right here with Kris' second song.
Adam Lambert - "Cryin' " : Ah, Adam tackling an Aerosmith song ... didn't somebody want Adam to perform an Aerosmith song? I'm thinking Melinda Doolittle - but she's obsessed with Aerosmith as a whole. Right from the get-go, his voice and one of the background singers is not meshing. I think that background singer is REALLY pitchy. But Adam Lambert is a pro - it's not throwing him off in the least. This is another strong rock-style vocal from Adam. I am actually liking this much more than his first performance and I agree with Randy that this is more of what works the best for Adam. What more can you say? This is Adam at his best being a rock star. It's a high energy performance; showing off his killer vocal skills. He truly nailed this song and he displayed great vocal control. American Idol has born it's newest star in Adam Lambert.
Hmm, my spell check isn't working! So if you notice any misspellings, blame blogger, not me. Anyways, here is how I rank tonight's performances:
ROUND #1:
Adam Lambert - best
Kris Allen
Danny Gokey - worst (actual eliminee - 5/13/09)
ROUND #2:
Kris Allen - best
Adam Lambert
Danny Gokey - worst (actual eliminee - 5/13/09)
This is going to be an absolutely tough choice in deciding who gets sent home. I've become a big Kris fan, so I'd like to see him stay. I've enjoyed Adam for most of the top 13. And Danny has fallen out of favor for me. Based on tonight's performances, I've got to say that Danny should be going home. But I've got to take into account his massive fan base. Meanwhile, Kris is a regular, everyday, humble guy and his fan base has been growing. Adam is popular because he's flashy, theatrics, and has amazing vocals. I mean honestly, it's truly a toss-up. With that being said, here is goes. Adam is safe - and in a shocker, Danny goes home and Kris makes it to the finale. That's right, I said it! Let's see if it all comes true tomorrow night. I have a feeling tomorrow's results show is going to be extremely tense. Be sure to enjoy it!
YIPEE!! Danny Gokey gets the boot on tonight's results show! So that means our finale will consist of Adam Lambert and Kris Allen. What a great pairing! I love it ... it will be awesome.
Tuesday, May 13, 2008
American Idol 7 - Top 3
Can you believe it; next week is the finale all ready?! Honestly, where has the first half of the year gone? It's amazing how quickly things have progressed but we are now down to the final three of American Idol! And I must say, all three contestants are definitely qualified to be there. It also doesn't hurt to have huge fan bases like the two David's have. Not only do the contestants have three songs to sing tonight, but they also get to choose a song of their own. In addition, the judges will be picking songs for each of the contestants and the producer's also have a say in song selection tonight. So this could prove to be a very interesting night for each of the three finalists. Song selection could make it or break it for them tonight. Wouldn't it be great to see all three contestants nail all of their songs? That way, the voting would be so unpredictable and wide open! It'd be fabulous. I don't forsee that happening, however. Let's get this party started!
David Archuleta - singing "And so it Goes" by Billy Joel: So Paula gets to choose for David. Did you know that whenever Paula picks the song for one of the three finalists, those contestants have never gone on to become the eventual American Idol? Let's hope David is able to break this curse! I really liked how this started off acapella. I agree with Randy; maybe he could've played a bit of this on the piano. Still, this is an enjoyable performance by Archie. He seems very much in the moment and really connecting with the song. He's able to have a connection with a song everytime he's up on stage and he makes it believable. Randy is right in that David is really in the zone and is in it to win it. I tend to agree with Simon in that it was good but nothing exceptional. He has two more songs in which he can really wow the crowd.
Syesha Mercado - singing "If I Ain't Got You" by Alisha Keys: Randy picks a song that Alicia Keys had a hit with and the good news is that it's contemporary! Nice pick by Randy. She's singing the song quite well. The song starts off pretty low key and Syesha is singing it how it's supposed to sound. Definitely not doing anything different to make it her own, but that's okay. It was a good performance from her but I wasn't blown away by it. I do think she has really embraced the competition for what it is and we're seeing her more comfortable and in the moment when she's up on stage. She is looking the part of a star and looks very elegant everytime she sings. I do wish she could've changed up the song some and made it her own. She could've even done a few runs to make it different. Still, it was a nice performance from Syesha.
David Cook - singing "The First Time Ever I Saw Your Face" by Raberta Flack: So Simon has the honors of picking the song for Cookie. An interesting choice, to say the least. Simon really tries to challenge a contestant whenever he's picking a song for them, and he definitely challenged David on this one. It's a very soft and low key song for him, definitely something we've rarely seen from him. Other than "Music of the Night," we haven't seen David tackle a ballad before. Usually they start off slow, like a ballad, but then they tend to pick up. Not necessarily so with this song. The tempo is gradually picking up and it sounds to me he's making it his own, although I am not really familiar with the original version. I actually liked seeing this side of Cookie and the last note really made this a good performance for him.
David Archuleta - singing "With You" by Chris Brown: Now who saw this coming? David chooses the most contemporary song of them all by picking an R n B song that talks about "boos" and a variety of other current R n B phrases (I can't remember all of the lyrics in the song at the moment). He takes a risk with this song and he seems pretty familiar with it. Otherwise, why would he have chosen it? He must like it enough. Looks like he briefly had trouble with the lyrics momentarily but made a nice recovery. It didn't appear that he forgot anything but he may have lost the tempo for a bit. Definitely seeing a different side of David here although I don't know if it truly works for him. The fans always crave for an uptempo song, but I don't know if this is the right one for him. Again, a good performance but not great. I am getting a bit concerned for David because Randy didn't gush about him being able to sing anything like usual. David needs to be on his "A" game for the next song.
Syesha Mercado - singing "Fever" by Peggy Lee: Syesha is looking particularly sexy with a short dress and is throwing in her sassy attitude into this performance. I must say, this is an interesting song choice for Syesha. I thought she'd want to do something more contemporary. I enjoy it when she's moving around on the stage and showing off her "broadway" personality, if you will. First she's sitting on a chair, then starts moving around and dances around Ricky. Then she goes back to the chair and leans/walks around it. She appears to be really in the element with this song and she sounds strong. Not a lot of high notes for Syesha to show off her incredible power and I didn't think she did anything very different with it. Nevertheless, it was still a nice performance from her.
David Cook - singing "Dare You To Move" by Switchfoot: Nothing against Simon, but these kind of songs do tend to suit David more (not to say I didn't like Cookie's first song - but it did seem awkward). I love hearing a contemporary song from him. An earlier song spoiler had him singing "The World I Know" by Collective Soul which would've been an absolute killer song for him to tackle. Personally, that song is one of my favorites. "Dare You To Move" is a good one, too, but not as great as the original spoiler stated. It ends up being a great personal song choice for him and out of the three contestants, Cookie picks the best of them all. I did notice a few pitchy notes, particularly in the beginning of the song. Arrangement-wise, it did seem rather short and he may not have incorporated enough of the middle-portion of the song into it. Otherwise, still well done for David.
David Archuleta - singing "Longer" by Dan Fogelberg: Clues have been out for awhile regarding this song chosen by producers. Even though it wasn't figured out right away by the fans, they eventually got it. This song does suit Archie's style and it's the perfect range for him. He's sitting down and does his usual thing with a classic ballad. This is the kind of performance we're used to seeing from David. He's definitely hitting this one out of the ballpark and vocally it sounds spot-on. Yeah, I guess it is a sappy kind of song lyrically, but David did a lights-out job with it. It's not his fault the producers chose it for him. Simon doesn't seem impressed by David tonight. Basically what I'm getting from him is that he did good, but not great. I hope that's not a bad omen for tomorrow.
Syesha Mercado - singing "Hit Me Up" by Gia Farrell: This is sounding like a fun little ditty for Syesha to sing. It's a very upbeat and fun song and it appears she is having a fun time with it on stage. She is still well-dressed but not donning a dress this time. I am not all that familiar with the song and the "Happy Feet" penguin movie is being referenced throughout the judge's comments, but it appeared to me like she didn't do enough with the song. It ends on kind of a bland note for me. It has definitely left me with a sour taste in my mouth. A very pleasant, rather cutesy song song but maybe not suited for Syesha's style. She does better with the more power-ballads and this song choice did not show off her vocal power. I bet secretly to herself, she absolutely hated having to sing this.
David Cook - singing "I Don't Want to Miss a Thing" by Aerosmith: Didn't we see an Aerosmith song done by Michael Johns during the week he was eliminated? I wonder if this is going to be a new curse for American Idol - those who perform Aerosmith get eliminated next night. Nah, that's pretty doubtful. I really didn't care for the orchestra sound to start the song. It seemed especially tacky for this kind of song. He's doing his usual thing with this song; an exceptional rock sound, great vocals, and ending the night on a good note. This song proves to be a good fit for David and he knocks it out of the ballpark. For me personally, this was Cookie's best performance of the night and the best out of all three contestants. He was really on his game for this one.
So after tonight's performances, I am feeling a bit disappointed overall. I'd rate this one a 7.5 out of ten. I don't think everyone was on their game tonight and with the added pressure of performing three songs, I don't believe the contestants were completely focused as they could've been. Also, the contestants experienced an ultimate high of going home and getting a star-like homecoming which probably threw them off, as it was tough getting back into the competition mode again. That being said, I don't think anyone was truly terrible. Heck, they didn't make it this far to be bad. I think David Cook is a definite lock to be in the finale. I am a bit concerned about David Archuleta after his second song which didn't receive the usual props from Randy. However, the judge's were probably the most negative for Syesha and they basically dubbed her as being forgettable. So with that being said, I have a feeling Syesha maybe going home tomorrow. But didn't we say that a lot throughout our journey through the top 12? Anyways, here is tonight's performance rankings:
#1: David Cook - best of the night
#2: David Archuleta
#3: Syesha Mercado - eliminated (eliminated - 5/14/08)
So there you have it; I believe Syesha will be going home after tomorrow. She has really peaked at the end of this competition and she's really grown into an ultimate performer. However, I believe the time has come for her to exit stage left. It's time to make room for the David vs. David that a lot of American Idol fans and producers have wanted for some time. But I will say this, don't be surprised if there's a shock elimination tomorrow night. Remember last week when Ryan said only a million votes separated the three contestants? If it was that close last week, who's to say it can't be that close this week, too. Remember to look for the elimination update to be provided sometime Thursday (that's when I'm available to do it). Until then, see you next week!
David Archuleta - singing "And so it Goes" by Billy Joel: So Paula gets to choose for David. Did you know that whenever Paula picks the song for one of the three finalists, those contestants have never gone on to become the eventual American Idol? Let's hope David is able to break this curse! I really liked how this started off acapella. I agree with Randy; maybe he could've played a bit of this on the piano. Still, this is an enjoyable performance by Archie. He seems very much in the moment and really connecting with the song. He's able to have a connection with a song everytime he's up on stage and he makes it believable. Randy is right in that David is really in the zone and is in it to win it. I tend to agree with Simon in that it was good but nothing exceptional. He has two more songs in which he can really wow the crowd.
Syesha Mercado - singing "If I Ain't Got You" by Alisha Keys: Randy picks a song that Alicia Keys had a hit with and the good news is that it's contemporary! Nice pick by Randy. She's singing the song quite well. The song starts off pretty low key and Syesha is singing it how it's supposed to sound. Definitely not doing anything different to make it her own, but that's okay. It was a good performance from her but I wasn't blown away by it. I do think she has really embraced the competition for what it is and we're seeing her more comfortable and in the moment when she's up on stage. She is looking the part of a star and looks very elegant everytime she sings. I do wish she could've changed up the song some and made it her own. She could've even done a few runs to make it different. Still, it was a nice performance from Syesha.
David Cook - singing "The First Time Ever I Saw Your Face" by Raberta Flack: So Simon has the honors of picking the song for Cookie. An interesting choice, to say the least. Simon really tries to challenge a contestant whenever he's picking a song for them, and he definitely challenged David on this one. It's a very soft and low key song for him, definitely something we've rarely seen from him. Other than "Music of the Night," we haven't seen David tackle a ballad before. Usually they start off slow, like a ballad, but then they tend to pick up. Not necessarily so with this song. The tempo is gradually picking up and it sounds to me he's making it his own, although I am not really familiar with the original version. I actually liked seeing this side of Cookie and the last note really made this a good performance for him.
David Archuleta - singing "With You" by Chris Brown: Now who saw this coming? David chooses the most contemporary song of them all by picking an R n B song that talks about "boos" and a variety of other current R n B phrases (I can't remember all of the lyrics in the song at the moment). He takes a risk with this song and he seems pretty familiar with it. Otherwise, why would he have chosen it? He must like it enough. Looks like he briefly had trouble with the lyrics momentarily but made a nice recovery. It didn't appear that he forgot anything but he may have lost the tempo for a bit. Definitely seeing a different side of David here although I don't know if it truly works for him. The fans always crave for an uptempo song, but I don't know if this is the right one for him. Again, a good performance but not great. I am getting a bit concerned for David because Randy didn't gush about him being able to sing anything like usual. David needs to be on his "A" game for the next song.
Syesha Mercado - singing "Fever" by Peggy Lee: Syesha is looking particularly sexy with a short dress and is throwing in her sassy attitude into this performance. I must say, this is an interesting song choice for Syesha. I thought she'd want to do something more contemporary. I enjoy it when she's moving around on the stage and showing off her "broadway" personality, if you will. First she's sitting on a chair, then starts moving around and dances around Ricky. Then she goes back to the chair and leans/walks around it. She appears to be really in the element with this song and she sounds strong. Not a lot of high notes for Syesha to show off her incredible power and I didn't think she did anything very different with it. Nevertheless, it was still a nice performance from her.
David Cook - singing "Dare You To Move" by Switchfoot: Nothing against Simon, but these kind of songs do tend to suit David more (not to say I didn't like Cookie's first song - but it did seem awkward). I love hearing a contemporary song from him. An earlier song spoiler had him singing "The World I Know" by Collective Soul which would've been an absolute killer song for him to tackle. Personally, that song is one of my favorites. "Dare You To Move" is a good one, too, but not as great as the original spoiler stated. It ends up being a great personal song choice for him and out of the three contestants, Cookie picks the best of them all. I did notice a few pitchy notes, particularly in the beginning of the song. Arrangement-wise, it did seem rather short and he may not have incorporated enough of the middle-portion of the song into it. Otherwise, still well done for David.
David Archuleta - singing "Longer" by Dan Fogelberg: Clues have been out for awhile regarding this song chosen by producers. Even though it wasn't figured out right away by the fans, they eventually got it. This song does suit Archie's style and it's the perfect range for him. He's sitting down and does his usual thing with a classic ballad. This is the kind of performance we're used to seeing from David. He's definitely hitting this one out of the ballpark and vocally it sounds spot-on. Yeah, I guess it is a sappy kind of song lyrically, but David did a lights-out job with it. It's not his fault the producers chose it for him. Simon doesn't seem impressed by David tonight. Basically what I'm getting from him is that he did good, but not great. I hope that's not a bad omen for tomorrow.
Syesha Mercado - singing "Hit Me Up" by Gia Farrell: This is sounding like a fun little ditty for Syesha to sing. It's a very upbeat and fun song and it appears she is having a fun time with it on stage. She is still well-dressed but not donning a dress this time. I am not all that familiar with the song and the "Happy Feet" penguin movie is being referenced throughout the judge's comments, but it appeared to me like she didn't do enough with the song. It ends on kind of a bland note for me. It has definitely left me with a sour taste in my mouth. A very pleasant, rather cutesy song song but maybe not suited for Syesha's style. She does better with the more power-ballads and this song choice did not show off her vocal power. I bet secretly to herself, she absolutely hated having to sing this.
David Cook - singing "I Don't Want to Miss a Thing" by Aerosmith: Didn't we see an Aerosmith song done by Michael Johns during the week he was eliminated? I wonder if this is going to be a new curse for American Idol - those who perform Aerosmith get eliminated next night. Nah, that's pretty doubtful. I really didn't care for the orchestra sound to start the song. It seemed especially tacky for this kind of song. He's doing his usual thing with this song; an exceptional rock sound, great vocals, and ending the night on a good note. This song proves to be a good fit for David and he knocks it out of the ballpark. For me personally, this was Cookie's best performance of the night and the best out of all three contestants. He was really on his game for this one.
So after tonight's performances, I am feeling a bit disappointed overall. I'd rate this one a 7.5 out of ten. I don't think everyone was on their game tonight and with the added pressure of performing three songs, I don't believe the contestants were completely focused as they could've been. Also, the contestants experienced an ultimate high of going home and getting a star-like homecoming which probably threw them off, as it was tough getting back into the competition mode again. That being said, I don't think anyone was truly terrible. Heck, they didn't make it this far to be bad. I think David Cook is a definite lock to be in the finale. I am a bit concerned about David Archuleta after his second song which didn't receive the usual props from Randy. However, the judge's were probably the most negative for Syesha and they basically dubbed her as being forgettable. So with that being said, I have a feeling Syesha maybe going home tomorrow. But didn't we say that a lot throughout our journey through the top 12? Anyways, here is tonight's performance rankings:
#1: David Cook - best of the night
#2: David Archuleta
#3: Syesha Mercado - eliminated (eliminated - 5/14/08)
So there you have it; I believe Syesha will be going home after tomorrow. She has really peaked at the end of this competition and she's really grown into an ultimate performer. However, I believe the time has come for her to exit stage left. It's time to make room for the David vs. David that a lot of American Idol fans and producers have wanted for some time. But I will say this, don't be surprised if there's a shock elimination tomorrow night. Remember last week when Ryan said only a million votes separated the three contestants? If it was that close last week, who's to say it can't be that close this week, too. Remember to look for the elimination update to be provided sometime Thursday (that's when I'm available to do it). Until then, see you next week!
Labels:
american idol,
David Archuleta,
David Cook,
season seven,
Syesha Mercado,
top 3
Wednesday, May 16, 2007
American Idol Top 3
Well, it must be getting near the end of the season for American Idol when I start slacking off on my recaps. We are about an hour away from the start of the elimination show tonight and next week is the huge finale. I'm running into some motivation problems in completing tonight's blog (I run into this problem from time to time), so it if ends up being shorter than my usual recaps, blame it on that. This week, the contestants had three songs to sing. One was chosen by one of the judges, another was chosen by the producers of American Idol, and the last was chosen by the contestant themselves. Here's the recap from the top 3...
I completely forgot about American Idol and totally missed Jordin's first performance. By the time I turned it on, Ryan was telling Jordin that she would be back in just a short amount of time singing her next song. Drat. It was a song that Simon chose Jordin to sing, and from what I understood, Jordin did a good job with the song but did not blow anyone away by it. Pretty consistent for Jordin the past few weeks, I must say. So, we'll move onto Blake going next.
Paula chose the song "Roxanne" originally covered by The Police for Blake. I didn't really understand Paula for choosing this song for Blake - but he handled it pretty well. I must say, though, that he did sound awkward singing it at times, as if he was singing it with an accent like Sting has. Overall, I thought Blake performed it quite solidly and stayed away from the beat boxing which was a good decision on his part.
Randy had the pleasure of picking a Whitney Houston song for Melinda, "I Believe in You and Me." Randy always chides a contestant for picking Whitney songs, especially if they don't sing them very well. He wanted to throw out a difficult song for Melinda to sing, and it doesn't get very easy singing a Whitney song. I wasn't blown away by it, but it was another near-flawless performance from Melinda. I think she had a few pitch problems, especially in the beginning, and the song wasn't exactly upbeat for me. But, Melinda still did well with it.
Now I get to see Jordin perform for the first time tonight. It's time for the producers to choose songs for the contestants (where is Clive Davis, anyways?), and I think they chose a real odd-ball for Jordin to sing. It's the Donna Summer classic, "She Works Hard for her Money." It's actually a great, upbeat song for her and I think she does a good job with it. I enjoy listening to her sing it and these kind of songs do well for her.
The producers picked an absolute perfect song for Blake, as he sang Maroon 5's "This Love." Maroon 5 is one of my favorite bands so of course I'm gonna love this. I thought it was a very fun song and it's also very recognizable; something that has been released within the past five years. Blake does well when he stays current, so the producers didn't hurt Blake here. And the little bit of beat boxing that he did worked very well.
Throughout the competition, Melinda has sung songs that made her sound like Tina Turner - at least that is what the judges have commented from time to time. One such example was when Melinda sang Bon Jovi's "Have a Nice Day." So the producers followed up on that when they selected an Ike and Tina Turner Song, "Nutbush City Limits." Nutbush? Okay, I have never heard of this song myself and it seems like another goofy choice. Certainly there's a lot better Tina Turner songs they could've picked. It's a very upbeat, rock 'n roll kind of song and I enjoy it when Melinda rocks out. I don't necessarily believe the producers did any favors to Melinda when they chose this song for her, but she did not flail and it ended up being a good performance.
Now it's time for the contestants to pick their own songs and Jordin sang "I Who Have Nothing." I wasn't sure if I had heard this song by Jordin before (how quickly I forget), but then I did some research and sure enough, she sung it during the British Invasion week. An interesting choice, considering she had a couple other songs that she blew wide open throughout the competition, but this wasn't bad. She sang it exceptionally well and included a lot of power and emotion to her voice. It was nicely controlled and who cares if it's an old song, as Simon pointed out. You've gotta have some variety.
Blake chooses a Robin Thicke song, "When I Get You Alone." Blake stays contemporary going with a current song and that doesn't hurt him the least bit. It will definitely attract the younger voters. Personally, I didn't know the song, so I cannot compare it to the original, but I thought he did a fine job with it. Once again, he used the beat boxing in limited fashion which was perfectly executed. Last week I think he went a bit overboard with it and he learned a lesson. Blake did a nice job this week.
Finally, Melinda wraps things up doing the same as Jordin did, choosing a song she had success with earlier in the competition, "Woman." The first time she performed this, I was blown away by it; it was that good. This time around, even though it was on a larger stage, I just didn't like it as much. Yes, it was still good and consistent like Melinda has been throughout the competition, but it didn't live up to her earlier rendition.
And now the all important pick as to who goes home this week. I think this season is about as wide open as ever as to who will end up being in the final three. I think Melinda is a definite shoo-in for the finale, and Jordin will also make her way through to next week. That means Blake ends up being the odd man out. I really like Blake and I hate to see him go, but at this stage of the competition, there are a lot of good performers. I think the two ladies are just a small notch ahead of him.
Soon enough, we will know for sure who the final two will be. Enjoy the results show!
I completely forgot about American Idol and totally missed Jordin's first performance. By the time I turned it on, Ryan was telling Jordin that she would be back in just a short amount of time singing her next song. Drat. It was a song that Simon chose Jordin to sing, and from what I understood, Jordin did a good job with the song but did not blow anyone away by it. Pretty consistent for Jordin the past few weeks, I must say. So, we'll move onto Blake going next.
Paula chose the song "Roxanne" originally covered by The Police for Blake. I didn't really understand Paula for choosing this song for Blake - but he handled it pretty well. I must say, though, that he did sound awkward singing it at times, as if he was singing it with an accent like Sting has. Overall, I thought Blake performed it quite solidly and stayed away from the beat boxing which was a good decision on his part.
Randy had the pleasure of picking a Whitney Houston song for Melinda, "I Believe in You and Me." Randy always chides a contestant for picking Whitney songs, especially if they don't sing them very well. He wanted to throw out a difficult song for Melinda to sing, and it doesn't get very easy singing a Whitney song. I wasn't blown away by it, but it was another near-flawless performance from Melinda. I think she had a few pitch problems, especially in the beginning, and the song wasn't exactly upbeat for me. But, Melinda still did well with it.
Now I get to see Jordin perform for the first time tonight. It's time for the producers to choose songs for the contestants (where is Clive Davis, anyways?), and I think they chose a real odd-ball for Jordin to sing. It's the Donna Summer classic, "She Works Hard for her Money." It's actually a great, upbeat song for her and I think she does a good job with it. I enjoy listening to her sing it and these kind of songs do well for her.
The producers picked an absolute perfect song for Blake, as he sang Maroon 5's "This Love." Maroon 5 is one of my favorite bands so of course I'm gonna love this. I thought it was a very fun song and it's also very recognizable; something that has been released within the past five years. Blake does well when he stays current, so the producers didn't hurt Blake here. And the little bit of beat boxing that he did worked very well.
Throughout the competition, Melinda has sung songs that made her sound like Tina Turner - at least that is what the judges have commented from time to time. One such example was when Melinda sang Bon Jovi's "Have a Nice Day." So the producers followed up on that when they selected an Ike and Tina Turner Song, "Nutbush City Limits." Nutbush? Okay, I have never heard of this song myself and it seems like another goofy choice. Certainly there's a lot better Tina Turner songs they could've picked. It's a very upbeat, rock 'n roll kind of song and I enjoy it when Melinda rocks out. I don't necessarily believe the producers did any favors to Melinda when they chose this song for her, but she did not flail and it ended up being a good performance.
Now it's time for the contestants to pick their own songs and Jordin sang "I Who Have Nothing." I wasn't sure if I had heard this song by Jordin before (how quickly I forget), but then I did some research and sure enough, she sung it during the British Invasion week. An interesting choice, considering she had a couple other songs that she blew wide open throughout the competition, but this wasn't bad. She sang it exceptionally well and included a lot of power and emotion to her voice. It was nicely controlled and who cares if it's an old song, as Simon pointed out. You've gotta have some variety.
Blake chooses a Robin Thicke song, "When I Get You Alone." Blake stays contemporary going with a current song and that doesn't hurt him the least bit. It will definitely attract the younger voters. Personally, I didn't know the song, so I cannot compare it to the original, but I thought he did a fine job with it. Once again, he used the beat boxing in limited fashion which was perfectly executed. Last week I think he went a bit overboard with it and he learned a lesson. Blake did a nice job this week.
Finally, Melinda wraps things up doing the same as Jordin did, choosing a song she had success with earlier in the competition, "Woman." The first time she performed this, I was blown away by it; it was that good. This time around, even though it was on a larger stage, I just didn't like it as much. Yes, it was still good and consistent like Melinda has been throughout the competition, but it didn't live up to her earlier rendition.
And now the all important pick as to who goes home this week. I think this season is about as wide open as ever as to who will end up being in the final three. I think Melinda is a definite shoo-in for the finale, and Jordin will also make her way through to next week. That means Blake ends up being the odd man out. I really like Blake and I hate to see him go, but at this stage of the competition, there are a lot of good performers. I think the two ladies are just a small notch ahead of him.
Soon enough, we will know for sure who the final two will be. Enjoy the results show!
Labels:
american idol,
blake lewis,
jordin sparks,
melinda doolittle,
season 6,
top 3
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)