Showing posts with label Crystal Bowersox. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Crystal Bowersox. Show all posts

Wednesday, June 02, 2010

American Idol 9 - Season Wrap-Up

It's Television Wednesday here on "Luke's Ponderings", which gives me the opportunity to look back on the American Idol season that just wrapped up last week. All in all, I wouldn't say it was a terrible season. Surely it never lived up to seasons seven or eight, which I think were two of the best in the series. I think early on, when the top 12 was announced, it was easy to see Crystal advancing to the final two. I think it was still up in the air whether or not Lee had a chance to make it to the finale, but he was starting to become more comfortable with performing live on television and on stage. Honestly, at that point in the competition, I thought Siobhan and Crystal would end up being the final two contestants standing. That's what I was hoping for, but Siobhan kind of fizzled until ultimately getting voted out at sixth place. Lee does make for a strong winner of American Idol, but is he, or will he live up to the legacy that Kelly Clarkson, Carrie Underwood, or even David Cook have left since being crowned winners of the show? That remains to be seen.

As we all know going into this season and watching during the finale, this was Simon Cowell's final year as judge on the show. You really can make the case that Simon was the show. But I really enjoyed his final comments last Wednesday when he said that the real judges of the show are those watching at home. The contestants and to a point, Ryan Seacrest are the show. The judges are replaceable. Even though we all hate to see Simon leave, it presents the opportunity for the show to bring aboard someone else with musical knowledge to critique the contestants and give constructive criticism. Sorry to all of the Ellen fans out there, but she has not lived up to her potential. Week in and week out, I heard her utter phrases such as "you're so good," and "that was great" to many of the contestants. You've got to say more than that. I really hope she brings her "A" game next season (reports say she will be back for season 10 as per the contract she signed prior to this past season). Brett Michaels has been rumored to be a potential candidate to replace Simon, which really intrigues me. He's been a judge on a TV singing contest before (anyone remember "Nashville Star"), he's experienced music success with his band Poison and other solo endeavors, and his recent health troubles make him an endearing figure and people will be willing to root for the guy. Plus, I have a feeling he won't be afraid to tell a contestant that their singing needs work when he needs to. That's not to say there aren't other people who can replace Simon's seat on the panel - it's just that Brett's name is one of the first rumored potential successors. And let's be frank, no one will ever be able to replace Simon on that show. He is one of a kind and it'll be interesting to see exactly how Idol adjusts in the new era, the Simon-less era.

I think the show is definitely in need of a major shake-up, and I'm not talking about new judges or new gimmicks - like the judge's save. Let's bring in some better themes instead of these recycles theme weeks we keep seeing season after season. I like one Idol expert's idea of having a contestant's originals week - in which a contestant would perform a song they wrote on their own. Or let the show feature more contemporary music from the past two decades. I think most Idol fans are getting tired of hearing the same songs performed season after season. The episodes also need to be cut down and condensed, which they are proposing for next season. Less filler during results night would be nice and please, less babble from the judges! Last but not least, let the show be more about the contestants. I think the producers are always trying to promise this but never prevail. How about additional behind the scenes footage when the contestants have some off time? I feel that during this season particularly, we just weren't able to connect to the contestants like I had hoped and often felt bored by them. And from their post-Idol interviews, they've been nothing but enjoyable to listen to.

All in all, I thoroughly enjoyed the two-hour finale last Wednesday. Usually there are some surprises involved, and the finale certainly did not disappoint. Seeing Brett Michaels on stage singing with Casey James, so soon after getting out of the hospital, was pretty incredible. I've been a big fan of the Bee Gees for awhile, so it was nice to see the last two brothers reunite on stage again, performing with Siobhan and Aaron. Such great singing between the four of them! Alanis Morisette was amazing with Crystal and was another highlight of the evening. And what more can you say about Joe Cocker performing his classic tune with the two finalists? What a special moment. That's not to say the night didn't have a few duds, including the "Pants on the Ground" rendition and seeing some of the Idol rejects (along with Dane Cook) return to the stage. But all in all, it was a great night which in turn lead to the crowning of the new American Idol.

So that wraps-up my thoughts on the season that was. I wouldn't say it was the worst, nor was it the best. Kind of somewhere in the middle. And I look back at those surprising eliminations we had during the semi-finals, when Kately Epperly, Lilly Scott, and Alex Lambert were sent home. What might've happened if those contestants stayed on a little longer and attracted more attention from the voting audience? I think the season could've ended up a lot different than it did and Lee may have ended up taking fourth or fifth place. Ah well, it's easy to speculate and to wonder what might've been. This is the hand that we've been dealt and Lee is a decent recording artist. His live performances certainly need work, but not everybody does well singing live. I guess time will tell whether or not America made the right decision. In time, we'll certainly find out.

Wednesday, May 26, 2010

American Idol 9 - Top 2

I don't have a lot of time to write today, so I will give brief comments on the performances from last night and make the all important prediction on who will win season nine of American Idol. For me and a lot of America, I felt Crystal performed the best. She picked the better of the two contestants' choice songs in "Me and Bobby McGee," which she absolutely nailed the first time out and did another masterful job with again. I guess I'm not all that thrilled when the contestants have to perform a song they've already done earlier in the season because you're not getting that same "moment" you first did, no matter how great the performance was. Nonetheless, Crystal's choice was much more energetic, fun, and it was right in her wheelhouse. Don't get me wrong, I love "The Boxer," but I felt Lee could've picked something a bit more upbeat for such an important night. He's had good performances recently and the momentum going his way, I'm sure he could've reprized something from then with a little more flair.

As for the producer's choice songs, I actually liked Lee's song better than Crystal's. Lee was pitchy in spots - I think he was quite nervous for being in such a huge venue. And I was a bit worried for him when the song started because the judges were harping on him for his first song choice and "Everybody Hurts" started out similar (even though he didn't pick this one). However, the tempo picked up and he used his rock growl to really make it great to listen to. As for Crystal and "Black Velvet," I'm just not a fan of that song. She did pretty decent with it and made a few changes to make it her own. But she struggled hitting the high notes and sounded strained at times. I think the moving around on the stage threw her off a bit. However, it wasn't her worst performance.

And last but not least, the winner's song which in the past was an original composition about magic rainbows or moving mountains, etc, etc. I actually miss the trainwreck that were those kinds of songs. Anyways, Crystal picked the far superior cover song. Does it sound good on today's contemporary radio? Probably not. But she was really in the moment with that song. I thought she was about to get emotional towards the end but remained strong. She was absolutely superb and last night was definitely for her. As for Lee, I felt the song was too big for him. It just didn't seem to fit his style and the music tended to drown him out. At least when he records songs in the studio, he sounds great no matter what the song. And if he wins, I think he'll sound great with this song.

MY PREDICTION: Now, who should win this season of American Idol? Crystal Bowersox should. She's been the most consistent performer on this competition since day one. And she performed the best last night. She's got a unique style and performs in a way that you don't really see in today's contemporary world. However, I don't feel she connects with America enough, particularly with the younger generation. So, with that being said ... who will win this season of American Idol? Lee Dewyze. He's improved week after week since the beginning and has gained incredible momentum to grasp the title. He still goes off pitch from time to time, but I think he will continue to become more and more comfortable singing in front of large audiences - the summer tour will do him well. And Lee is a genuinely nice guy who seems humbled by the whole American Idol experience. That, and he's got a huge fan base who I'm sure voted like crazy last night. Even though I would've like to seen a woman win this year in this heavily touted "the season of the women," and we're getting another guitar playing male for a winner, I think Lee is going to make a fine American Idol and he fits more into today's contemporary mold.

So that's it, American Idol is officially over for the season! Simon Cowell leaves after tonight and who knows who'll be judging next year. There's a rumor that the whole panel might be overhauled. I am hoping to write a recap of the finale in a few days after everything has sunk in, so be sure to check for that. Enjoy tonight's two-hour finale if you can!

Wednesday, May 19, 2010

American Idol 9 - Top 3

Here we are again with another American Idol recap. It's really getting down to the wire now, with only three contestants left! I'm always amazed when we get to this point in the season because it always seems to go by so quick. And this year is no exception. Man, what are us Idol fanatics going to do once the show ends next week? Ah well, it's like this every year. At least the weather is nice enough outside now that we'll be able to spend it out there more than watching TV in the summer. At least that's my plans. Anyways, regarding last night's Idol performance episode. I think we all know how big of a disappointment season nine has been overall. Don't really need to emphasize it anymore than it already has been. So heading into Top 3 night, I wasn't all that enthusiastic about the night - not like in prior seasons. I think it's been pretty clear for awhile that we'll end up with a Crystal and Lee finale. The only way Casey has a slim chance is if the other two completely flounder with their songs and Casey absolutely nails his songs. Let's find out exactly what happened last night ...

CONTESTANTS' SONG CHOICES:

Casey James - "Okay It's Alright With Me" by Eric Hutchinson : Interesting song choice from Casey because it's pretty obscure and relatively unknown. This could either work in his favor or completely bomb. Did you notice he almost had a near disastrous moment when he forgot his guitar pick in his pocket and had to quickly fish it out before the song took off on him? Nice save there. My initial reaction to his performance was that it was just okay. I was definitely not jumping up and down about it as I listened to it. I kind of compare it to Lite FM music - nothing big or fancy, but easy listening. The song certainly didn't have a lot of range to it and Casey did fine with it vocally. But as I said, it's not a big, dynamic song and at this stage of the game, it needed to be a better song choice.

Crystal Bowersox - "Come to My Window" by Melissa Etheridge : When I first heard that Crystal picked this song to perform last night, I thought this could really be huge for her. It's a great song and you'd think it would fit her perfectly. Well, it kind of fell flat for me. I honestly don't think she did enough with the song to make it her own. The song kind of started rather awkwardly (after the harmonica solo) when it almost seemed like she was whispering. I'd agree with the judges comments about the arrangement being off because it was. Not as great of an arrangement as it could've been. And she was really straining on those high notes in the song, especially during the chorus of the song. So for me, it wasn't as great of a performance from Crystal as I was expecting.

Lee Dewyze - "Simple Man" by Lynyrd Skynyrd : Now Lee picked the best song for himself out of all of the contestants on the night. It suited his style and you could tell he had a great time with it. I can't say I'm all that familiar with the original but it sounds as if Lee made it current and it could be a hit on today's radio. He is really beginning to own the stage now, as his confidence is there and he realizes he belongs there. I really think that visit home within the week did him some good. It goes to show what kind of impact he is having to those people watching at home. When you look back on the show in previous years and the kind of performances the contestants have at this stage of the game - this is the kind of performance Lee needed to have and he did exactly right by it.

JUDGES' SONG CHOICES:

Casey James - "Daughters" by John Mayer: Here we have the laugh-out-loud moment when Randy Jackson says "as Casey James leaves the show" when commenting why he and Kara chose the song for Casey. Nice, real nice Randy - as if Casey has no chance (well, he really doesn't). It was a real nice performance from Casey and it suited him quite well. He certainly didn't have a moment with it, as it's not one of those songs that'll wow a person. But he did a competent job with it, changed it up just enough to make it his own, and vocally it was quite good. I read or heard a comment during the week that Casey is probably the best guitarist that Idol has ever seen (contestant-wise) and we may not ever see someone that talented again, and that's true. He certainly knows how to wield out a guitar, that is for sure.

Crystal Bowersox - "Maybe I'm Amazed" by Paul McCartney : Coming into this performance from Crystal, I was wondering how'd she do with it and what she'd do to make it her own. She stepped out of her comfort zone a bit (even though we've seen her do that on occasion this season) by not playing her guitar and even performing from different spots on the Idol stage. I must say, this is the kind of performance that Crystal needed, especially on this night. I loved that she was able to show off the range in her voice. Wow, those high notes - who knew she could sing those? I really liked how she controlled the performance, from singing all out to dialing it back when it was appropriate. She is a true musician and is definitely deserving to be on that Idol stage next week in the finale.

Lee Dewyze - "Hallelujah" by Leonard Cohen : Oh my goodness, where do I begin. First off, the song choice by Simon. As we've seen earlier this season when Tim Urban performed it, it's one of those songs that can allow anyone to have a moment. As further proof, look at Jason Castro in season seven. It's got a great, haunting message to it and you can't go wrong with that. Secondly, the set-up by the Idol Powers-That-Be to bring in a choir and orchestra during the performance. An incredible effect but honestly, was it needed? Thirdly, Lee's vocal. It was awesome. He really excelled with the song and it suited him nicely. So taking that all into consideration, whether you want to call it over-pimping from the producers or what have you, I thought it was a nice moment for Lee. I actually got caught up into it all when I first watched it. But I can see why people would be turned off by all of the choreography going on within the performance. Lee's vocal shined on its own.

Top 3 Performance Rankings:
1.) Lee Dewyze
2.) Crystal Bowersox
3.) Casey James

Going Home: This really is a no-brainer this week, and after picking him to leave for awhile now, I honestly think I have a good shot at getting it right this week (whataya know!). Casey James' Idol journey ends tonight. Nice job on getting this far, Casey.

Tuesday, May 04, 2010

American Idol 9 - Top 5

Coming into tonight's episode, we have just a month left of this season and at the end of this journey, a new Idol will be crowned. I hate to be so negative, but I just have no enthusiasm for the finale this year. I don't know if it's because of the lackluster talent or the predictability of this season (not that I've been picking correctly in who goes home each week), but something is totally missing. I miss season seven and eight! Anyway, let's try and make the most of season nine and enjoy as much of it as we possibly can. This week the contestants perform songs from one of the legends himself, Frank Sinatra. And what a great mentor the contestants have this week in Harry Connick Jr. He's even helping to arrange the songs for them! What a cool guy. I hope this is a home run for all of the contestants this week.

Aaron Kelly - "Fly Me to the Moon" : Aaron has had his fair share of struggles as of late (however, last week was quite good for him, not surprisingly), and despite the criticism he gets from the judges, he's always positive and strives to improve. That's one thing you have to like about this high school student. As for tonight's performance, it was just okay for me. I wasn't jumping out of my seat because he didn't really do a whole lot vocally. I noticed a few pitchy notes and I thought the second half was better than the first. Sometimes when he stretches out a certain note, he goes off pitch. He has to continue working on his pitch problems, especially those in his upper register. He trended to strain a bit on some of those higher notes towards the end of the performance.

Casey James - "Blue Skies" : Casey has been molded into a decent lead singer in a cover band. However, there are times when he has shined on that big Idol stage - it seems to be during those performances where the tempo is softer and where he's able to show off his vocal talent. This week could work out very well for Casey if it's executed perfectly. However, it's executed horribly. It just goes extremely bad for Casey. He clearly shows that this is the wrong kind of music for him and he looks totally uncomfortable on stage. He tries moving to different points on stage but he looks so stiff. The singing is just way off; he's pitchy and his phrasing is horrible. Oh man, I had high hopes for Casey this week but it's just not working tonight. I'm afraid this may be the end for him.

Crystal Bowersox - "Summer Wind" : It'll be interesting to see how Crystal adapts to singing Sinatra songs tonight. What am I saying? She can sing anything! So far this season, she's stepped outside of her comfort level and have taken some pretty large risks, probably more so than any other contestant in season nine. So I am sure she can adapt quite well to performing a Sinatra song. And I must say she did a pretty good job tonight. I won't say it was her best and I am not completely comfortable hearing her perform these kinds of songs. However, she made it enjoyable to listen to and we got to see another side of the music machine that is Crystal Bowersox. I did think the beginning of the song was rather underwhelming compared to the last half of the song. Also, the band tended to drown out her singing towards the end. But vocally, it was quite good.

Michael Lynche - "The Way You Look Tonight" : Out of the five remaining contestants, I can definitely see Big Mike having the most success tonight. This is the type of music that he excels on. Maybe not so much the Sinatra-style of music, but more along the lines of a ballad. Those seem to be Mike's most memorable performances, when he's able to be vulnerable, emotional, and sing from the heart. And I must say, Mike was quite good tonight. Again, am I going to remember exactly what he sang tomorrow and how he sang it? Most likely, no. But so far tonight, he was far and away the best. Again, he sang the song with such emotion and you could feel his connection to the song. And yes, he still tends to be over dramatic on that stage, but that's just how he is. That's how he's able to remain comfortable on that stage and at least it's not completely awkward like Casey's stage presence.

Lee Dewyze - "That's Life" : First let me just say, nobody did "My Way" or "New York, New York"? That's rather surprising and a bit disappointing for me. Anyways, Lee is on tap with the pimp spot tonight. Let's see if he can close the show in a proper and memorable way. I've got to admit, I was a little worried with the way it started for me. I noticed a few off-pitch notes but Lee recovered quite nicely and made the song his own. Again, like a few of the other contestants, this is outside of Lee's comfort zone but he did a nice job of incorporating it into his style. Towards the end of the song he did get drowned out a bit by the band, but you could definitely tell it was Lee singing. He just continues to step it up week after week and after a couple of okay performances from Crystal the past two weeks, Lee is starting to inch his way ahead of her.

Top Five Performance Rankings:
1.) Lee Dewyze
2.) Michael Lynche
3.) Crystal Bowersox
4.) Aaron Kelly
5.) Casey James

Going Home: I think Casey's journey comes to an end after tomorrow. Last week he was in the bottom two, and that was after he delivered the best performance of that particular night! To me, that spells doom and gloom, especially after tonight's dismal performance. I think Aaron can be carried over one more week by the tween votes and Crystal is still a lock for the finale. As for Casey, I just think it's time.

Wednesday, April 21, 2010

American Idol 9 - Top 7

It's Idol Gives Back week and we're looking for inspirational performances from the remaining seven contestants. I think this is probably one of the more tricky weeks to pick a song, because you need one with a message and an individual needs to deliver it in an inspirational way. If one of them sings it in a typical fashion and they do not connect to the message within the song, the importance of the night can be lost. Tonight's mentor is Alicia Keys, who has done a large amount of charity work herself. Doesn't it seem like Idol is bringing more and more mentors back into the fold each and every week? I remember after season six, they felt there were too many mentors and it was taking away from the contestants themselves. Now it seems we're seeing more and more mentors again. Not that it matters, really. Because either a contestant sings well or they don't - regardless if there's a mentor there or not. Anyways, on with the recap!

Casey James - "Don't Stop" by Fleetwood Mac : Up first tonight is Casey James and he picks a classic Fleetwood Mac song. Hmm, "Don't Stop" as inspirational? Sure, it has potentially moving lyrics. But I don't think it quite fits the mold as an inspirational song. I am not in the least inspired by this performance. Honestly, what is Casey doing on that stage? It's the same performance style week after week and it's getting old. I think he needs to change things up - two weeks ago he performed "Jealous Guy" in such a passionate, soulful, and earnest way. We need to see something like that again and not the same rocking bar-scene performance. This week he could've had another performance like "Jealous Guy" and it would've fit the theme perfectly. Missed opportunity there.

Lee Dewyze - "The Boxer" by Simon and Garfunkel : Next up is Lee and he chooses an amazing song. I am a big fan of Simon and Garfunkel and "The Boxer" is one of my favorite songs of theirs (next to "Bridge Over Troubled Water"). I just hope Lee doesn't screw it up! And he doesn't and even gives the song a bit of a different sound to it - a more modern feel. He's clearly much more connected with his song than Casey was with his and this is what performing inspirational songs is all about. You pick a song with a great message, connect to the song, and make the audience feel that performance. I actually prefer Lee when he's not shouting so much and I can't wait to hear the longer rendition on his iTunes recording.

Tim Urban - "Better Days" by the Goo Goo Dolls : The ever-improving Tim Urban is up next (but will he ever be great?) with an inspirational song from the Goo Goo Dolls. I like the choice of song by Tim but the performance was not executed as well as it could've been. It starts off rather under whelming and he seems to struggle with the lower notes in his register. It gradually gets better but it's still lacking a spark. His phrasing is still not the greatest and he's still a pretty mediocre vocalist. I wasn't all that impressed with the arrangement of the song, either, as it was kind of all over the place. It was just okay for me and he didn't propel himself any higher than he already has this season.

Aaron Kelly - "I Believe I Can Fly" by R. Kelly : "High School student" Aaron Kelly is next with another head-scratcher of a song choice. I guess I am not a big fan of this song, particularly on the Idol stage. I know it's been song a few times previously on the show and nobody has really done well with it. Aaron follows that trend and it falls flat for me. Speaking of flat, there's definitely some pitchiness here and there. Honestly, I think it's just too big of a song for him. Yes, I applaud him for picking such a gigantic song but at this stage of the competition, effort isn't good enough. When he tries hitting some of those higher notes in the song, he struggles. Definitely not a stellar week from Aaron, again.

Siobhan Magnus - "When You Believe" by Whitney Houston & Mariah Carey : Siobhan was once considered a front runner in this competition and many were envisioning a Crystal-Siobhan finale in May, including myself. But Siobhan has been derailed a bit lately and I think the conflicting criticism from the judges may be to blame. This week, I thought her vocals were quite good. There were a couple of times where her voice didn't quite sound right to me - even a bit nasally. But this is probably the best she's sounded in a good three weeks. I do agree in a sense that her recent song choices have made her become more old fashioned and she may be embracing more of a broadway feel. I guess I would like to see her return to tackle a song like "Think" which she did quite well with earlier on.

Michael Lynche - "Hero" by Chad Kroeger featuring Joey Scott : I guess I don't understand why Michael needs to pick up practically ever celebrity mentor he meets when giving them a hug. Don't you think he needs to be more restrained and gentle? That's one of the gripes I have of Big Mike. As for his performance, it was good, but I wasn't jumping up and down over it, either. I wasn't a fan with the way it started when he gave it a more acoustic feel, and then I didn't care much for when the tempo picked up and it turned more rock-ish. I just don't feel it was the right song for Mike. It didn't fit his voice and I feel it was another missed opportunity for him.

Crystal Bowersox - "People Get Ready" by the Impressions : So Crystal is sans the guitar tonight (no instrument of any kind) and is stepping outside of her comfort zone. It worked for her a few weeks back (even with playing the piano) so why shouldn't it work this time around? I wouldn't say it was a perfect vocal for her but it was awfully close. Honestly, now this is an inspirational performance. What a way to end the night. Crystal gets all emotional when noticing her dad in the audience and it's truly a touching moment. I really think this has the potential to win over a lot of people about Crystal who may have been on the fence about her. I mean, what more can you say? She's already a consummate professional and she's the most deserving to go all the way.

Top 7 Performance Rankings:
1.) Crystal Bowersox
2.) Lee Dewyze
3.) Siobhan Magnus
4.) Michael Lynche
5.) Casey James
6.) Tim Urban
7.) Aaron Kelly

Going Home: I have done a terrible job picking the eliminees this season, so I am sure I'll get this wrong, too. But based on vocals last night, I'd have to say Aaron Kelly will get the boot. He just has not stepped it up the past three weeks when he absolutely needed to, even delivering mediocre, karaoke-type performances. Tim Urban is definitely a lock for the bottom three but I don't foresee his journey ending quite yet. And don't be surprised to see Casey James in the bottom three, but he still has a strong-enough fanbase that should keep him in this for a week or two longer.

Wednesday, April 14, 2010

American Idol 9 - Top 9 (again)

It's top nine week again! Last week brought a potentially shocking elimination when Michael Lynche received the least amount of votes. However, the judges used the power of the save and allowed Michael to return once again. Will Michael ultimately win the competition this season? Likely not. But hey, this season is filled with mediocrity - so why not use it to save Michael? He's been one of the most consistent performers week in and week out. The only individuals I think you might look at needing the save are Crystal and Lee. But they have such strong fanbases, I don't think they'll be in danger for awhile yet. As for this week, the theme is songs by Elvis Presley. And who better to mentor the contestants on Elvis songs than a showman himself, Adam Lambert. Let's see how the contestants fared this week:

Crystal Bowersox - "Saved" : I don't think Crystal has been quite on her "A" game the past few weeks, although she's still been one of the best performers all along. This week she picks a lesser-known Elvis track which I think is smart on her part. Adam Lambert gives her the advice of using the electric guitar over the acoustic. We'll see how that pays off. And I must say, this is the best Crystal has sounded in awhile. Her performance was powerful and you could definitely tell she injected a gospel feel into it. I didn't notice a whole lot of the electric guitar during the performance, but that didn't matter to me. Another excellent performance by Crystal. A great way to start the night on.

Andrew Garcia - "Hound Dog" : So Andrew's up next and I feel he's fallen back to mediocrity after having one decent week since moving past Hollywood Week into the Top 24. And despite his mediocrity, he still hangs around. He was awfully close to going home last week, though. This week it was once again, another less-than-inspiring performance. I don't care if Andrew "has fun" with his performances, you also have to sing well and make a memorable impression to the audience. His rendition of "Hound Dog" once again felt loungy to me. The slowed-down arrangement did not help and it still felt rather boring to me. His vocals were ok, but it shouldn't be enough to save him this week. I think it's his time to go.

Tim Urban - "Can't Help Falling in Love" : So instead of expecting Andrew or Katie to start doing well in this competition, it's actually Tim that's gradually improved week after week. One thing is for sure, he's definitely more comfortable performing when he has a guitar with him. And although he's not the greatest vocalist in the competition (probably the weakest, even), he's learned to sing the songs on key and to change up the arrangement of songs just enough to make them his own. He did exactly that with "Can't Help Falling in Love." He certainly has developed a strategy and as long as he follows that strategy, he'll outlast a lot of the mediocre performers. Another solid week for Tim once again.

Lee Dewyze - "A Little Less Conversation" : Here we have a song that's been done on Idol quite a bit, yet with Lee's interpretation of the song this week, he changed it up very nicely and basically turned it into a completely different song. I actually thought it was a big improvement over last week, as I was not a fan of his "Hey Jude" rendition (with bagpipes and all!). Someone in the blog world mentioned that Lee kind of screwed up the lyrics during the chorus once - but I really didn't notice until looking back and I'm sure the majority of people watching didn't notice, either. I do think that Lee shouted the song an awful lot and the performance would've been that much better if he toned it down just a bit. But still, it was very good.

Aaron Kelly - "Blue Suede Shoes" : Aaron has struggled a bit as of late and its definitely showed in the results - Aaron was in last week's bottom three, although he was the first announced safe before Andrew and Big Mike. Aaron has to be careful of his song choices and start picking smarter. He also needs to perform better. Overall, I'd say he made a good attempt at this week's pick, but it ended up being the wrong song for him. He was moving all over the stage, which was nice to see, even coming up close to Kara at one point. But I think all of that movement kind of through off his vocals. I think he was a bit underwhelming for that particular song and although it wasn't bad, it still wasn't great either.

Siobhan Magnus - "Suspicious Minds" : Siobhan has experienced her own bout of struggles on the Idol stage lately. And it doesn't help that she's been getting conflicting advice from the judges, either. They tell her she shouldn't be using that infamous wail during every performance, yet when he doesn't use it, her performance is regarded as being sleepy. So what will Siobhan do this week? I actually liked it when Adam suggested she pick up the pace of the song, because it worked. She has a tendency to struggle with the lower notes in her register, and that was evident in the first part of the song. I actually think the second half of the song was better than the first, where she really started to ramp the performance up.

Michael Lynche - "In the Ghetto" : Michael definitely did something smart this week. After getting the least amounts of votes last week and being saved by the judges, he performed with an acoustic song and stripped down the arrangement of "In the Ghetto" to the point where the audience could really focus on his vocals. So instead of being flashy, moving all across the stage, and using a variety of hand gestures, he sat still on the Idol stage and performed his song. It was really the right thing to do and his performance was quite beautiful. Sure, you could say it was sleepy but his decision will allow him to stay in this competition a week longer. How embarrassing would it have been to be eliminated this week after getting saved the following week?

Katie Stevens - "Baby What Do You Want Me To Do" : Last week Katie finally lived up to her potential with a strong performance of "Let it Be" and ended up being one of the top performers during Lennon/McCartney week. Let's see if she's able to keep that momentum going. And yet, right from the start, she sounds a bit sharp - not quite matching the pitch that's intended for the song. I actually think she's encountered that problem quite often during her Idol run, except last week it was non-existent. This week it wasn't as bad as it's been, but her vocals weren't perfect. And I don't think this particular song helped her, either. It's one of Elvis' more lesser-known songs and I think Katie does better when she sings ballads over up-tempo songs.

Casey James - "Lawdy Miss Clawdy" : So Casey really picks an old-school Elvis song this week. I certainly wasn't familiar with it and I'm sure many others out there weren't familiar with it, either. Sometimes that's not a negative thing for certain contestants, though. I thought it was a decent performance, but it wasn't all that memorable, either. That's kind of how Casey has performed overall this season. Except for last week where he truly had a moment, he's performed songs exactly how they should be sang, with little changes to the arrangement. He'd really be a great performer in an '80's cover band. Something just felt missing in this performance for me, even though vocally it was quite good.

Top 9 Performance Rankings:
1.) Crystal Bowersox
2.) Lee Dewyze
3.) Michael Lynche
4.) Tim Urban
5.) Siobhan Magnus
6.) Casey James
7.) Katie Stevens
8.) Aaron Kelly
9.) Andrew Garcia

Going home: Andrew Garcia and Aaron Kelly. I think Andrew is definitely a shoo-in to get the boot this week. Of course, how often have I said that this season and he's managed to get through just barely! But with two people going home this week, I really think it's his time. As for the other individual, I really think it's a toss-up between Aaron Kelly and Katie Stevens. However, I think Aaron won't get through beyond this week. Katie is probably still riding some momentum from last week and Aaron has struggled a bit lately.

Wednesday, March 31, 2010

American Idol 9 - Top 10

I want to get outside before I have to go to work today (it's beautiful out!), so the recap of last night's American Idol episode will be rather short. I wasn't even able to watch the episode - instead having to rely on YouTube last night to find clips. I was at work while Idol was on, and then I thought my VCR was set to record correctly. Apparently not! When I went to start watching the episode, it was this season's episode of the Top 10 male performances during the semi-finals. Alex Lambert and Todrick Hall were still in the competition then. Ahhh! So like I said, I resorted to YouTube to catch out on what I missed. Here are my thoughts:

Siobhan Mangus - "Through the Fire" by Chaka Khan : This is definitely Siobhan's weakest performance to date. It just seemed underwhelming to me, plus she was had some off-pitch moments. The song did not to her justice and I think she needs to step back and re-evaluate her strategy going into next week. I thought her usage of the scream at the end of her song not once, but twice was unfortunate and unnecessary. Maybe she felt her performance was falling flat and she resorted to amping things up? Well, it didn't work.

Casey James - "Hold On I'm Coming'" by Sam and Dave : This was probably my favorite performance by Casey to date. He showed a lot more personality, didn't just stand in one spot on that stage, and you could really tell he was having a good time. He is really coming into his own this season and could wind up going quite far. He still needs to work on his stage presence, but it's definitely getting better with each passing week.

Michael Lynche - "Ready for Love" by india.arie : I'm with Kara - I was not familiar with the song at all. However, I know it now and Mike did fantastic this week. He really enunciates his vocals, almost too well at times. But this again showed off his excellent stage presence, this time being close to the center of the audience (and not in front of the judges, strange stage placement but nice to see!). He really connected with the song and showed his softer side. R&B music is definitely in his wheel house.

Didi Benami - "What Becomes of the Broken Hearted" by Jimmy Ruffin : A classic R&B/soul song and it's certainly a good one. Didi had some issues this week - it seemed that by picking this song, it brought back tearful memories of her past (probably involving her friend that passed away - which was mentioned during her audition). And she struggled on stage this week. The song just didn't do her any favors at all as I felt she lacked any connection to it. She was pitchy at times and it was the wrong song for her singing style.

Tim Urban - "Sweet Love" by Anita Baker : Tim has certainly taken his fair share of shots on the Idol Stage since the live shows have started, and rightly so. He's not advancing each week by his singing abilities, that's for sure. You can't honestly tell me Tim was the best choice as a male replacement to make the top 24? I don't know what more I can say of Tim. His performance this week was boring, lacked any excitement, and his singing was just plain flat. He tries, but it's just not good enough.

Andrew Garcia - "Forever" by Chris Brown : The song selection for Andrew this week was definitely an interesting one. A Chris Brown song - and you all know the kind of trouble he's been in most recently? And the song that was featured in Double Mint gum ads! I gotta say, this is the best Andrew has performed in a long, long time. This is the kind of potential we've all been waiting to see from Andrew! He still has some work to do, but he just might have finally turned the corner and is on his way to living up to his front-runner status.

Katie Stevens - "Chain of Fools" by Aretha Franklin : So Katie picks a big song this week and she does a fairly decent job with it. I wouldn't say it was her best by any means, but she's getting there. I agree with the judges that she may have went backwards a bit by choosing an older song. She needs to embrace her youth and pick more contemporary songs where she can. I think she has a tendency to under-sing the notes, too. I noticed a few off-pitch and sharp notes here and there. But she seems to be improving week after week.

Lee Dewyze - "Treat Her Like a Lady" by Cornelius Brothers and Sister Rose : For awhile now, we've been waiting for Lee to have a spectacular, pitch-perfect performance where we can collectively say that it was his best. And finally, this was it. He was confident, he chose a song and re-worked it just enough to fit his style and made it quite enjoyable. Now hopefully, by having a good performance like this, it doesn't make him even more nervous to live up to his front-runner status!

Crystal Bowersox - "Midnight Train to Georgia" by Gladys Knight and the Pips : Just when you think we've seen all that we need to see from Crystal. Even though she did hint at this surprise last week, it was still nice to see and it was a nice change of pace. Actually I think I would've liked it even more if she would've stayed at the piano the whole performance. But yet, we did get to see her perform without the guitar and just holding the mic. It was another great performance from Crystal and it was nice seeing another side of her.

Aaron Kelly - "Ain't No Sunshine" by Bill Whithers : I think there's a great bit of danger involved with Aaron picking this song because Kris Allen performed this it last season and had a moment with it. You know people will be comparing the two performances (just like I'll be doing - HA!). Did it compare favorably to Kris' rendition last year? Not really. But I think he did change it up just enough to make it his own. However, it wasn't his best performance. It seemed like he was struggling to hit the right notes. Kind of a downer-way to end the night.

Top 10 Performance Rankings:
#1: Lee Dewyze
#2: Crystal Bowersox
#3: Michael Lynche
#4: Casey James
#5: Andrew Garcia
#6: Didi Benami
#7: Aaron Kelly
#8: Katie Stevens
#9: Siobhan Magnus
#10: Tim Urban

So who's going to be voted out this week? It's going to be rather tricky deciding who gets sent home. I think the most obvious pick is Tim, but he's got a lot of young girls voting for him so his fanbase might save him yet again. Despite a strong performance this week, I think Andrew still could be in trouble. His lackluster performances up until this point might be enough to eliminate him. Also, I wouldn't be surprised to see Katie wind up in this week's bottom three. And for a shocker, Siobhan might make her first visit to the bottom three. But will she be voted out? I don't think so. As of now, I'm leaning towards Tim Urban as getting eliminated this week.

Wednesday, March 24, 2010

American Idol 9 - Top 11

Here comes another week of reality TV at its best - it's American Idol! You know, ratings for the show this season have gone down compared to last year. Its actually been a gradual slide in ratings for the show since season five. The general consensus is that more people are tuning out due to this season's mediocre talent. I can buy that to an extent, but after nine seasons, a show does get stale. Anyways, we've had our fair share of stars rise out of this reality competition, like Kelly Clarkson, Carrie Underwood, Chris Daughtry, and David Cook. Who's to say season nine won't popularize one or two more nobodies and make them household names. It seems that once you reach the top 12 on Idol, you get to be pretty famous as it is. Oh the power of American Idol! This week we have Miley Cyrus mentoring the contestants (Miley, really?). Oh yes ... she's such a powerful and influential musician these days (sarcasm). Eh, I guess she wasn't a horrible mentor to the contestants. I just would've figured they'd have a mentor with a little more experience in the music industry. And this week's theme? #1 Billboard songs ... ZZZZ. Come on Idol, let's get some better inspiring themes already (I gotta admit, Rolling Stones was quite good last week). On with this week's recap!

Lee Dewyze - "The Letter" by the Boxtops (version by Alex Chilton) : Lee has been gradually improving week after week and it's certainly clear what kind of artist he wants to become. He just needs to become a more polished artist on stage because the nerves are still there. Do you ever notice how often he taps his right foot during a performance? It's usually going faster than the beat of the song! As for this week's performance - it wasn't bad, yet it wasn't great. This isn't the first time we've seen this version of the song performed on stage (going back to that great season seven duet with Michael Johns and Carly Smithson) and Lee does an admirable job with it. I am not overly enthusiastic about it, though and think Lee can do a lot better. He needs to embrace his rock-star persona.

Paige Miles - "Against All Odds" by Phil Collins : Oh brother; here's one song that needs to just go away from the Idol stage forever. I love the original, but its been overdone on the show. And now it's Paige's turn to give it new life. Last week she was dealing with laryngitis and sounded quite good overcoming that obstacle. And she probably picked up quite a few sympathy votes because of it, too. This week she's back to normal (so it appears) yet she sounds worse than ever. Holy cow, she is off pitch. She really struggles with the lower notes in her register and it just sounds awful. The higher notes in the performance were nice but they weren't enough to save this rendition from being a complete train wreck.

Tim Urban - "Crazy Little Thing Called Love" by Queen : To use a famous quote by Simon Cowell, Tim is a "funny little thing," isn't he? So far his Idol journey has been less-than-stellar. His only shining moment has been "Hallelujah" which was such a smart song choice for him because it saved him from being cut that week and it allowed him to advance into the Top 12. Not to say the vocal in that performance was splendid, because it wasn't. But he sang it well just enough and put together a very emotional and pleasant performance. This week again I was bored by his vocals. He doesn't do enough runs and riffs and sings a song plain-Jane. I just don't buy him as being a legit musician. I actually thought he sang the song well, but his vocal abilities are just too boring. And the schtick on stage was just a bit too much. But he knows exactly what he's doing because that performance is going to get him a lot of votes from his fans (teen girls).

Aaron Kelly - "I Don't Want to Miss a Thing" by Aerosmith : It seems throat ailments are going around amongst the Idol contestants lately. Last week it was Paige dealing with laryngitis, this week it's Aaron's turn to struggle with losing his voice (along with tonsillitis). So he chooses a song that, yet again, has been overdone on the show. Can he bring anything new to the song and make it memorable? Taking all things into consideration, he does a decent job with the song. I wouldn't necessarily say it was his best vocal and I think he should get a pass this week because of his throat issues. But he's definitely coming into his own and improving week after week. If he keeps improving, he's got a good shot to go quite far.

Crystal Bowersox - "Me and Bobby McGee" by Janis Joplin : I just had to laugh at the thought of Miley mentoring Crystal this week. Honestly, Miley trying to give advice to an artist that's already a true-professional is just laughable. And I could tell that Crystal had a few negative inner-thoughts whirling around in her head while Miley was trying to be constructive. Crystal is going to do whatever she wants because she's always good! Again, this week was no exception. She's comfortable with who she is and she's not afraid to express her artistic vision. I really enjoyed where the tempo kind of picked up a bit towards the end and she starting jamming out and riffing. It truly was the highlight performance of the night.

Michael Lynche - "When a Man Loves a Woman" by Percy Sledge : Michael took a few steps back last week with the judges when they did not love his more up-tempo performance along with his erratic stage movements. Michael is definitely the strongest when he sings an R&B ballad. He's really able to get into a song and sing to such an emotional level and make it quite powerful. This week he's going back to his most successful roots, a slowed-down R&B ballad. And honestly, it's quite good. Vocally it's spectacular - by far and away the best vocal for a male contestant this week. It's a rare thing to hear off-pitch notes from Michael. I do tend to agree it was a bit on the old fashioned side, but it was definitely one of the better performances of the evening.

Andrew Garcia - "I Heard it Through the Grapevine" by Marvin Gaye : This is a song that my high school choir sang back in the day (and it was a fun song to sing, too). What does that tell ya about Andrew's performance this week? Again, the judges evoked the "Straight Up" cover from Hollywood week - AGAIN. But Simon rightfully made the comment about overrating that particular moment. Honestly, was it REALLY that good? I think it was such a jaw-dropping moment because it was a Paula Abdul song and this was her first season where she's not on the show. And nobody had ever covered a Paula song quite that good during the show's history. Again this week, Andrew's performance just fell flat for me. This clearly shows that he's just a one-trick pony.

Katie Stevens - Big Girls Don't Cry" by Fergie : Okay first of all, big props to Katie for stepping away from the pageanty-dresses she's worn since she's been singing live. Her look this week was miles-away the best that she's looked so far on her Idol journey. Now, for her singing. I liked the song choice as it was current and really helped to embrace her teenage persona. But it still wasn't sung well enough. I thought it started off pretty decent, but once we got into the chorus, it started going off-pitch. And it was also sharp and flat at times. Man, she needs a vocal coach. Yes, it's definitely step in the right direction but she needs to actually sing well for a change. Still plenty of room for improvement.

Casey James - "Powerful Love" by Huey Lewis and the News : One of the biggest surprises this week was seeing this song chosen by a contestant. Don't get me wrong, I really enjoy Huey Lewis and his '80's music, but Idol and Huey Lewis songs just don't match. And yes, we even get a "Back to the Future" mention from Ryan. Casey really tries to rock it out and he does a decent job. Yet, between the goofy grin on his face and his stiff, boring performance style, it just shows he has some work to do to win over the Idol voting public. Vocally it was quite good and this kind of stuff shows what type of artist Casey is going to be. With some of the contestants, we don't know what they are going to do yet. Casey has truly embraced who and what he's all about.

Didi Benami - "You're No Good" by Linda Ronstadt : Between the over-done songs and oldies this week, you'd think we stepped back in time! Only Katie has really delivered on being current this week. Let me just say that last week, I thoroughly enjoyed Didi's Rolling Stone cover of "Play with Fire." I found myself listening to it over and over again. I actually liked it more than Siobhan's cover! This week I am just not digging Didi's song choice. I loved her look on stage, though - YOW! But her vocals were just kind of mediocre during the performance. I just don't think the song suited her unique singer-songwriter style. When she picks the right song, she hits the performance out of the ballpark. But yet, there are times when the song doesn't help her cause like this week.

Siobhan Magnus - "Superstition" By Stevie Wonder : Honestly, how brave is this girl? She has chosen song pretty crazy songs and have done quite well with them. We all know the famous "Think" performance where she hit that incredible note. And now this week, she tackles a Stevie Wonder song (not her first Stevie Wonder song, either - she covered on during Hollywood Week). It's a very upbeat, funky song. She slinks across the stage, from one point to another. I mean, what more can you say? You can definitely tell she had fun with the song. And vocally I thought it was quite good. People are beginning to tire with her frequent use of including those big, shrieky notes at the end of her performances. But that's what makes Siobhan unique! Without it, she'd just be another Katie Stevens or Paige Miles.

Week 11 Performance Rankings:
#1: Crystal Bowersox
#2: Siobhan Magnus
#3: Michael Lynche
#4: Aaron Kelly
#5: Lee Dewyze
#6: Casey James
#7: Didi Benami
#8: Katie Stevens
#9: Tim Urban
#10: Andrew Garcia
#11: Paige Miles

Going Home: I think it's Paige's time to head home. She just has not lived up to the early hype from the judges and delivered one of the worst performances on the Idol stage ever. Her rendition of "Against All Odds" was all over the place. She is not deserving to stay another week and to be on the summer tour because of it.

Wednesday, March 17, 2010

American Idol 9 - Top 12

With the wide-open semi-finals out of the way, the remaining 12 contestants left on the show will now get to deal with regular theme weeks. During the three weeks of semi-finals, they basically got to sing any song they wanted, as long as it placed in the Billboard Charts. But the remaining contestants have reached the latest stepping stone in their progression towards the finale. Obviously two contestants will reach the end of that proverbial road, but each of the remaining 12 need to try and master the latest challenge in their journey. They'll have to deal with singing older songs on a more regular basis, like we have this week with the Rolling Stones. The Rolling Stones have released some epic songs during their careers and hopefully the contestants this week will be able to cover these songs gracefully and won't butcher them too terribly. Let's see how they fared during the tribute to the Rolling Stones.

Michaeal Lynche - "Miss You" : Big Mike is up first this week and he has definitely delivered on strong performances during the semi-finals. He chooses a more up-beat Rolling Stones song which hearkens back to his first semi-final performance where he performed a Maroon 5 song, which wasn't totally embraced by the judges. I get the same reaction from this performance this week. I think he uses the falsetto too much and his on-stage dancing and swaying is a bit off-putting. He almost makes the song too unrecognizable with his dramatic overhaul, trying to give it a more R&B flavor. Don't get me wrong, his vocals were quite good, it's just the overall performance felt too cheesy for me.

Didi Benami - "Play with Fire" : Didi has put together a few consistent performances the past few weeks (even if her cover of "Lean on Me" wasn't as loved by the judges like her previous two - I still thought it was decent). I'm anxious to see how she adjusts to the bigger Idol stage and whether that throws her off or not. I really enjoyed Didi's performance this week. She put together an intense, focused performance of this classic Rolling Stones song. Yes, it wasn't perfect. She messed up the lyrics in a few spots (but recovered nicely in both instances) and she was off-pitch in a few spots (especially on the last note - was that a hiccup?) - but all in all, Didi's performance was highly enjoyable. She is definitely putting up a fight to stay in this competition a long while.

Casey James - "It's All Over Now" : So Casey's run during the semi-finals can be described as being up and down - a bit too inconsistent. He did well the first week, not so well the second, and then delivered a decent, yet forgettable performance during the third week. This week he brings his rock-edge and electric guitar back. It's a strong performance overall, but yet again I find it to be a bit forgettable. I liked that he injected a bit of country twang into the performance (makes sense since he's from Texas) and he put together an upbeat performance. Yet I just didn't feel all that connected to Casey and his performance. And he's just so stiff on that stage that he needs to loosen up. Still, it's an improvement over last week.

Lacey Brown - "Ruby Tuesday" : Lacey picks probably one of the more recognizable Rolling Stones tunes they released. There's no question Lacey has a distinct sound - the trouble is she doesn't know what to do with it (oh yeah, she likes to sing songs that evoke emotion - who doesn't?). Last week was her best of the semi-finals, but she has a long way to go. She tries to make the song her own with some subtle changes. I liked the violin accompaniment throughout the song but some of her phrasing I had issues with. The arrangement of the song wasn't as good as it could've been. Her vocals seemed to struggle a bit with the slower pace of the song, especially in the non-chorus portion of the song. And I didn't enjoy the sped-up "still I'm gonna miss you" portion of the song. Definitely has work to do to improve.

Andrew Garcia - "Gimme Shelter" : I was wondering if the judges would bring up Andrew's "Straight Up" cover from Hollywood Week once again and sure enough, Simon mentioned it. I think it's time to get over that performance because Andrew has not lived up to it since. I think that particular performance and everyone of them since has uncovered Andrew as being a one-trick pony. That's the only performer he knows how to be! Again, Andrew just fell flat for me this week. It was apparently obvious this week that he's trying to switch things up since the semi-finals were an overall disaster. He goes without that acoustic guitar, which we hadn't seen him be without and tries to be more of a rocker. But he struggled staying on pitch and the performance was all over the place.

Katie Stevens - "Wild Horses" : I thought the name of the song sounded familiar, but I just couldn't put my finger on where I had heard it before until Simon mentioned that he recorded it with Susan Boyle. Then it all came back to me. As for Katie, what more can you say? She has struggled to find her identity since Hollywood Week. She's almost a carbon copy of Andrew Garcia, except I don't remember her having that memorable of a performance during Hell Week like Andrew did. I think this week, Katie definitely gets things together and delivers a more admirable performance. Was it spectacular? No. Was it without pitch problems? No. Yet it was a step in the right direction, certainly not as big of a disaster as the semi-finals were for Katie. She still has a lot more work to do, however.

Tim Urban - "Under My Thumb" : I have yet to see a performance from Tim that completely wowed me. Yes, "Hallelujah" last week was good for him, but it certainly wasn't the greatest rendition of the song that I've heard. He has a long way to go if he wants to be as good as some of his female competitors like Siobhan and Crystal. I'd say he's made baby-steps in his overall performance improvement. However, I don't know if I'd call this week's performance of "Under My Thumb" an improvement. Vocally it wasn't too bad. Except the issue I have with Tim is that his singing style is just too plain. He doesn't do enough runs and doesn't take enough risk with his vocals. It's quite clear that is intention is not to win the crown of American Idol, but to make the summer tour. Hopefully he falls short of reaching that goal within the next few weeks.

Siobhan Magnus - "Paint it Black" : It seems to me this isn't the first time "Paint it Black" has been covered on Idol during its nine seasons. But no one has made it as memorable like Siobhan was able to do this week. You can always expect the unexpected with Siobhan and you never know how she's going to interpret the song. I wouldn't say the vocal was totally flawless. And even her big note at the end wasn't as spectacular as it was when she sang "Think." However, the overall feel of the performance changed several different times. At first, it was very slowed down with an almost somber feel. Then the tempo picked up and she gave it almost an emo-feel to it. I felt that the song was set a little too low for Siobhan, one octave higher could've improved it. Still, what imperfections there was were quite minor. Siobhan is a force to be reckoned with.

Lee Dewyze - "Beast of Burden" : At this stage, Lee is probably the strongest male contestant in the top 12. However, that doesn't mean there isn't room for improvement. So far he still hasn't had a vocally flawless performance. And it appears that nerves are still getting the best of him at times (which could be a contributing factor to being off-pitch). If he really wants to make it far, at least through to the top five, he really has to overcome the nerves and own that stage. I'll say that he's making gradual improvements towards reaching that goal. His performance of "Beast of Burden" was actually quite good. I didn't really notice any blaring off-pitch notes. I do agree that I was expecting a bit more out of the performance and that it could be described as being a bit safe.

Paige Miles - "Honky Tonk Woman" : Paige dodged a huge bullet last week when she was declared safe over Katelyn Epperly and moved onto the top 12. She clearly delivered the weakest performance of the top 16, which makes me wonder who was voting for her (she got more votes than Lily, Katelyn, and Alex!). Nonetheless, she gets a reprieve but is dealing with a bout of laryngitis. Apparently she just can't get a break. Considering that her voice wasn't all there, her rendition of "Honky Tonk Woman" was quite good. She was very powerful on those higher notes and yet struggled on those lower notes in the song. Good for her for not trying to play the sympathy card - only until the judges brought it up. She'll likely stay another week just for that and also, she wasn't the worst performer this week, either.

Aaron Kelly - "Angie" : Aaron has not been a fan favorite as of late with his less-than-stellar performances. Obviously the judges selected him to be in the top 24 for a reason - yet we really hadn't seen a reason why yet. His semi-final performances had mixed results - his first week performance was probably his best, and it has trailed off since. So Aaron really needed to deliver this week to get fan support back on his side. And taking everything into consideration, he did exactly what he needed to do. His performance was much more controlled and he didn't over-exert himself on those bigger notes. I'd say he had a lot more success this week than he's had so far during the live shows and if he keeps it up, a lot more people will begin to notice.

Crystal Bowersox - "You Can't Always Get What You Want" : Ah Crystal, the proverbial favorite of this season. Yet, even she realizes that the competition is far from over. And I think she understands that even more after last week's surprising eliminations. Simon has pimped her as being the favorite to win it on "The Tonight Show," but I think at this stage, it's way too early to tell. He's said the same thing about certain constants on previous years, and it hasn't exactly worked out that way. Crystal's performance this week probably wasn't her best that we've seen, but it was still way better than many of the contestants tonight. She's just so comfortable on that stage and knows exactly the kind of artist she wants to be. She can do no wrong.

Top 12 Performance Rankings:

1. Siobhan Magnus
2. Didi Benami
3. Crystal Bowersox
4. Lee Dewyze
5. Aaron Kelly
6. Casey James
7. Paige Miles
8. Michael Lynche
9. Katie Stevens
10. Tim Urban
11. Lacey Brown
12. Andrew Garcia

I think it's finally time for Andrew Garcia to go home. He has not lived up to his Hollywood Week hype and people are getting tired of him doing the same old schtick. He tried reinventing himself this week but it just fell flat. Look for Lacey Brown to end up on the bottom three as and I wouldn't be surprised to see Paige Miles or Tim Urban wind up there, either. But I definitely think it's time for Andrew to go.

Tuesday, March 09, 2010

American Idol 9 - Top 16 (Girls Night)

We have reached the final week of the semi-finals in which we'll see how the top 12 shapes up after results night. So far, I don't totally buy into the early season hype for the girls. I think there are some strong male contenders in the mix, too. But at this stage of the game, there's probably only three stand out performers that could make a run to finale week. So there are plenty of people who need to step up their game. Let's see if there's any surprise performances tonight and whether or not someone has blown their chances. On with the recap!

Katie Stevens - singing "Breakaway" by Kelly Clarkson : Seriously? Another Kelly Clarkson cover? It seems like there have been a bunch in the semi-finals this season (not necessarily from Katie, neither). There are definitely a few off-pitch notes to start and this performance falls flat for me. I don't believe this was the right song for Katie. Going first certainly doesn't help her cause, either. I don't know, it seems as if Katie has fallen quite hard during these semi-finals and she has not lived up to the hype from early on in the show.

Siobhan Magnus - singing "House of the Rising Sun" by the Animals : Another unexpected song choice from Siobhan, but I wouldn't expect anything less from her. She has definitely become one of my favorites this season and she delivers another solid performance. It didn't necessarily have that "wow" moment like last week, but I really loved the accapella start to it. It kind of had an eery, haunting feel with it in the beginning. She definitely embraced the song, made it her own, and really delivered a solid performance.

Lacey Brown - singing "The Story" by Brandi Carlisle : So far, we have yet to see the real reason why Lacey has made it this far in the competition. She has the potential and has embraced a unique look that transfers well to a TV audience. I feel as if the beginning of the performance is a bit underwhelming. She wavers a bit, as if she's nervous and I notice a few off-pitch notes. I'll say this, the song certainly fits her style - probably the best song she's chosen thus far. I don't think she didn't anything remarkable with the song, but it was good overall.

Katelyn Epperly - singing "I Feel the Earth Move" by Carol King : The last couple of weeks, she's had some very strong performances and has proven herself to be a real contender for the girls. Tonight it fell a little flat for me. It was more or less just a bland, safe performance. I was not a big fan of the song as it was basically middle-of-the-road. I liked her "look" tonight, as she stood up playing the piano. But I just thought she played it too safe and just was not wowed by this.

Didi Benami - singing "Rianna" by Fleetwood Mac : Didi had a rough time last week and I felt the judges were rather harsh on her then. How did it turn out this time? The song was a much better choice for her as it suited her style better. I also liked that she played the guitar and accoustically, too. She sang with much more passion and conviction tonight. I think she really wanted to prove that she could come back from such a negative performace from last week. Overall, I thought she sung it very well.

Paige Miles - singing "Smile" by Charlie Chaplin : So far this season, Paige has been stuck at the end or the middle of the pack of this competition for the girls. She needs to pick a song that can make her stand out. Unfortunately she really took two steps back with her song selection. She really goes old school with this "oldie" and does not sound good singing it at all. She's pitchy, flat, and not inspiring in the least. I just didn't find anything nice to say about this performance. I think she just punched her ticket home tonight.

Crystal Bowersox - singing "Give Me One Reason" by Tracy Chapman : First of all, this is one of my favorite songs from the 1990's, so already Crystal is doing great for me. I don't know what else you can say about Crystal that hasn't already been said. She's consistent for one and knows exactly what kind of performer she wants to be. Her vocals were stellar tonight and I really enjoyed her electric guitar playing. She kind of puts Casey James to shame! She's in a class all to her own.

Lilly Scott - singing "I Fall To Pieces" by Patsy Cline : Lilly has been quite consistent in the semi-finals thus far and is a unique artist all her own. I could really see this season coming down to a show-down between the most unique contestants. I was so not expecting to hear a country song from Lilly tonight, so this is quite the surprise for me. I heard a few pitchy notes to start, but then she sang it quite well. I wouldn't necessarily say this was her strongest performance to date, but it wasn't terrible by any means. It was another solid, consistent performance from Lilly.

My favorite performers of the night: Crystal Bowersox, Siobhan Magnus, Didi Benami.

Performances that were so-so: Lacey Brown, Katelyn Epperly, Lilly Scott.

In danger of being voted off: Paige Miles, Katie Stevens.

Going Home: Paige Miles and Katie Stevens. I don't think any of Paige's performances prior to tonight were terrible, just forgettable. She really needed to nail it tonight to solidify her chances of making it into the top 12 and she failed miserably. Her performance was not good at all and I'd be utterly shocked if she advances. She was pretty much cannon fodder from the start, anyways. As for Katie Stevens, she never lived up to the early-season hype. I don't know if she's been mislead by the commentary from the judges, but she's never had a spectacular performance to date. Her chances were seriously damaged by going first and delivering a pitchy and forgettable performance. Again, I'd be shocked if she advanced, but yet Katelyn could be a surprise pick for an early departure, too. But I'm not expecting it.

Thursday, March 04, 2010

American Idol 9 - Top 20 (Girls Night)

After Tuesday's sudden switch to the guys singing, the girls finally get their night to perform. If anything, it allowed the girls a chance to polish their performances even more. Hopefully that extra day helped! It also allowed Crystal to heal up enough to perform. She has proven to be such a bright spot so far, it'd be a shame for her to miss out. I am looking forward to seeing the girls step up over last week. They were the more hyped-up group over the guys leading up to Hollywood Week. Let's see if they can live up to the hype tonight as the performances begin!

Crystal Bowersox - singing "As Long as I See the Light" by Creedence Clearwater Revival : Such a pleasure to see Crystal performing tonight after her recent health scare. This season's competition would've seriously suffered if she ended up being disqualified. Couldn't hardly tell she had been suffering on stage because her performance was absolutely lights out. What a wonderful way to start the show out. She was on pitch, her guitar playing was great, and her singing was perfect. There's no question she'll end up going far (as long as she stays healthy).

Haeley Vaughn - singing "The Climb" by Miley Cyrus : Ah Haeley. I remember her having such a strong audition. Ever since then, it's been pretty much downhill. Honestly, I think the judges thought she had strong potential, which is why they put her through to the top 24. It probably would've been better if she waited a few more years before auditioning. This performance is not good. She's having trouble staying on pitch and she's not really connecting with the song. She really struggles trying to hit the high notes.

Lacey Brown - singing "Kiss Me" by Sixpence None the Richer : So Lacey's journey on Idol can be traced back to last season, when she nearly made it into the top 36 but lost out to Megan Joy in the sing-off. I really like Lacey's look and she has the potential to go quite far if she can put together a decent performance. This week was an improvement over last - yet she still did not deliver a homerun. I liked that it was more of an upbeat song, but her moves on stage were awkward as if she didn't know what to do with herself. More stage experience needed, I think.

Katie Stevens - singing "Put Your Records On" by Corinne Bailey Rae : Apparently Katie has quite the on-line following. Last week she ended up tallying the highest percentage on Dial Idol, even though her performance was average. She has the potential to do a lot better with a more current song in "Put Your Records On." Yet, it's not as spectacular as it could've been. It wasn't perfect by any means as I heard a few off-pitch notes. Again, Katie performs another average performance. Good thing she didn't do worse than some of the others, otherwise she'd be in trouble.

Didi Benami - singing "Lean on Me" by Bill Withers : Didi has a similar singing style to last season's contestant Megan Joy (wow, used her name twice so far). However, I think Didi is a much more polished singer than Megan Joy was at this point in the competition. Last week was a pretty good week for Didi. She's trying to switch things up a bit and perform this Bill Withers song. You know, it's not half-bad. The first part of the song was a bit rough, but I think she pulled things together at the end. The judges over-reacted a bit, I think.

Michelle Delamor - singing "With Arms Wide Open" by Creed : Ah, Michelle is doing the "sing a song originally performed by the opposite gender" trick that often works. Michelle hasn't done enough to really stand out in this season's group so far. I can't even tell you what she sang last week. Hopefully she'll pull through and put together a memorable performance. Overall, it's a decent rendition of "With Arms Wide Open," but I don't think she did enough with it. She changed it up some, but it's not powerful-enough for her. Not totally on pitch, either.

Lilly Scott - singing "A Change is Gonna Come" by Sam Cooke : Lilly is one of those girls this season that we all want to know more about. She is one unique individual, from the way she dresses, her hair, to her singing style. And she is super confident on stage. There's no question she is extremely comfortable on stage; one thing that some of the other girls lack. Her performance this week was absolutely stunning. She knew the song, had a deep connection with it, and sang her heart out. It was definitely enjoyable to watch.

Katelyn Epperly - singing "The Scientist" by Coldplay : Katelyn kind of surprised a lot of people last week with a good performance. She certainly has the potential to advance quite far as long as she can pick the right songs. This week she picks something contemporary - a Coldplay song. Yes, the song was quite slow and a slightly faster tempo could've made it better. However, she was able to put her awesome vocal abilities on display with this tune. Her piano playing was excellent (who knew?!) and her vocals were quite good.

Paige Miles - singing "Walk Away" by Kelly Clarkson : A few of Kelly Clarkson's songs have been covered on Idol this season - and nobody has lived up to the original American Idol so far (this season). Again, Paige is one of those contestants we don't know much about. Her performance last week was rather forgettable - can she be memorable this week? She makes a good effort this time out but yet again, she doesn't do enough to stand out. I kind of agree with Simon that she may have the best vocals out of all the girls this season. Decent, yet forgettable.

Siobhan Magnus - singing "Think" by Aretha Franklin : Siobhan is really taking a huge risk by covering an Aretha song. The judges always warn the contestants about taking on songs by such powerful artists. I must admit, there were some parts in the beginning that were not good, but the later half of the song was stellar. And that last note - wow! This girl has some amazing potential and I love her spaciness. She's so random and interesting at the same time. Siobhan has quickly become one of my favorites of the season.

My favorite performers of the night: Crystal Bowersox, Lilly Scott, Siobhan Magnus, and Katelyn Epperly.

Performances that were so-so: Katie Stevens, Didi Benami, Paige Miles.

In danger of being voted off: Haeley Vaughn, Lacey Brown, Michelle Delamor.

Going Home: Haeley Vaughn and Lacey Brown. Haeley just hasn't sang well enough to stay in this competition any further. She definitely needs additional experience and hopeful Idol proves to be a huge wake-up call for her. Too bad she auditioned this season - a couple of more years may have done her some good. As for Lacey, bad song picks have done her in so far. Her singing isn't exactly where it needs to be, either. If she does get a second chance, hopefully it all comes together for her. After coming so close to advancing into the top 36 last year, I'm sure she doesn't want to get voted out yet.

(3/4/10) Actual Eliminee: Haeley Vaughn and Michelle Delamor. No huge surprise here, particuarly with Haeley's depature. I thought Michelle might be spared one more week before eventually getting the boot. But it appears many voters were not in love with her rendition of "With Arms Wide Open" (and with Creed in general - not a lot of Creed fans out there, I guess!).

Tuesday, February 23, 2010

American Idol 9 - Top 24 (Girls Night)

Welcome to the American Idol live shows! Its been a long time coming, but they have finally returned. We are also going to see how Ellen does during the live performance shows. Overall, I thought she did quite well tonight (and has been doing great since joining the show). Tonight, the girls performed pretty much any song they wanted to sing (it was bascially a billboard top 100 songs-type of night). Some performed older songs, while some went current. All in all, it was a bit of a disappointment overall. A few of the girls picked the wrong song and others just didn't sound very good. However, there were some bright spots. Let's get to the reviews!

(BTW, the reviews at this stage of the game are going to be shorter and I'm not going to focus too long on the write-ups. Either the contestants are memorable or they're not.)

Paige Miles - "Alright Now" by Free : So this is basically the first glance we get of this girl. I don't really remember much of her prior to tonight. I was not totally wowed by this performance. I mean, it was good but it didn't blow me away. She probably could've been helped by a more current song, but please no Alisha Keys, Mariah, or Whitney. She may be hurt by the lack of previous screen time and by going first. We'll see how it all pans out on Thursday.

Ashley Rodriguez - "Happy" by Leona Lewis : I do enjoy the direction she was trying to go with this song (by going current) however, I do agree with the judges that this song was just too big for her. Honestly, by tomorrow this performance will be forgettable (already I'm forgetting how she sang it). It was too sound-alike, she didn't differentiate herself from Leona, and it wasn't sung as well as it could've been. She would've done much better, I believe, with a different song.

Janell Wheeler - "What About Love" by Heart : I really like the original but Janell is not doing well with this selection. This is a big, rocker-chick kind of ballad and Janell doesn't necessarily fill that mold. I liked her Hollywood performance when she sang that Kara Dioguardi song while she played the guitar. I am afraid she tried to go all-out and went too far with this one. Again, it wasn't memorable enough and it was just an average performance. She has potential but this didn't cut it tonight.

Lilly Scott - "Fixin' a Hole" by the Beatles : Finally, someone that breathes new life into tonight's otherwise dull performance show. I enjoy the music from the Beatles but this is one song I'm definitely not familiar with. I swear she could've wrote this song herself and made a hit from it. The very beginning of the song was a bit off for me but then she truly delivers and I'm totally digging her style. She's passionate, soulful, and very fun to listen to. And look, I guess they can play the guitar during the semi's, too!

Katelyn Epperly - "Oh Darlin' " by the Beatles : Another of the Beatles' lesser popular songs, but it's a nice selection by Katelyn. I gotta admit, I follow a lot of Idol sites out there and many didn't think very highly of Katelyn prior to tonight. But I must say she was better than expected. It's probably not a performance we're all going to remember in a week, but it should be enough to get her through. I'd like to see her back playing the guitar like we saw during Hollywood week.

Haeley Vaughn - "I Want to Hold Your Hand" by the Beatles : Wow, why all these Beatle songs tonight (not that there's anything wrong with that, of course)? I like that she distinguishes herself from the original and does an original take on it with guitar in hand. However, she struggles with the higher notes in her upper register. And some of those notes, boy, they were painful to listen to. Not as strong as it could've been. It probably would've been better for her if she waited a year or two before auditioning.

Lacey Brown - "Landslide" by Fleetwood Mac : Another older song pick but hey, oldies are goodies, right? It's a very slow, serious song. I'm just not wowed by it and I noticed a lot of pitchy notes. I feel bad for her because I think she's got some major potential. Seeing how close she was last year to making the semi-finals and then making it this year, I was expecting a lot more. It just wasn't as strong as it could've been and the judges let her know it. She could definitely be in trouble.

Michelle Delamor - "Fallin' " by Alisha Keys : Just as I had feared, someone performing an Alisha Keys' song, particularly this one. In the past, contestants have not fared well performing this one. Michelle does a good job with it but it sounds too much like the original. She doesn't do enough to distinguish herself from Alisha's masterful job with the song. However, I will say that she did enough to stay for another week. She can definitely sing, there's no doubt about that.

Didi Benami - "The Way I Am" by Ingrid Michaelson : I had to laugh when I first heard she was singing this because another contestant sang this song during their audition and Simon hated the song! He had nothing bad to say about the song this time but he certainly wasn't wowed. I got what the judges were saying about Didi's performance but all in all, I thought she did very well compared to most of the previous contestants tonight. I think Didi has the potential to go very far this season.

Siobhan Magnus - "Wicked Game" by Chris Isaak : What an excellent song choice and one that I don't believe any previous contestant has picked before. This song showed that Siobhan has an incredible range. Just look at how low she had to go at the beginning of the song and really went high in the middle and the end. She was definitely in the moment with this performance and it was virtually flawless. Definitely one of my favorites of the night, despite the fact that it's a dark and dreary-kind of song.

Crystal Bowersox - "Hand in my Pocket" by Alanis Morissette : Another song choice I am loving - Alanis really knows how to write some epic songs. And Crystal truly has some staying power in this year's competition. She's an original, she's soulful, and she knows what kind of an artist she wants to be. I remember seeing her play the harmonica during Hollywood and I was blown away then. I, too, am glad to see that Crystal auditioned for American Idol because she has the potential to win the entire show.

Katie Stevens - "Feeling Good" by Michael Buble : Katie has gotten a lot of early hype which has been well deserved. Now that we're into the live shows, will she be able to keep it up? She has the all-important pimp spot tonight which should definitely work to her favor. She does not disappoint but it's probably not as great as it could've been. I do agree with the judges, that even though it's a current song, Buble's kind of music is more old-fashioned. Katie is 17 and we need to remember that.

So, my favorites tonight were: Crystal Bowersox, Siobhan Magnus, Didi Benami, Lilly Scott, and Katelyn Epperly. These five should definitely advance.

Performances that were so-so: Katie Stevens, Michelle Delamor, Paige Miles, Janell Wheeler. They weren't great, but they weren't terrible. These girls should be safe.

In danger of being voted off: Ashley Rodriguez, Haeley Vaughn, and Lacey Brown. Start to pack your bags tonight, girls.

Going home: Haeley Vaughn and Lacey Brown. Unfortunately Haeley enterted the competition too soon. I think she would've been better off waiting a few more years. As for Lacey, it just wasn't her night. However, during these semi-final rounds, usually there's a surprise or two. One of these girls just might be safe. But as of now, these are my predictions.

That is all, folks. I'll probably be able to blog during most of tomorrow night's show when the boys perform, but I will not be able to finish. Be sure to catch the rest of tomorrow's blog the follow day.

(2/25/10) Actual Eliminees: Ashley Rodriguez and Janell Wheeler. Not totally surprised by this outcome, although I thought Janell would've been saved by the voters because of her good looks. It was all for naught this time, however.

Friday, February 19, 2010

American Idol - Season 9 Preview

Finally, after a lengthy and painstaking journey in the crazy American Idol journey, the American public will soon be allowed to vote for their favorites starting next week. I have begun to loathe the audition rounds because they are drawn out rediculously long. I honestly believe they could have two or three weeks of audition episodes, then two weeks featuring Hollywood week, then start the Top 24 competition. But that's just my opinion and I know there are several people out there who enjoy the auditions and the bad singers more than the competition-portion of the show itself. So far, I don't really have my eye on a clear favorite to win this year's American Idol title. A strong contender at this stage is Andrew Garcia, who performed an amazing rendition of Paula Abdul's big 1980's hit "Straight Up" in his first performance during Hollywood week. Unlike the past few years, this year features a strong contingent of girls. It'll be interesting to see if a girl prevails this year afterall. At this stage of the game, things can quickly change.

I was also happy to hear earlier in the winter when it was announced that the show was going back to its more traditional Top 24 format as opposed to last season's Top 36. So many talented individuals were cut too soon last year. For everyone involved during season eight's semi-finals, it was a one-and-done process. All everyone got was one performance and if they did enough to impress the American voting public, they advanced to the Top 12 (which became the Top 13 after the wildcard show). That means there'll be no wildcard, in which the judges pick the last three contestants, and there'll likely be no judge's save this year. To be honest, the judge's save was not used at the right time during last season's competition. Ultimately, they used the save on Matt Girad, who pretty much was already past his prime on the show. The judges should've used the save on Alexis Grace right off the bat. But I can see why they waited to use the save and not use it on Alexis so early on. But the gimmick of the save is just that, a gimmick. It's better off being just a one-season thing because although it produced a nice moment last season, the surprise of a shocking elimination helps make American Idol what it is. And maybe we'll have a return to that this season.

Other contestants who I like at the top of my head include Crystal Bowersox. And what a cool last name, by the way. She's very bluesy, soulful, and does an impressive job playing the harmonica and guitar. She really stood out during Hollywood week. I also really liked Didi Benami and her performances during Hollywood week. She's basically performing for her best friend who tragically died way too young. At this stage for the girls, there are a lot of blondes and many of them play the guitar. So it's kind of difficult to keep track of who's who. However, once we get to the semi-final performances, I think it'll be quite easy to pick them all out. Right now all we're basing our opinion on these contestants are from short snippets of their auditions and during Hollywood week. As for the guys, I've already mentioned Andrew Garcia as being a front-runner. A couple of the other guys who may be strong contenders are Casey James and Aaron Kelly. I am sure Casey is going to have a big following because he took off his shirt to bare his chest to America during his audition. And he's not a bad singer, either. He actually proved to be quite impressive, especially with his guitar-playing skills. Now as for Aaron, he'll likely get the tween and young teenage girl vote because he's only 16. So far I haven't been completely blown away by his singing, and he did have difficulty remembering some of the words of a song during Hollywood week. But he's definitely had some strong moments and I'd be shocked if he didn't make the Top 12.

So there you have it; a short preview of the upcoming American Idol season. Who knows, this season may prove to be the strongest yet. However, for me, nothing can beat the excitement I felt during season seven, when David Cook beat David Archuleta for the title. We may experience something along those very same lines this season - except it's two girls vying for the title of American Idol. This may be the most wide-open field of contestants we've ever had for the show heading into the Top 24. Even last year, Danny Gokey and Adam Lambert were front-runners heading into the Top 36, and look how far they went. Really, only Andrew Garcia is the only one whom I consider a front-runner. You never know how this season will play out. After all, that's why American Idol is the most popular show in America. It's truly unpredictable!