Here comes another week of reality TV at its best - it's American Idol! You know, ratings for the show this season have gone down compared to last year. Its actually been a gradual slide in ratings for the show since season five. The general consensus is that more people are tuning out due to this season's mediocre talent. I can buy that to an extent, but after nine seasons, a show does get stale. Anyways, we've had our fair share of stars rise out of this reality competition, like Kelly Clarkson, Carrie Underwood, Chris Daughtry, and David Cook. Who's to say season nine won't popularize one or two more nobodies and make them household names. It seems that once you reach the top 12 on Idol, you get to be pretty famous as it is. Oh the power of American Idol! This week we have Miley Cyrus mentoring the contestants (Miley, really?). Oh yes ... she's such a powerful and influential musician these days (sarcasm). Eh, I guess she wasn't a horrible mentor to the contestants. I just would've figured they'd have a mentor with a little more experience in the music industry. And this week's theme? #1 Billboard songs ... ZZZZ. Come on Idol, let's get some better inspiring themes already (I gotta admit, Rolling Stones was quite good last week). On with this week's recap!
Lee Dewyze - "The Letter" by the Boxtops (version by Alex Chilton) : Lee has been gradually improving week after week and it's certainly clear what kind of artist he wants to become. He just needs to become a more polished artist on stage because the nerves are still there. Do you ever notice how often he taps his right foot during a performance? It's usually going faster than the beat of the song! As for this week's performance - it wasn't bad, yet it wasn't great. This isn't the first time we've seen this version of the song performed on stage (going back to that great season seven duet with Michael Johns and Carly Smithson) and Lee does an admirable job with it. I am not overly enthusiastic about it, though and think Lee can do a lot better. He needs to embrace his rock-star persona.
Paige Miles - "Against All Odds" by Phil Collins : Oh brother; here's one song that needs to just go away from the Idol stage forever. I love the original, but its been overdone on the show. And now it's Paige's turn to give it new life. Last week she was dealing with laryngitis and sounded quite good overcoming that obstacle. And she probably picked up quite a few sympathy votes because of it, too. This week she's back to normal (so it appears) yet she sounds worse than ever. Holy cow, she is off pitch. She really struggles with the lower notes in her register and it just sounds awful. The higher notes in the performance were nice but they weren't enough to save this rendition from being a complete train wreck.
Tim Urban - "Crazy Little Thing Called Love" by Queen : To use a famous quote by Simon Cowell, Tim is a "funny little thing," isn't he? So far his Idol journey has been less-than-stellar. His only shining moment has been "Hallelujah" which was such a smart song choice for him because it saved him from being cut that week and it allowed him to advance into the Top 12. Not to say the vocal in that performance was splendid, because it wasn't. But he sang it well just enough and put together a very emotional and pleasant performance. This week again I was bored by his vocals. He doesn't do enough runs and riffs and sings a song plain-Jane. I just don't buy him as being a legit musician. I actually thought he sang the song well, but his vocal abilities are just too boring. And the schtick on stage was just a bit too much. But he knows exactly what he's doing because that performance is going to get him a lot of votes from his fans (teen girls).
Aaron Kelly - "I Don't Want to Miss a Thing" by Aerosmith : It seems throat ailments are going around amongst the Idol contestants lately. Last week it was Paige dealing with laryngitis, this week it's Aaron's turn to struggle with losing his voice (along with tonsillitis). So he chooses a song that, yet again, has been overdone on the show. Can he bring anything new to the song and make it memorable? Taking all things into consideration, he does a decent job with the song. I wouldn't necessarily say it was his best vocal and I think he should get a pass this week because of his throat issues. But he's definitely coming into his own and improving week after week. If he keeps improving, he's got a good shot to go quite far.
Crystal Bowersox - "Me and Bobby McGee" by Janis Joplin : I just had to laugh at the thought of Miley mentoring Crystal this week. Honestly, Miley trying to give advice to an artist that's already a true-professional is just laughable. And I could tell that Crystal had a few negative inner-thoughts whirling around in her head while Miley was trying to be constructive. Crystal is going to do whatever she wants because she's always good! Again, this week was no exception. She's comfortable with who she is and she's not afraid to express her artistic vision. I really enjoyed where the tempo kind of picked up a bit towards the end and she starting jamming out and riffing. It truly was the highlight performance of the night.
Michael Lynche - "When a Man Loves a Woman" by Percy Sledge : Michael took a few steps back last week with the judges when they did not love his more up-tempo performance along with his erratic stage movements. Michael is definitely the strongest when he sings an R&B ballad. He's really able to get into a song and sing to such an emotional level and make it quite powerful. This week he's going back to his most successful roots, a slowed-down R&B ballad. And honestly, it's quite good. Vocally it's spectacular - by far and away the best vocal for a male contestant this week. It's a rare thing to hear off-pitch notes from Michael. I do tend to agree it was a bit on the old fashioned side, but it was definitely one of the better performances of the evening.
Andrew Garcia - "I Heard it Through the Grapevine" by Marvin Gaye : This is a song that my high school choir sang back in the day (and it was a fun song to sing, too). What does that tell ya about Andrew's performance this week? Again, the judges evoked the "Straight Up" cover from Hollywood week - AGAIN. But Simon rightfully made the comment about overrating that particular moment. Honestly, was it REALLY that good? I think it was such a jaw-dropping moment because it was a Paula Abdul song and this was her first season where she's not on the show. And nobody had ever covered a Paula song quite that good during the show's history. Again this week, Andrew's performance just fell flat for me. This clearly shows that he's just a one-trick pony.
Katie Stevens - Big Girls Don't Cry" by Fergie : Okay first of all, big props to Katie for stepping away from the pageanty-dresses she's worn since she's been singing live. Her look this week was miles-away the best that she's looked so far on her Idol journey. Now, for her singing. I liked the song choice as it was current and really helped to embrace her teenage persona. But it still wasn't sung well enough. I thought it started off pretty decent, but once we got into the chorus, it started going off-pitch. And it was also sharp and flat at times. Man, she needs a vocal coach. Yes, it's definitely step in the right direction but she needs to actually sing well for a change. Still plenty of room for improvement.
Casey James - "Powerful Love" by Huey Lewis and the News : One of the biggest surprises this week was seeing this song chosen by a contestant. Don't get me wrong, I really enjoy Huey Lewis and his '80's music, but Idol and Huey Lewis songs just don't match. And yes, we even get a "Back to the Future" mention from Ryan. Casey really tries to rock it out and he does a decent job. Yet, between the goofy grin on his face and his stiff, boring performance style, it just shows he has some work to do to win over the Idol voting public. Vocally it was quite good and this kind of stuff shows what type of artist Casey is going to be. With some of the contestants, we don't know what they are going to do yet. Casey has truly embraced who and what he's all about.
Didi Benami - "You're No Good" by Linda Ronstadt : Between the over-done songs and oldies this week, you'd think we stepped back in time! Only Katie has really delivered on being current this week. Let me just say that last week, I thoroughly enjoyed Didi's Rolling Stone cover of "Play with Fire." I found myself listening to it over and over again. I actually liked it more than Siobhan's cover! This week I am just not digging Didi's song choice. I loved her look on stage, though - YOW! But her vocals were just kind of mediocre during the performance. I just don't think the song suited her unique singer-songwriter style. When she picks the right song, she hits the performance out of the ballpark. But yet, there are times when the song doesn't help her cause like this week.
Siobhan Magnus - "Superstition" By Stevie Wonder : Honestly, how brave is this girl? She has chosen song pretty crazy songs and have done quite well with them. We all know the famous "Think" performance where she hit that incredible note. And now this week, she tackles a Stevie Wonder song (not her first Stevie Wonder song, either - she covered on during Hollywood Week). It's a very upbeat, funky song. She slinks across the stage, from one point to another. I mean, what more can you say? You can definitely tell she had fun with the song. And vocally I thought it was quite good. People are beginning to tire with her frequent use of including those big, shrieky notes at the end of her performances. But that's what makes Siobhan unique! Without it, she'd just be another Katie Stevens or Paige Miles.
Week 11 Performance Rankings:
#1: Crystal Bowersox
#2: Siobhan Magnus
#3: Michael Lynche
#4: Aaron Kelly
#5: Lee Dewyze
#6: Casey James
#7: Didi Benami
#8: Katie Stevens
#9: Tim Urban
#10: Andrew Garcia
#11: Paige Miles
Going Home: I think it's Paige's time to head home. She just has not lived up to the early hype from the judges and delivered one of the worst performances on the Idol stage ever. Her rendition of "Against All Odds" was all over the place. She is not deserving to stay another week and to be on the summer tour because of it.
Showing posts with label top 11. Show all posts
Showing posts with label top 11. Show all posts
Wednesday, March 24, 2010
Wednesday, March 18, 2009
American Idol 8 - Top 11
It's time to get out your cowboy hat and boots and celebrate country music on American Idol this week! More specifically, the songs featured on this week's Idol come from artists who belong to the coveted Grand Ole Opry. This week also is the first of the mentor weeks as Randy Travis gives his advice about each of the contestant's songs. There isn't a huge amount of recent country artists included in the Grand Old Opry, from what I understand. So the contestants have a choice of picking songs that go way back to the Country-Western times. Somehow I don't think they want to be classified as being too "old-fashioned" either. Seeing that Carrie Underwood is a member of the Grand Old Opry, how much you wanna bet that we'll be seeing one or two of her songs featured by this week's contestants? I guess we'll find out.Michael Sarver - "Ain't Goin' Down Til the Sun Comes Up" : Country seems to fit Michael well even though he's made comments previously that it's not the kind of music he wants to sing. It's a very fast, upbeat country song. He appears extremely comfortable on stage singing this song, even interacting with the audience. Michael does a nice effort with this performance. It involved plenty of risk especially with a song that moves as fast as this; it could've been very easy for him to stumble and forget a lyric or two. It was a good performance, but not spectacular. Agreed with Randy in that it didn't show off his vocal abilities like it could've.
Allison Iraheta - "Blame it on Your Heart" : A very rock-country type of song for Allison. I am not familiar with this song but I am going to assume the original does not have this much of a rock flair to it. Allison infused her own rock edge to it and it fit her personality to a T. She plays to her strengths and does a nice job. She is having lots of fun; seems very comfortable moving around on stage. I do think that her lack of a large fan base may end up hurting her at this stage of the competition. She's been a solid performer, but typically the American audience doesn't embrace a female rocker like Allison.
Kris Allen - "To Make You Feel My Love" : Kris is going without his guitar tonight which I think is a very good move. I always feel that by mixing it up week after week, it shows off more variety. Kris shows a very vulnerable side to him with this performance. I think he's been getting better and better with each week. I tend to agree that he's probably better at singing ballads than more of the up-tempo songs. I could really feel his connection that he had with this song and he's definitely doing the right things to stay in this competition.
Lil Rounds - "Independence Day" : I thought the low notes in the early part of the song were too low for Lil and she struggled a bit there. She tried singing a straight country song and I don't think it quite fit her. She certainly could've included a more R' n B edge to the song and probably would've had much better success with it. I don't agree that a different song (such as Randy's suggestion of "I Will Always Love You) would've done Lil any better either. The performance definitely got much better in the later half of the song where she was able to hit those power notes like she usually does. This week certainly wasn't as strong as Lil has been.
Adam Lambert - "Ring of Fire" : I can empathize with Randy Travis in how he was speechless over Adam. I mean, what can you really say about this? It started out very intense. It almost seemed as if I was watching a Broadway rendition of this classic Johnny Cash song. He starts to infuse his usual vocal dynamics into the song once the tempo picks up. This whole performance has a very different sound to it; no question it has more of a middle eastern flair to it. I can say I've never seen anything like it on American Idol. Honestly, this is supposed to be country week, right? One thing you can say about Adam is that he is entertaining.
Scott MacIntyre - "Wild Angels" : I can tell Scott enjoys picking songs that tell a message. Again as I've said before, Scott isn't the most dynamic singer during this season of Idol - but he definitely holds his own. He struggled more with the lower notes in this song. I would tend to agree that he shouldn't always be playing the piano during his live performances but then again, he's not going to be moving steadily across the stage without it, either. He's doing what he feels is most comfortable to him. The falsetto note towards the end of the song wasn't great. Overall, I'd say it was a good performance from Scott, but not great.
Alexis Grace - "Jolene" : It will be interesting to see how Alexis pulls this one out. We're used to seeing her sing rock songs with a harder edge. "Jolene" is more of a softer tune and Alexis even said she wanted to show that side of her. I don't entirely believe it was the right song choice for this particular week. Overall, she struggles a bit with the song and is off-tune throughout. The arrangement just wasn't as favorable for her to be successful this week, either. Basically, it was just an okay performance and actually was quite forgettable. A rare off week for Alexis so far in the competition.
Danny Gokey - "Jesus Take The Wheel" : There's always a certain risk to choosing a song that has been created by a former Idol. I think a different song would've suited Danny better, especially one that wasn't so low or bland to start. The front part of the song just sounded awkward to me; even though that's how it's supposed to sound. Of course be rebounded well with the later half of the song once the tempo picked up and he was able to get into his upper register. That is typical of Danny's performances there. He's a very likable guy, but this week he was just good for me, not great.
Anoop Desai - "You Were Always on My Mind" : Anoop goes the Kris Allen route and performs a softer, vulnerable ballad. It's a perfect song choice because it allows Anoop to show off his vocal talents. He is definitely much improved over the last couple of weeks. He doesn't go over board with the song and holds back more. It was definitely a much more controlled performance and he doesn't try to do too much with it. It was very well done and it's nice to see him get such great reviews from the judges. Another very likable guy.
Megan Joy - "Walking After Midnight" : We have absolutely no idea that Megan has been sick this week except after her performance is over when she starts coughing. I don't know what more you can say about Megan that hasn't already been said. The judges say time and time again that she's quirky and unique. That about sums up this performance. It was the perfect song choice for Megan and she delivered on that unique sound of hers. She made the song her own and certainly made it much more memorable. And actually, it was a lot better than I thought it was going to be.
Matt Giraud - "So Small" : Whenever I think of Matt, I just can't get his Coldplay performance out of my head. He has been severely damaged because of that and hopefully as we move further along in the competition, that performance in particular can be all but a memory. He is a super-talented guy and there's no question he belongs in this competition. He does a very impressive job with this Carrie Underwood song. He is a true consummate musician - I think he nailed this song tonight and it proved to be a very memorable performance.
So how did the contestants fair? Here is tonight's performance rankings:
1.) Matt Giraud
2.) Anoop Desai
3.) Kris Allen
4.) Allison Iraheta
5.) Adam Lambert
6.) Danny Gokey
7.) Megan Joy
8.) Michael Sarver
9.) Lil Rounds
10.) Alexis Grace (actual eliminee 3/19/09)
11.) Scott MacIntyre
CODES:
best of the night
in danger of being eliminated
As for who will be eliminated tonight - now that is a very tough call. Even though I've had a very tough time connecting with every one of the contestants this year, they are all extremely talented. I thought these last couple of weeks have been very strong, vocal-wise. In my opinion, the top six in this week's performance rankings are a lock and in no risk of going home anytime soon. Adam, Anoop, and Danny have such huge fan bases. Allison has been consistently strong each and every week even though her fan base isn't quite as big as the three guys mentioned. Kris Allen has been improving with each week and is quickly becoming a fan favorite. And then there's Matt Giraud who we know is an amazing musician. He stumbled pretty seriously after his Coldplay performance but quickly picked himself back up and is making a strong push towards the later stages of this competition.
Now as for the bottom five of the performance rankings, the only one that could be considered a pretty sure lock to stay in this competition for a long time is Lil Rounds. She, too, has a pretty strong fan base. Megan, Michael, and Scott are basically just cannon fodder. It'll only be a matter of time before they get eliminated. As for Alexis, she also has a relatively small fan base and one weak performance like this week's could leave her in serious danger. That is why I am picking Alexis Grace to be this week's eliminated contestant on American Idol. I know, it's a mild-shocker seeing how well she has done in prior weeks. But does anyone see her outlasting Adam, Danny, Anoop, or Matt? The males truly are the stronger of the gender this season and the only female contestant that stands a chance to last awhile is Lil, and maybe Allison, too. It could be a very, very interesting results show tonight. Don't miss it!
(UPDATE: Sad to say, but I ended up being right - Alexis is eliminated. It is never easy, especially someone with her talent. Only one sub-par performance was all it took for her to be booted off. I am disappointed she is gone, to say the least.)
Tuesday, March 18, 2008
American Idol 7 - Top 11
It's a new week which brings us to the latest American Idol recap from me! It's another week of songs by the Beatles (but it appears they expanded the songbook to include Ringo and George this week). So there's definitely some good songs left for the contestants to choose from in the vast array of #1's the Beatles had. I will say this, though; even though I absolutely love the songs by the Beatles, maybe two weeks in a row is a bit much. I don't care how much positive feedback they've heard from the fans of the show about it. It's just something that can get stale fast. We'll see how the contestants handle another week of songs by the Beatles. Let's get this show on the road!
Amanda Overmyer - singing "Back in the USSR": Amanda's up first tonight - usually not the place any contestant wants to be placed in. Another rock song for Amanda (yawn). Okay, so it's not that bad, but as Simon mentioned tonight, it was pretty predictable. She keeps doing the same rock performance week in and week out and it's beginning to seem like a broken record. She's a good performer and is very consistent. She knows how to pick songs that fit her mold but it may be starting to get a bit old for the fans. You can definitely say one thing about Amanda, however; she knows how to have a good time on stage.
Kristy Lee Cook - singing "You've got to Hide Your Love Away": This is such a great Beatles tune; one of my favorites, in fact. I did not care for the arrangement with Kristy's version, however. It was actually really odd and seemed to have more of a rock-edge with it. Eddie Vedder re-made the song and knew enough not to mess with something great. Kristy tried messing with the arrangement and it just didn't work. Overall I thought she did a decent job with the song but the problem I am having with her is that she's rather forgettable. The last note of the song that Kristy sang was nice, but that was about all that was memorable with it. She could've done a lot better with the song, that's for sure.
David Archuleta - singing "The Long and Winding Road": With last weeks performance clearly in the back of my mind, I was pretty nervous for David A. I really wanted him to have a great week. And I am happy to say, he delivered. Now this is the David we all remember from week's past. This was a great song choice for him as I believe he does his best when singing the slower tempo songs which allows him to concetrate on the lyrics better. He remembered his lyrics this time around, he was on pitch the whole time and it was very enjoyable to listen to. He even received across-the-board praise from the judges with Simon even calling it "master class." Clearly it was the best performance of the night out of all the contestants. If he stays consistent with performances like tonight, he'll definitely be one of the final two contestants left standing when all is said and done (if not the eventual American Idol winner).
Michael Johns - singing "A Day in the Life": I don't know what's going on with Michael as of late, but he definitely hasn't been living up to the expectations that he brought with him during Hollywood week. His version of Bohemian Rhapsody was so great that I often look it up on YouTube just to hear it again. Tonight's peformance was very lackluster right from the start. With his first attempt at a higher note, he went way off pitch. After that, he really couldn't recover. I thought he performed the song like the Beatles sang it and didn't really do much different with it. The pace of the song was pretty slow, then picked up briefly, but went back to being slow. I thought the song was going to suit him well but it certainly ended up being not his best. There were definite arrangement issues with the song and he really needs to start raising his game up pretty fast.
Brooke White - singing "Here Comes the Sun": Another performance where Brooke doesn't perform an instrument. It worked the other time when she just sang; will it work this time? Well, not as well, according to the judges. She probably wasn't quite as connected with the song as she was with "Let it Be." It appeared she was having the time of her life up on stage; moving and dancing around pretty freely. Certainly a very upbeat song for Brooke; something we hadn't yet seen from her (something like tonight's performance, anyways). Yet, she seemed out of her element in some way. Overall it was rather safe, vocally; but performance-wise she did try some new things. I have a pretty good suspicion that'll she'll go back to being behind a guitar or piano next week.
David Cook - singing "Day Tripper": And here we have David going back to what he does best; playing the guitar. He stays true to his roots which is rather nice. And unlike Amanda, David isn't afraid to try different things even though he's mainly a rocker. All of the risks that David has taken thus far have paid off. I did like the Peter Frampton-esque use of the voice box; it was certainly different and the first time used in an "Idol" performance. He did a great job with the song that had the audience into it and even Paula up on her feet. I like the fact that each and every single week, he seems to try something different and it hasn't yet hurt him. I had to disagree with Simon when he said it was predictable. Now Amanda, yes; she was predictable. David Cook was not.
Carly Smithson - singing "Blackbird": A much slower paced song for Carly; going in a different direction tonight. I didn't think it was her best as I perfer the more up-beat songs from her. But the vocals were spot-on as usual. I liked the performance the best when she started hitting the higher notes which showed off her vocal skills. I wouldn't say it was my favorite of hers in the competition but it was still an enjoyable performance. I thought it was definitely better in the end than it was in the beginning. It was a very controlled song for Carly with superb vocals and a deep connection with the song. Carly definitely knows what she's doing and I believe she'll be around for a long time.
Jason Castro - singing "Michelle": So Jason goes without the guitar tonight which worked before when he sang "Halleljah." He seemed to do a fairly decent job with the song, but he appeared out of touch at times. I have a feeling, though, that he wasn't really taking the performance all that seriously. In fact, I thought at one point he almost lost control and started laughing. Maybe it was the audience that threw him off but he certainly did not seem as connected to the song. I thought it was a good song choice for him if only he took the performance seriously. I hope he didn't think it was a big joke because his fans could turn on him pretty fast. I don't really believe that's going to happen, but he really needs to be more careful in the future.
Syesha Mercado - singing "Yesterday": Out of all the Beatles songs, this is probably one of my all-time favorites (including Let it Be, Hey Jude, Penny Lane, and You've Got to Hide Your Love Away). Syesha starts things off kind of boring and I am beginning to question whether this is really a good choice of song for her, whether or not she had a connection with it in the past. But she definitely worked it out in the end and think she did an admiral job with it. The problem with Syesha, however, is that she's a pretty forgettable performer. Yes, this week was much better than last, but I just don't see her sticking around for very long. She just doesn't appear to be all that interesting and that is what really hurts her. She's got to do something that's going to wow the audience and make us remember her for a very long time. So far, that has yet to happen.
Chikezie - singing "I've Just Seen a Face": This is an unfamiliar Beatle tune for me. It appears that Chikezie turns back to performing a ballad which tends to suit him more. The pace starts off rather slow but then really picks up. In fact, I thought the pace was much too fast and it reminded me a lot of Kristy Lee's version of "Eight Days a Week" from last week. The last part of the song had that country/blue grass feel to it which wasn't necessarily a good thing, in my opinion. I thought Chikezie tried capitalizing on last week's success and it didn't quite work as well. It was still a decent performance yet it wasn't as good as last week. It was sort of all over the place like the judges mentioned, harmonica and all.
Ramiele Malubay - singing "I Should've Known Better": The performance started off pretty weak and somewhat pitchy for me. I do think this is a great song choice for Ramiele, however. It doesn't start off all that great, though and she seems to be having some difficulty projecting her voice. She has a great voice and can hit some pretty incredible notes. We haven't seen anything like that in awhile from her, though. She did finally hit a couple of high notes towards the end of the performance but it wasn't enough for me. She did have better vocals tonight but I definitely think she needs to be more assertive and confident with her songs. Ramiele has been lacking consistency for some time and pretty soon it will end up hurting her.
Now it's time for this week's Idol Rankings. Remember, these are based on tonight's performances and they are not cumulative from week to week. I think most of the contestants will be relieved to see the songs of the Beatles go away next week. In addition, Simon only gave favorable reviews to David Archuleta and Syesha (even though he told Syesha that Brooke should've sang "Yesterday"). And did anyone else notice how some of the contestants were wearing ear pieces while others didn't? This probably helped David A. out quite considerably compared to last week where he didn't wear one. I think with the audience standing up and cheering like in a concert setting, it tends to throw the contestants off especially for those not used to concerts. So this is probably a good thing for everyone involved. Anyways, here are the rankings from tonight:
#1: David Archuleta
#2: David Cook
#3: Carly Smithson (actual bottom three - 3/19/08)
#4: Syesha Mercado - bottom three
#5: Jason Castro
#6: Brooke White
#7: Amanda Overmyer (officially eliminated - 3/19/08)
#8: Ramiele Malubay
#9: Chikezie
#10: Michael Johns - bottom three
#11: Kristy Lee Cook - eliminated (actual bottom three - 3/19/08)
All in all, I still believe it's Kristy Lee's time to go. Even though this week was better than last, it still doesn't compare with the rest of the group. I thought she was pretty fortunate to stick around instead of David Hernandez because she was really awful last week. We'll see if she maintains the same luck this time around. I also believe that Syesha remains a pretty forgettable figure on the show and despite a decent performance this week; she'll wind up in this week's bottom three again. It just doesn't seem like she has an avid fanbase like the rest of the contestants and one of these weeks, it's going to cost her.
Amanda Overmyer - singing "Back in the USSR": Amanda's up first tonight - usually not the place any contestant wants to be placed in. Another rock song for Amanda (yawn). Okay, so it's not that bad, but as Simon mentioned tonight, it was pretty predictable. She keeps doing the same rock performance week in and week out and it's beginning to seem like a broken record. She's a good performer and is very consistent. She knows how to pick songs that fit her mold but it may be starting to get a bit old for the fans. You can definitely say one thing about Amanda, however; she knows how to have a good time on stage.
Kristy Lee Cook - singing "You've got to Hide Your Love Away": This is such a great Beatles tune; one of my favorites, in fact. I did not care for the arrangement with Kristy's version, however. It was actually really odd and seemed to have more of a rock-edge with it. Eddie Vedder re-made the song and knew enough not to mess with something great. Kristy tried messing with the arrangement and it just didn't work. Overall I thought she did a decent job with the song but the problem I am having with her is that she's rather forgettable. The last note of the song that Kristy sang was nice, but that was about all that was memorable with it. She could've done a lot better with the song, that's for sure.
David Archuleta - singing "The Long and Winding Road": With last weeks performance clearly in the back of my mind, I was pretty nervous for David A. I really wanted him to have a great week. And I am happy to say, he delivered. Now this is the David we all remember from week's past. This was a great song choice for him as I believe he does his best when singing the slower tempo songs which allows him to concetrate on the lyrics better. He remembered his lyrics this time around, he was on pitch the whole time and it was very enjoyable to listen to. He even received across-the-board praise from the judges with Simon even calling it "master class." Clearly it was the best performance of the night out of all the contestants. If he stays consistent with performances like tonight, he'll definitely be one of the final two contestants left standing when all is said and done (if not the eventual American Idol winner).
Michael Johns - singing "A Day in the Life": I don't know what's going on with Michael as of late, but he definitely hasn't been living up to the expectations that he brought with him during Hollywood week. His version of Bohemian Rhapsody was so great that I often look it up on YouTube just to hear it again. Tonight's peformance was very lackluster right from the start. With his first attempt at a higher note, he went way off pitch. After that, he really couldn't recover. I thought he performed the song like the Beatles sang it and didn't really do much different with it. The pace of the song was pretty slow, then picked up briefly, but went back to being slow. I thought the song was going to suit him well but it certainly ended up being not his best. There were definite arrangement issues with the song and he really needs to start raising his game up pretty fast.
Brooke White - singing "Here Comes the Sun": Another performance where Brooke doesn't perform an instrument. It worked the other time when she just sang; will it work this time? Well, not as well, according to the judges. She probably wasn't quite as connected with the song as she was with "Let it Be." It appeared she was having the time of her life up on stage; moving and dancing around pretty freely. Certainly a very upbeat song for Brooke; something we hadn't yet seen from her (something like tonight's performance, anyways). Yet, she seemed out of her element in some way. Overall it was rather safe, vocally; but performance-wise she did try some new things. I have a pretty good suspicion that'll she'll go back to being behind a guitar or piano next week.
David Cook - singing "Day Tripper": And here we have David going back to what he does best; playing the guitar. He stays true to his roots which is rather nice. And unlike Amanda, David isn't afraid to try different things even though he's mainly a rocker. All of the risks that David has taken thus far have paid off. I did like the Peter Frampton-esque use of the voice box; it was certainly different and the first time used in an "Idol" performance. He did a great job with the song that had the audience into it and even Paula up on her feet. I like the fact that each and every single week, he seems to try something different and it hasn't yet hurt him. I had to disagree with Simon when he said it was predictable. Now Amanda, yes; she was predictable. David Cook was not.
Carly Smithson - singing "Blackbird": A much slower paced song for Carly; going in a different direction tonight. I didn't think it was her best as I perfer the more up-beat songs from her. But the vocals were spot-on as usual. I liked the performance the best when she started hitting the higher notes which showed off her vocal skills. I wouldn't say it was my favorite of hers in the competition but it was still an enjoyable performance. I thought it was definitely better in the end than it was in the beginning. It was a very controlled song for Carly with superb vocals and a deep connection with the song. Carly definitely knows what she's doing and I believe she'll be around for a long time.
Jason Castro - singing "Michelle": So Jason goes without the guitar tonight which worked before when he sang "Halleljah." He seemed to do a fairly decent job with the song, but he appeared out of touch at times. I have a feeling, though, that he wasn't really taking the performance all that seriously. In fact, I thought at one point he almost lost control and started laughing. Maybe it was the audience that threw him off but he certainly did not seem as connected to the song. I thought it was a good song choice for him if only he took the performance seriously. I hope he didn't think it was a big joke because his fans could turn on him pretty fast. I don't really believe that's going to happen, but he really needs to be more careful in the future.
Syesha Mercado - singing "Yesterday": Out of all the Beatles songs, this is probably one of my all-time favorites (including Let it Be, Hey Jude, Penny Lane, and You've Got to Hide Your Love Away). Syesha starts things off kind of boring and I am beginning to question whether this is really a good choice of song for her, whether or not she had a connection with it in the past. But she definitely worked it out in the end and think she did an admiral job with it. The problem with Syesha, however, is that she's a pretty forgettable performer. Yes, this week was much better than last, but I just don't see her sticking around for very long. She just doesn't appear to be all that interesting and that is what really hurts her. She's got to do something that's going to wow the audience and make us remember her for a very long time. So far, that has yet to happen.
Chikezie - singing "I've Just Seen a Face": This is an unfamiliar Beatle tune for me. It appears that Chikezie turns back to performing a ballad which tends to suit him more. The pace starts off rather slow but then really picks up. In fact, I thought the pace was much too fast and it reminded me a lot of Kristy Lee's version of "Eight Days a Week" from last week. The last part of the song had that country/blue grass feel to it which wasn't necessarily a good thing, in my opinion. I thought Chikezie tried capitalizing on last week's success and it didn't quite work as well. It was still a decent performance yet it wasn't as good as last week. It was sort of all over the place like the judges mentioned, harmonica and all.
Ramiele Malubay - singing "I Should've Known Better": The performance started off pretty weak and somewhat pitchy for me. I do think this is a great song choice for Ramiele, however. It doesn't start off all that great, though and she seems to be having some difficulty projecting her voice. She has a great voice and can hit some pretty incredible notes. We haven't seen anything like that in awhile from her, though. She did finally hit a couple of high notes towards the end of the performance but it wasn't enough for me. She did have better vocals tonight but I definitely think she needs to be more assertive and confident with her songs. Ramiele has been lacking consistency for some time and pretty soon it will end up hurting her.
Now it's time for this week's Idol Rankings. Remember, these are based on tonight's performances and they are not cumulative from week to week. I think most of the contestants will be relieved to see the songs of the Beatles go away next week. In addition, Simon only gave favorable reviews to David Archuleta and Syesha (even though he told Syesha that Brooke should've sang "Yesterday"). And did anyone else notice how some of the contestants were wearing ear pieces while others didn't? This probably helped David A. out quite considerably compared to last week where he didn't wear one. I think with the audience standing up and cheering like in a concert setting, it tends to throw the contestants off especially for those not used to concerts. So this is probably a good thing for everyone involved. Anyways, here are the rankings from tonight:
#1: David Archuleta
#2: David Cook
#3: Carly Smithson (actual bottom three - 3/19/08)
#4: Syesha Mercado - bottom three
#5: Jason Castro
#6: Brooke White
#7: Amanda Overmyer (officially eliminated - 3/19/08)
#8: Ramiele Malubay
#9: Chikezie
#10: Michael Johns - bottom three
#11: Kristy Lee Cook - eliminated (actual bottom three - 3/19/08)
All in all, I still believe it's Kristy Lee's time to go. Even though this week was better than last, it still doesn't compare with the rest of the group. I thought she was pretty fortunate to stick around instead of David Hernandez because she was really awful last week. We'll see if she maintains the same luck this time around. I also believe that Syesha remains a pretty forgettable figure on the show and despite a decent performance this week; she'll wind up in this week's bottom three again. It just doesn't seem like she has an avid fanbase like the rest of the contestants and one of these weeks, it's going to cost her.
Tuesday, March 20, 2007
American Idol Top 11
It's another week, and now that I am feeling much better, it's time for a full recap of this evening's two-hour American Idol! This week's theme was songs from the British Invasion. A lot of these songs seemed to be new to many of the contestants but I can tell you one thing, I knew a majority of them myself, since I grew up listening to a lot of oldies songs (all thanks to my parents).
Regarding last week, it was no surprise that Brandon was voted off. He struggled for quite a few weeks and I think him forgetting the words was the final nail in the coffin. That does not mean he was worse than Sanjaya, because he wasn't. But for some reason, Sanjaya is just so popular. A lot of people are saying it's because of his hair; other speculation is that he's getting votes because of the website votefortheworst.com. Hopefully one of these times, he'll be out.
Here's tonight's recap:
Haley Scarnato sings Vonda Shephard's "Tell Him." I actually enjoyed her performance and thought she did a decent job. She looked very sexy and she proved that she can sing (and remembered the words to the song). Definitely not a forgettable performance and I've got to believe she will get a lot of votes from the male contingent. This week: safe
Chris Richardson sang a nice rendition of the song "Don't Let the Sun Get You Crying" by Gerry and the Pacemakers. He gets major props from the judges and I think he deserves it this week. This song was definitely more low key than some of the previous songs he's done and it worked well for him. He showed he can mix it up with his song selections and that's always a good thing. This week: safe
Stephanie Edwards sings a Dusty Springfield hit, "You Don't Have to Say You Love Me." I think she does a decent job, but it's certainly not a memorable performance. I think Stephanie has lost her edge some in recent weeks and has become a middle-of-the-pack performer. I think she runs the risk of being in this week's bottom three by this performance; yet I don't think she'll be out. This week: possibly bottom three
Blake Lewis performs a Zombies' classic in "Time of the Season." He's probably my favorite male performer and is very talented. His beat-boxing works well in just about every song he sings and it's no different with tonight's performance. Just as the judges commented, he turned a 40-year old song into something contemporary and could be a hit on today's radio. He'll be sticking around for awhile. This week: safe
Lakisha Jones sings "Diamonds are Forever" by Shirley Bassey. For me, I thought it was just an average performance by Lakisha this week. I did not care much for the song and thought it was kind of weird. I think Lakisha did an admiral job in making the song listenable. Lakisha was more toned down this week and although it worked last week, it wasn't so good this time around and I think the song contributed to that. Even though it wasn't her best performance, she's not going anywhere. This week: safe
Phil Stacey performs The Nashville Teens' hit "Tobacco Road" from the 1960's. Phil tries to be a rocker this week and it did not work at all for me. Certain people can pull it off, but I think Phil should try to stay away from rock songs. I really think he should've toned it down. After a nice performance last week, Phil will be once again in danger of being in the bottom three and eliminated from the competition (unless by some miracle, Sanjaya actually gets voted out this week). This week: in serious danger
Jordin Sparks sings "I Who Have Nothing" by Terry Knight and the Pack. Jordin is really rising to the occasion in this competition and it was another stellar night for her. Again, this was not a favorite song choice for me personally, but I think Jordin did an amazing job with it and made it easy to listen to. Simon commented that this was a depressing song, but it wasn't so bad for me. I think she's a serious contender for the finals and with performances like this, she will be in it to win it. This week: safe
Sanjaya Malakar performs the song "You Really Got Me" by the Kinks. As Randy and Paula commented, it was an improvement over previous weeks and he did break out of his shell more. However, it wasn't much of an improvement and was still quite weak. All he basically did was more shouting and a lot of his notes were still off the mark. He's got to do a lot better and he still has not proven he is worthy in this competition. This week: should be gone
Gina Glocksen sings the Rolling Stones' classic "Paint it Black." Personally, I thought it wasn't too bad and I was rocking out with her. But that was probably because it's such a well-known song covered by one of the greatest Rock n Roll bands of all time. True, some of the notes were off but she was having a blast singing the song. She's a favorite of mine, but I'll agree that it wasn't one of her stronger performances. This week: possibly bottom three
Chris Sligh performs "She's Not There," another classic by the Zombies. Another decent performance by Chris and you had to enjoy the way he moved throughout the theatre; first going through the audience, then going up on the podium behind the judges, and then finishing the song up on stage. Although I think Chris is more of a middle-of-the-pack singer, he's enjoyable to listen to. This week: safe
Melinda Doolittle sings "As Long as He Needs Me," another song credited by Shirley Bassey and one from the musical "Oliver." Melinda once again brings it home and although it started off rather slow, she really notched it up in the middle and end. She continues to shine and there's still no doubt in my mind that she is the favorite. I think with Lakisha faltering a bit this week, this raises Melinda up even more. This week: definitely safe
That wraps it up for this week. If the voting goes the way it should, Phil or Sanjaya will be gone. However, you can never be too sure with this show.
Regarding last week, it was no surprise that Brandon was voted off. He struggled for quite a few weeks and I think him forgetting the words was the final nail in the coffin. That does not mean he was worse than Sanjaya, because he wasn't. But for some reason, Sanjaya is just so popular. A lot of people are saying it's because of his hair; other speculation is that he's getting votes because of the website votefortheworst.com. Hopefully one of these times, he'll be out.
Here's tonight's recap:
Haley Scarnato sings Vonda Shephard's "Tell Him." I actually enjoyed her performance and thought she did a decent job. She looked very sexy and she proved that she can sing (and remembered the words to the song). Definitely not a forgettable performance and I've got to believe she will get a lot of votes from the male contingent. This week: safe
Chris Richardson sang a nice rendition of the song "Don't Let the Sun Get You Crying" by Gerry and the Pacemakers. He gets major props from the judges and I think he deserves it this week. This song was definitely more low key than some of the previous songs he's done and it worked well for him. He showed he can mix it up with his song selections and that's always a good thing. This week: safe
Stephanie Edwards sings a Dusty Springfield hit, "You Don't Have to Say You Love Me." I think she does a decent job, but it's certainly not a memorable performance. I think Stephanie has lost her edge some in recent weeks and has become a middle-of-the-pack performer. I think she runs the risk of being in this week's bottom three by this performance; yet I don't think she'll be out. This week: possibly bottom three
Blake Lewis performs a Zombies' classic in "Time of the Season." He's probably my favorite male performer and is very talented. His beat-boxing works well in just about every song he sings and it's no different with tonight's performance. Just as the judges commented, he turned a 40-year old song into something contemporary and could be a hit on today's radio. He'll be sticking around for awhile. This week: safe
Lakisha Jones sings "Diamonds are Forever" by Shirley Bassey. For me, I thought it was just an average performance by Lakisha this week. I did not care much for the song and thought it was kind of weird. I think Lakisha did an admiral job in making the song listenable. Lakisha was more toned down this week and although it worked last week, it wasn't so good this time around and I think the song contributed to that. Even though it wasn't her best performance, she's not going anywhere. This week: safe
Phil Stacey performs The Nashville Teens' hit "Tobacco Road" from the 1960's. Phil tries to be a rocker this week and it did not work at all for me. Certain people can pull it off, but I think Phil should try to stay away from rock songs. I really think he should've toned it down. After a nice performance last week, Phil will be once again in danger of being in the bottom three and eliminated from the competition (unless by some miracle, Sanjaya actually gets voted out this week). This week: in serious danger
Jordin Sparks sings "I Who Have Nothing" by Terry Knight and the Pack. Jordin is really rising to the occasion in this competition and it was another stellar night for her. Again, this was not a favorite song choice for me personally, but I think Jordin did an amazing job with it and made it easy to listen to. Simon commented that this was a depressing song, but it wasn't so bad for me. I think she's a serious contender for the finals and with performances like this, she will be in it to win it. This week: safe
Sanjaya Malakar performs the song "You Really Got Me" by the Kinks. As Randy and Paula commented, it was an improvement over previous weeks and he did break out of his shell more. However, it wasn't much of an improvement and was still quite weak. All he basically did was more shouting and a lot of his notes were still off the mark. He's got to do a lot better and he still has not proven he is worthy in this competition. This week: should be gone
Gina Glocksen sings the Rolling Stones' classic "Paint it Black." Personally, I thought it wasn't too bad and I was rocking out with her. But that was probably because it's such a well-known song covered by one of the greatest Rock n Roll bands of all time. True, some of the notes were off but she was having a blast singing the song. She's a favorite of mine, but I'll agree that it wasn't one of her stronger performances. This week: possibly bottom three
Chris Sligh performs "She's Not There," another classic by the Zombies. Another decent performance by Chris and you had to enjoy the way he moved throughout the theatre; first going through the audience, then going up on the podium behind the judges, and then finishing the song up on stage. Although I think Chris is more of a middle-of-the-pack singer, he's enjoyable to listen to. This week: safe
Melinda Doolittle sings "As Long as He Needs Me," another song credited by Shirley Bassey and one from the musical "Oliver." Melinda once again brings it home and although it started off rather slow, she really notched it up in the middle and end. She continues to shine and there's still no doubt in my mind that she is the favorite. I think with Lakisha faltering a bit this week, this raises Melinda up even more. This week: definitely safe
That wraps it up for this week. If the voting goes the way it should, Phil or Sanjaya will be gone. However, you can never be too sure with this show.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)